Renowned Chinese documentarian Wang Bing has built a career on creating sprawling, hours-long observational films that immerse viewers in the day-to-day realities of his subjects. His latest project, the 3-hour-and-12-minute Youth (Spring), continues this signature approach but to less compelling ends. Filmed over five years in the industrial city of Zhili, the film closely follows several migrant garment workers in their late teens and early 20s as they labor long hours in crowded workshops and dorms.
As the first part of a trilogy, Youth (Spring) provides an unflinching look at the repetitive drudgery and economic uncertainties facing Chinese youth employed in the country’s massive sweatshop economy. However, in excessive devotion to dreary minutiae, Wang’s immersive style starts to feel numbingly monotonous.
The director’s past films used duration purposefully to challenge official narratives or memorialize overlooked histories. Here, the extended runtime dilutes the impact by masking Wang’s political acquiescence to the status quo with a veneer of austerity. While a technical achievement, Youth (Spring) displays Wang’s observational mastery to less resonant effect.
Inside the Monotonous Routine of China’s Sweatshop Economy
Youth (Spring) unfolds primarily in the cramped workshops and spartan dormitories of Zhili City, an industrial hub in eastern China churning out children’s clothing. Wang spent five years immersed in this community, his static camera capturing the repetitiveness of garment work and the workers’ limited lives. The film focuses more on tone and texture than plot or arcs. We follow no single character, instead observing a collective portrait of exploited youth passing time on the factory floor.
Wang’s sequences have a fly-on-the-wall intimacy. The camera weaves between rows of workers at their sewing machines, eavesdropping on chatter and quarrels. The conversations veer from playful banter to grievances over pay. Two young men bicker over thrown spool, sparking a brief brawl quickly broken up. Co-workers flirt and gossip. A heart-wrenching episode follows a pregnant employee pressured to get an abortion. These vignettes reveal the social ecosystem that sprouts in the drudgery.
Most striking are scenes of the workers’ synchronized motions set to pop songs blaring from a radio, evoking a dystopian musical fantasia. The juxtaposition reveals the workers’ latent youthful spirit despite exhaustion and oppression. Wang keenly observes how repetitive manual labor permeates consciousness. The camera focal length barely budges, fixating on hands speedily stitching fabric at machine after machine in sequence. This unending flow induces an almost trance-like effect.
Negotiations with bosses provide rare moments of tension, as we witness the power dynamics surrounding wages. The workshops are family-run, not state-owned, adding a complex human dimension. Yet the owners seem beholden to economic forces beyond their control too. The film’s constrained physical spaces reflect the workers’ lack of autonomy in Zhili’s social hierarchy.
Only in a quiet final sequence do we escape this hermetically sealed world, as Wang follows two workers outside at dusk. They marvel at seeing the moon, a poetic transition hinting at dreams beyond the factory. Yet the parade of identical buildings receding down the street underscores how distant that wider horizon remains. Like the film’s title, the innocence of youth perseveres, yet constrained by forces larger than itself.
The Struggles and Hopes of China’s Next Generation
While the film’s title evokes the innocence of youth, Wang paints a far bleaker picture of stunted potential and unrealized dreams. Yet glimmers of vitality persist amid the drudgery. The workers’ interactions reveal texture within monotonous routine, from camaraderie to simmering tensions. In documenting their incremental actions to assert collective rights, Wang captures China’s next generation striving for agency against systemic exploitation.
On the surface, little differentiates one poorly-lit workshop from the next. But subtle contours emerge through the workers’ idiosyncrasies and dramas. Flirtations kindle, jokes fly, frustrations vent. The periodic disputes over wages lay bare their lack of leverage. We witness the beginnings of solidarity, as they discuss striking for better pay. Their livelihood depends on banding together, though long-shot odds face such grassroots activism.
Wang conveys a sense of their youth being stuck on repeat, of biding time until their vigor fades. Days bleed into nights as workshops morph into dorms. Brief glimpses of “off hours” provide no respite, like a young woman berated in an internet café for being out late. In the film’s cycles, we feel the grind wearing down idealism. Yet the defiance of certain workers hints at an awakening collective conscience.
The harsh exterior glimpsed in nighttime streets reflects the numbing interior life. Demands made of pregnant employees reveal the collision between family obligations and pitiless profit motives. Forced abortions uphold productivity. The workshop boss’s detached edict about workers getting “bitten” and then just “biting back” displays capitalism’s capacity to normalize cruelty. Wang illustrates the myriad ways human aspirations are contorted and stifled.
But the owner’s own problems remind us of the hierarchies above even him. Amid arguing over pennies, we recognize his narrow margins. The workshops of Zhili operate in a nexus of complex socioeconomic forces, seeking loopholes for autonomy. Still, the political system constrains their agency too, despite greater independence from the state.
Youths flock to Zhili out of necessity, not choice. When the camera finally exits the workshop in the closing scene, we feel the characters’ relief like a breath held too long. Yet the ordered rows of buildings receding down the street reimpose limits. The Workers step from one confining interior to another. For all their latent promise, the future offers little more.
“Explore the fragile bonds of a broken family in our Bleeding Love review. Witness the authentic performances of Ewan and Clara McGregor in a drama about addiction, redemption, and the power of reconciliation.”
An Observational Eye Overwhelmed by Duration
Wang Bing’s signature direct-cinema approach operates ambitiously here, if not always successfully. Rather than visual beauty, he focuses on texture and unscripted moments. His static camera avoids imposed narratives, simply presenting candid scenes as they unfold. This observational style can evoke great power through understatement. Yet in Youth (Spring), Wang’s reliance on excessive duration dulls the impact.
