Five Nights at Freddy’s Review: No Horror Fan’s Piece of Pizza

Few recent video game franchises have embedded themselves in pop culture quite like Five Nights at Freddy’s. The indie point-and-click horror series exploded onto the scene in 2014, thanks largely to viral gameplay videos showcasing its nerve-shredding jump scares. Players took on the role of a night security guard trapped inside an abandoned Chuck E. Cheese-style restaurant, where the creepy animatronic mascots come to life after hours. Through masterful minimalist design choices that left gamers feeling helpless, Five Nights earned a cult following that ballooned into unfathomable fandom.

Given the runaway success and hungry fanbase, a film adaptation seemed inevitable. With the franchise’s creator Scott Cawthon producing alongside horror hitmaker Blumhouse Productions, Five Nights finally lumbered its way to the big screen in 2023. But successfully translating the intimate, repetitive scares of the games to a 90-minute feature would prove challenging. Does the movie capture the same hair-raising magic within Freddy Fazbear’s garishly neon halls? Or does it botch the recipe like an overcooked jerk chicken pizza?

In this review, we’ll assess whether Five Nights at Freddy’s does justice to its gaming roots. We’ll analyze how it adapts the source material, expands on the lore, and conjures up old-school robotic terror for a new audience. As fans hungry for more Freddy, or total newcomers drawn by the creepy trailers, is this fright flick worth your time and money? Does it live up to the addictive terror of the games, or feel like a lazy cash-grab? We’ll study the ingredients carefully to determine if this pizza delivers fresh fun or just reheats stale leftovers. Strap on your security helmet, and let’s see if this Five Nights survives until 6 AM.

A Bear-y Traumatic Homecoming at Freddy’s

In the film, we follow Mike Schmidt (Josh Hutcherson), a down-on-his-luck security guard struggling with repressed childhood trauma. As a boy, Mike witnessed his younger brother get kidnapped at a park while under his watch. The unsolved disappearance still haunts Mike’s dreams decades later. After a mall mishap where Mike pummels an innocent man he mistakes for a kidnapper, the hot-tempered guard finds himself out of a job and options.

With custody of his little sister Abby on the line, Mike reluctantly takes an overnight position watching the long-shuttered Freddy Fazbear’s Pizza. The Chuck E. Cheese-style family fun center once boasted singing animatronic mascots as its main attraction. Now, its neon-lit halls sit empty, air thick with mold, dust, and mystery. It doesn’t stay quiet for long once Mike settles into his first shift. Lumbering to life at midnight, the furry robot band – Freddy Fazbear and friends – prove startlingly lively on their creaky limbs.

As Mike scrambles to evade the clunky-yet-crafty bots roaming the restaurant past hours, his repressed memories also begin bubbling to the surface. Are the robots connected to the traumatic history of missing kids that still scars this place? Also snooping around after hours is Vanessa (Elizabeth Lail), a local cop whose persistence suggests she knows more about Freddy’s shadowy past than she lets on.

With clues tying the pizzeria to his brother’s vanishing, Mike’s nightly cat-and-mouse game escalates beyond just surviving his shift. His sister Abby even becomes part of the robot animals’ sinister agenda, evident through her unsettling sketches of their party. As Mike unravels buried secrets of the pizzeria after dark, protecting Abby from both the bots and their custody-contesting aunt becomes intertwined. The horrors of Mike’s own childhood memories merge with the present-day robotic threat that comes to life once the parents and kids leave this twisted den of faux-family entertainment.

To solve the mysteries of Freddy’s, save his sister, and overcome past trauma, Mike will have to tamp down his temper and outsmart the wily robotic creatures who roam these halls after the staff and families clear out. Will he make it to morning without getting shoved into an animatronic suit or will the buried secrets of this pizzeria finally claim another victim? As Mike soon learns, this derelict restaurant has even more horrors lurking within than those furry singing bots stalking its darkened dining area.

• Also Read: Life on Our Planet Review: Freeman’s Narration Anchors an Uneven Paleontological Doc

Freddy’s Execution Fails to Deliver on Scares

One of the biggest challenges adapting Five Nights at Freddy’s is translating the minimalist scares of the game into a full-length feature. Unfortunately, the film’s execution consistently misses the mark in balancing tone and expanding the simple premise. The result is a disjointed mix of lackluster horror and melodrama.

