Girls Will Be Girls Review: A Rare Perspective on Indian Womanhood

Mother and Daughter Come Into Their Own in Shuchi Talati's Debut

Set against the backdrop of the Himalayas, Girls Will Be Girls tells the story of 16-year-old Mira, a model student who’s just been named the first female Head Prefect at her strict Indian boarding school. It’s a big responsibility, and Mira takes her role as a leader seriously. That is, until a charismatic new student named Sri arrives and catches her eye. Before long, Mira finds herself navigating the exhilarating but complicated waters of her first romance.

At home, tensions flare between Mira and her mother Anila, who recognizes her daughter’s budding relationship from her own experience at the same school years earlier. Anila tries to allow the young couple supervised time together, but soon finds herself reliving her own repressed adolescence vicariously through her daughter.

As Mira falls deeper in love, she struggles to balance her friends, family duties, and ambitions with her growing passion for Sri. When rumors and scandal threaten Mira’s reputation at school, she’s forced to make difficult choices about who she wants to be.

Girls Will Be Girls tackles universal teenage themes through a uniquely Indian lens, taking an unflinching yet thoughtful look at young women coming of age under a patriarchal system. With strong central performances and wise direction from newcomer Shuchi Talati, it marks the arrival of an exciting new cinematic voice.

Exploring Womanhood in a Patriarchal World

At its heart, Girls Will Be Girls is a coming-of-age story that confronts the unique challenges faced by young women growing up in a patriarchal society.

As Mira explores romance with Sri, she’s embarking on a journey of self-discovery through sexuality that’s considered taboo for Indian girls her age. The film insightfully examines how societal repression robs girls like Mira of the language and means to understand their burgeoning desires.

Yet Mira finds ways to subtly rebel, whether practicing kissing alone in the shower or dancing freely in her room. Through Mira, debut director Shuchi Talati paints an empathetic portrait of a teenage girl claiming ownership of her body and sexuality.

Central to the narrative is Mira’s complicated relationship with her mother Anila. Their tense dynamic seems rooted in Anila’s own repressed upbringing. Having attended the same strict boarding school, Anila recognizes herself in her daughter’s first flirtations.

At times, Anila lives vicariously through Mira’s romance, as if getting a second chance at the adolescent experience she was denied. But Anila also feels protective, wanting to shield Mira from harm and discipline her when she strays too far. This push-and-pull between them is navigated beautifully through knowing glances and charged silences.

Beyond her home life, Mira faces pressure to be a model student as the school’s first female Head Prefect. She’s expected to reprimand other girls for minor infractions even as the boys get away with appalling behavior like taking upskirt photos. Mira quickly learns her authority is meaningless in the face of entrenched sexism.

Through it all, Mira struggles to balance her duties, ambitions, and desires – to be the perfect daughter, student, and young woman everyone expects her to be. But denying her true self takes an emotional toll that builds toward a breaking point.

Girls Will Be Girls immerses us in the whirlwind of Mira’s inner world as she tries to reconcile what she wants with what society tells her she should be. Through Mira’s journey, the film thoughtfully explores the unique challenges of coming-of-age female in a culture that still judges women by a different standard.

“Take to the skies with ‘Masters of the Air’, a gripping aerial drama that brings World War II’s legendary ‘Bloody Hundredth’ bomb group to life. Explore our Masters of the Air Review to experience the thrilling and emotional journey of American bomber crews, masterfully brought to the screen by Steven Spielberg and Tom Hanks. Click here to witness a series that combines stunning visuals, intense action, and deep historical insight.”

Captivating Performances Bring the Characters to Life

The talented young cast of Girls Will Be Girls brings warmth, nuance, and complexity to their characters. In the lead role, Preeti Panigrahi delivers an incredible breakout performance as Mira. With thoughtful subtlety, she captures the innocence, intelligence, and insecurity of a teenage girl navigating immense societal pressures. We feel Mira’s self-doubt and anguish as she’s pulled between conforming to expectations and following her heart.

Girls Will Be Girls Review

As Mira’s mother Anila, Kani Kusruti is simply masterful. She gives a profoundly layered performance, conveying both strength and vulnerability. With just a knowing glance or pause, Kusruti reveals the depth of Anila’s inner conflicts as a mother torn between disciplining her daughter and reliving her own repressed youth.

Kesav Binoy Kiron brings charm and charisma to the role of Sri, Mira’s first love. He walks the line between sincere romance and possible manipulation with compelling nuance. We understand how Mira could fall for Sri’s easy confidence and warm energy, even as his intentions grow more questionable.

Together, the trio share a magnetic chemistry made up of both tender and tense moments. The emotional complexity of their relationships is made utterly believable thanks to the natural, affecting performances. Subtext and history flow between the characters through everything left unspoken.

With their moving performances, the cast of Girls Will Be Girls makes this coming-of-age story resonate on a profound emotional level. They bring honesty, vulnerability, and humanity to a film that captures both the joy and ache of growing up.

“Immerse yourself in the vibrant and authentic world of rural Tunisia with ‘Under the Fig Trees’. Explore our Under the Fig Trees Review to experience a film that beautifully captures the essence of youth, friendship, and the journey towards adulthood. Click here to join the lives of teenagers working in the fig harvest, where their stories unfold amidst the lush landscapes and the rhythms of nature.”

Arresting Visual Storytelling

In her feature directorial debut, Shuchi Talati demonstrates immense promise and talent behind the camera. With thoughtful framing and intimate yet non-exploitative close-ups, Talati’s visual approach enhances the naturalistic performances while pulling us into the psyche of our young heroine.