Nearly every sequence fixates on repetitive motions and rituals of making clothes. Wang patiently watches workers’ hands swiftly stitch fabric, the camera lens barely wavering. These extended shots consciously reject propulsion in favor of realism. But extended well past the point of revelation, the approach grows tedious. The near-plotless accumulation of mundane moments loses resonance. We gain no deeper insight by the 10th identical shot that we lacked from the first.
This magnification of tedium distances rather than immerses the viewer. Wang offers no characters to latch onto. The camera moves detachedly from one anonymous face to the next. While this refusal to sentimentalize has integrity, it suppresses emotional engagement. Spending three hours peering through a one-way mirror breeds apathy more than empathy.
The few narrative hints Wang provides, like the pregnant worker’s dilemma, get lost in the relentless parade of drudgery. Every glimpsed clue promising drama or change dissolves back into the rote routine. These could be compelling threads if developed; instead they are subsumed by the inexorable sameness.
That said, Wang’s clinical eye effectively conveys the workers’ reality. His use of pop songs is striking, injecting rhythmic vitality into scenes of collective toil. The music contrasts with the storyless fiction of a regime demanding silence. Ultimately though, Wang’s approach confuses duration with purpose. His past films justly used extreme length to restore ignored voices and histories to the historical record. Here the extra runtime simply renders the monotony numbing rather than profound.
Muted Social Critique Reflects China’s Closing Society
Given Wang’s reputation for strongly political films, Youth (Spring) contains surprisingly little overt social commentary or critique. Unlike his early masterworks, which challenged official narratives, this film acquiesces to the status quo. The director’s simplified black-and-white portrayals of capitalist exploitation have given way to more sanitized shades of gray. This softened perspective seems tailored to appeal internationally while dodging censorship back home.
Nowhere does Wang address the broader context of labor rights suppressed by the authoritarian regime. The global economic forces driving the sweatshop industry remain unexamined. Besides light hints of developing class consciousness, no viable path to progress emerges. The critique stops at lamenting hardship without questioning root causes.
Wang argues this is a conscious refusal to impose an agenda, letting life unfold unscripted. But that rings hollow given his past films’ strong advocacy. This detached neutrality feels less like journalistic nonpartisanship than an artistic failure of vision and nerve.
While Wang shows the harsh realities these workers face, he provides glimmers of hope too conventional to convince. The pregnant employee keeping her baby, the modest raise extracted from the boss – these triumphs seem contrived to satisfy rather than convince. They avoid engaging with the system’s deep corruption.
Indeed, such optimism contradicts China’s current social crises, like record youth unemployment under Xi’s authoritarian grip. The film’s muted self-censorship reflects the closing public discourse as dissent gets silenced. Where Wang’s earlier films spoke truth to power, this one resignedly whispers.
Aesthetic achievements aside, Youth (Spring) displays a gifted activist director relinquishing his once-radical perspective for unearned uplift. Wang’s noble goals of memorializing injustice ring hollow without context or culpability. In this repressive era, speaking softly while overlooking truths serves no one.
An Excess of Tedium Weakens a Vital Message
Wang Bing’s latest immersive documentary offers an eye-opening glimpse into the harsh realities facing Chinese youth slaving away in sweatshops. The early sequences vividly convey the texture of this world through intimate fly-on-the-wall observation. However, the film’s excessive devotion to boring minutiae ultimately undermines its provocative power.
Clocking in at over 3 hours, Youth (Spring) displays Wang’s trademark use of duration, but here it serves little purpose beyond a pretense of arthouse austerity. The approach smothers rather than deepens the impact, draining away engagement as the repetitious scenes accumulate. This oppressive tedium masks the director’s apparent political acquiescence, substituting an edgy critique for easy uplift.
Wang remains a skilled technician, evidenced in the film’s striking interplay between scenes of drudgery and musical pop. Yet these immersive flashes shine only fitfully amidst the dreary longueurs. While a worthwhile glimpse into the social realities within China’s sweatshops, Youth (Spring) ranks among this great director’s less resonant efforts. Wang’s singular observational talents could have better served this vital subject matter through a tighter, more purposeful execution. This overindulgent endurance test dulls the necessary revelations of exploited youth awaiting China’s future.
The Review
Youth (Spring)
Though an admirably ambitious undertaking, Wang Bing's latest sprawling documentary proves less illuminating than exhausting. The director's signature immersive style falters under the burden of redundancy and overlength. We gain intimacy but little insight from the relentless tedium. Youth (Spring) offers some striking moments that peek past the monotony. But the film's muddled sociopolitical focus and diluted critique offset Wang's technical mastery. This overindulgent endurance test drains away the power of its necessary message.
PROS
- Offers an intimate, fly-on-the-wall look inside Chinese sweatshops and the lives of migrant garment workers
- Captures the youthful energy and interactions of the workers despite the grueling conditions
- Static camerawork creates an immersive, observational style that puts the focus on the workers
- Evocative use of pop music juxtaposed against scenes of repetitive manual labor
- Moments of humor and humanity shine through the bleakness at times
CONS
- Excessive length (over 3 hours) leads to monotonous and repetitive viewing
- Lacks a strong narrative structure or arc for viewers to follow
- Can feel dull, drained of drama and engagement due to minimal story
- Director's detached approach prevents emotional connection to individual workers
- Surprising lack of strong social commentary or critique of labor issues
- Glimpses of hope seem unrealistic or contrived for uplift
- Runtime not justified like director's past films on ignored histories