The biggest problem lies in the script overloaded with ponderous backstories distracting from the core horror. Mike’s traumatic childhood and custody battle drama feel like filler outweighing the Freddy’s mystery. The film strains to be a serious exploration of trauma rather than delivering the killer animatronic concept’s inherent fun. Every moment outside the pizza restaurant drags momentum to a screeching halt.

Even the scenes inside Freddy Fazbear’s lack the tight, oppressive atmosphere that made the games so chilling. The horror set pieces feel rushed and perfunctory, failing to ratchet up tension. The bots’ jump scares lack surprise, while their limited screen time reduces them to minor nuisances rather than unrelenting threats.

Part of the issue is the bland creature design that renders the robots more goofy than creepy. The costumes lack the eerie quality of old animatronics that so effectively tapped into childhood nostalgia gone warped. While visually faithful to the games, Freddy and friends feel generic rather than uncanny. The scant violence further neuters any sense of danger.

Most of the cast struggle amidst the muddled script. Josh Hutcherson strains to make the thinly sketched Mike compelling, while Elizabeth Lail is saddled with explanatory dialogue as the exposition-spewing cop. Supporting characters like Mike’s sister and aunt blend together due to lack of development. The actors’ efforts can’t override the one-dimensional roles.

Stylistically, Five Nights at Freddy’s never commits to a tone. It lacks the primal scares of films like It or The Conjuring that successfully translated horror games into movies. The story similarly never taps into childhood fantasy and imagination ala Night at the Museum. Fun nods to ‘80s nostalgia and haunting animatronic visuals are outweighed by the drab plotting.

Overall, the film’s uneven execution continuously undercuts its horror potential. The few moments of creepiness and visual flair get smothered by the muddy scripting and thinly spread runtime. While admirably ambitious in scope, the end result feels both overstuffed yet undercooked. Like the bland pizza at Freddy’s, it’s flavorless without enough sauce or cheese in the right places. This Freddy adaptation needed sharper writing and direction to become greater than the sum of its parts. The ingredients were there, but the execution leaves you hungry for scares.

Freddy’s Film Forgets Its Gaming Roots

When adapting a beloved property like Five Nights at Freddy’s, faithfulness to the source material is key. Yet the film takes ample liberties that abandon the spirit of the games. While the visual aesthetics evoke the franchise, the expanded storylines and muted horror tone down the elements that made the games so distinct.

Visually, the Freddy animatronics and restaurant design capture the vintage pizza parlor aesthetic. Seeing the characters realized as clunky physical robots has novelty appeal. But the creatures feel generic compared to their memorably eerie computer-generated counterparts from the games. Their conversion into literal flesh-and-blood monsters demystifies their menace.

The biggest betrayal comes from dismissing the games’ pervasive atmosphere of mystery and minimalist storytelling. The creeping sense of the unknown is what allowed players’ imaginations to run wild. By over-explaining the lore and backstories, the film loses touch with the cryptic nature that spawned endless fan theories.

This expanded focus is most evident in the new prominent themes of trauma and family drama which overwhelm the core horror. The game quickly immersed players in survival tension; the film meanders through heavy-handed character subplots which mute the frights. While perhaps attempting to give the premise emotional weight, they sap momentum.

The film further strays with its PG-13 restraint. The games utilized implication and intelligent design to craft scares. The movie instead relies on jump shocks and chases unsuitable for younger viewers anyway. Aiming for a wider audience dilutes the inherent creep factor.

While movie adaptations inevitably require creative liberties, the best honor a property’s essence. Five Nights at Freddy’s tweaks the template in ways that disregard the elements that made it effective. It takes the mysterious animatronic concept and over-explains it while diagnosing the villainy through tragic backstories. An overt bid at mainstream appeal waters down precisely what made audiences hungry for more Freddy in the first place – the nightmarish ambiguity. Like the sterile restaurant devoid of kids and life, the film captures the superficial appearance but misses the soul.

Heavy Themes Weigh Down Freddy’s Fright Potential

On the surface, Five Nights at Freddy’s taps into the common horror trope of corrupted childhood innocence. The creepy animatronics twisting a pizza party into nightmare fuel makes for solid scary movie fodder. However, the film also attempts to graft weightier themes of trauma and commerce onto the killer robot concept – with mixed results.