Clever camera angles immerse us in Mira’s point of view as she navigates strained relationships and societal pressures from all sides. The audience feels her disempowerment and isolation, but also her private moments of freedom and exploration.

Talati’s most powerful storytelling tool is her nuanced use of hands – whether fidgeting nervously, reaching for a forbidden touch, or reluctantly accepting help from her mother. With this simple motif, the director reveals hidden depths, intimacy, tension and tenderness.

Though Girls Will Be Girls tackles sensitive themes around sexuality, Talati handles such scenes with graceful subtlety. Mira’s private self-discovery is portrayed with honesty and care. The film echoes Mira’s own journey from shame to self-acceptance when it comes to desire and the female body.

From quiet moments in cavernous classrooms to golden-lit dance parties in cozy living rooms, Talati’s assured direction and rich visual language speak volumes about relationships. With her eye for striking compositions and her trust in actors’ expressions, she constructs an emotional experience that resonates long after the credits roll.

For a debut feature, Girls Will Be Girls announces Shuchi Talati as a director boasting sensitivity, insight and skill. She proves herself a natural visual storyteller who can distill universal adolescent themes down to their very essence – a fleeting expression, the brush of two hands.

“Discover the power of community and the spirit of giving in our Ordinary Angels review, a film that celebrates the unsung heroes among us. Witness how a simple act of kindness can change lives and bring light to the darkest of times.”

Poignant Perspective on Womanhood

While Girls Will Be Girls explores universal coming-of-age themes, it offers a uniquely Indian feminist perspective. Mira’s journey enlightens Western audiences about the distinct challenges facing Indian girls navigating adolescence and sexuality under a patriarchal system.

The film has been praised for its rare, honest depiction of female desire, intimacy, and sex education – topics still considered taboo in Indian cinema. The thoughtful approach to such scenes is both eye-opening and quietly empowering.

However, some critics felt the strained mother-daughter relationship was underdeveloped compared to the central romance between Mira and Sri. Anila’s motivations in particular could have used more context and background to better understand her complex attitudes.

Overall, Girls Will Be Girls was lauded upon its premiere at Sundance for providing an authentic window into the trials young Indian women face in claiming independence and defying expectations. It resonated as an unflinching yet compassionate portrait of girls shamed and silenced by society simply for coming of age on their own terms.

While the story focuses intimately on two generations of women, it touches universally relatable themes about balancing others’ wants with one’s own evolving identity. The lead performers connect profoundly with the vulnerability and intensity of self-discovery.

Even through an Indian lens, Mira’s journey speaks to the solidarity and inner strength girls anywhere must summon in growing up female. Her story serves as both reflection and inspiration to question the roles imposed on women and write their own.

With such wisdom and emotional depth, Girls Will Be Girls announces Shuchi Talati as a sensitive new cinematic voice. She tackles the joys and struggles of womanhood with understated power and the promise of more impactful perspectives to come.

A Touching Debut Exploring Womanhood

With Girls Will Be Girls, writer-director Shuchi Talati proves herself a sensitive emerging talent in Indian cinema. Her debut feature film provides a rare insider’s perspective on the challenges facing teenage girls growing up in a patriarchal society.

Led by incredible performances and graceful visual storytelling, Girls Will Be Girls navigates difficult themes around sexuality and societal pressures with wisdom and care. Though intensely personal, the coming-of-age story taps into universal emotions with relatable resonance.

In giving voice to silenced female experiences, Talati announces the arrival of an exciting cinematic voice. She tackles the joys, confusions, and struggles of womanhood with refreshing authenticity and compassion.

At its heart, Girls Will Be Girls is a touching look at mothers and daughters learning to understand each other while navigating their own identities. It captures the alienation yet solidarity of growing up female with poignant insight.

With so much emotional honesty packed into its tender coming-of-age narrative, Girls Will Be Girls deserves attention as a promising debut from an emerging filmmaker. Come for the undeniable performances, stay for the rare perspective that resonates deeply. Shuchi Talati is a gifted storyteller poised to make a meaningful impact.

The Review

Girls Will Be Girls

8.5 Score

With Girls Will Be Girls, first-time writer-director Shuchi Talati proves herself a sensitive and perceptive new cinematic voice. Her debut feature film tells a resonant coming-of-age story exploring womanhood in Indian society through a refreshingly authentic lens. Anchored by incredible performances and graceful visual storytelling, the movie navigates intensely personal themes around sexuality, identity and societal pressures with compassion and insight. Girls Will Be Girls announces the arrival of an exciting filmmaker to watch, and deserves praise for bringing such humanity and wisdom to the complex teenage experience.

PROS

  • Strong lead and supporting performances, especially by Preeti Panigrahi and Kani Kusruti
  • Beautiful cinematography and thoughtful framing brings setting to life
  • Director Shuchi Talati shows immense promise and potential
  • Honest, thoughtful depiction of female sexuality and awakening
  • Nuanced exploration of mother-daughter relationship dynamics
  • Powerful themes related to societal expectations and patriarchal pressures
  • Resonant coming-of-age narrative with universal relatability

CONS

  • Mother-daughter storyline feels slightly underdeveloped
  • Some motivations could use more context and background
  • Tonal shift in third act may seem jarring or extreme to some viewers
  • Narrative resolution is abrupt and leaves you wanting more
  • Dialogue occasionally comes across as expository or YA-esque

Review Breakdown

  • Overall 8.5
Exit mobile version