The most prominent theme expanded from the games is trauma haunting Mike’s adulthood. His unresolved childhood memories intertwine with the robotic threat. While an ambitious narrative angle, depicting the lasting impacts of tragedy risks over-empathizing with the villains. By diagnosing the source of horror as past trauma, it also demystifies the frights on display.

The film’s extended focus on Mike’s custody battle further distracts from the core appeal. Time devoted to exploring the lingering effects of family trauma detracts from time spent bringing the homicidal robots to life. While well-intentioned, the somber tone weighs down the story instead of enhancing it.

Less prominently, the film hints at critiquing commerce and multimedia exploitation. The idea of a beloved childhood haven corrupted over time by business interests has resonance. Yet the commentary gets lost amidst the various subplots. As an adaptation meant to launch a film franchise, the satire has a hypocritical edge.

Effective horror explores primal fears through bold, tightly-controlled storytelling. Though admirably thoughtful, Five Nights at Freddy’s mistakes headier themes for substance. Corporate critique and trauma drama clash with the story’s inherent silliness. The outlandish core concept begs for camp and mystery, not solemn backstories.

By attempting to ground its supernatural threat in emotional realism, the film drains the scenario of escapist thrills. The trauma angle aims for depth but requires too great a tonal shift from goofy haunted robots. Not every popular franchise needs multilateral themes to justify itself cinematically. Sometimes, killer animatronic animals can just be killer animatronic animals.

Five Nights at Freddy’s: A Botched Opportunity for Animatronic Mayhem

As both an adaptation and standalone horror flick, Five Nights at Freddy’s shows glimmers of creepy promise but ultimately disappoints. What could have been a culty camp thrill ride gets bogged down by misguided choices that abandon the core appeal of the games. The end result may satisfy neither loyal fans nor horror newbies seeking fresh scares.

On a positive note, the film nails the vintage pizzeria atmosphere and faithfully renders the signature animatronics to life. Their menacingly floppy movements and exaggerated proportions tap into childhood nostalgia turned sinister. First glimpses of the characters lumbering through dimly lit rooms generate intrigue.

Additionally, lead actor Josh Hutcherson commits fully to his portrayal of haunted protagonist Mike despite thin writing. Brief moments harness a playful weirdness, like Matthew Lillard’s eccentric turn as an exuberant career counselor. The parts are greater than their sum.

Unfortunately, the film’s merits end there. The biggest misstep is overstuffing the straightforward premise in a misguided bid for substance. The added focus on trauma, family drama, and childhood abductions smothers the core concept rather than deepening it. Scenes away from Freddy’s continuously kill momentum and tension.

The convoluted plot threads leave minimal room for the horror set pieces to breathe. We spend more time exploring Mike’s psyche than watching him evade monstrous robots. Even the animatronics themselves get shortchanged on terror. Their limited screen presence and neutered jump scares make them fall flat as villains.

For all its faults, Five Nights at Freddy’s perhaps still could have worked as a silly midnight movie had it fully embraced the absurdity. Leaning into over-the-top B-movie camp and schlock could have captured the games’ gonzo spirit. Instead, playing it straight somehow makes it feel even cheaper.

As is, Five Nights feels like a slapdash cash-in on a hot property lacking purpose. It offers neither thoughtful storytelling nor thrilling horror. The filmmakers seemingly lost sight of what draws audiences to either psychological dramas or killer robot capers in the first place. Mashing up both worlds together does no favors for either genre.

In the end, Five Nights at Freddy’s fails to justify its own existence as a film. Even those unfamiliar with the games would likely find this a dull and disjointed effort. For devoted followers of the franchise, it sadly cannot be recommended either. This adaptation could have cleverly remixed the source material for the screen. Instead, like so much stale pizza crust, it is merely stale – full of empty calories and lacking in any animatronic magic or bite.

Also Read:

A Hellish Night Shift Awaits: First Look at ‘Five Nights at Freddy’s’ Trailer A Nostalgic Nod: The Return of Sparky in Five Nights at Freddy’s Film Spooky Success: ‘Five Nights at Freddy’s’ Sets New Viewership Records on Peacock Five Nights At Freddy’s Movie Release Date Announced with a Sneak Peek