Pictures of Ghosts Review: Nostalgia and Change in the Heart of Brazil

Brazilian director Kleber Mendonça Filho takes viewers on a poignant stroll through his hometown in Pictures of Ghosts, a personal documentary with a spectral air. Known for fiction films like Neighboring Sounds that explore the changing face of Recife, Brazil, Filho now directly confronts the city’s transformation over time. Divided into three acts, Pictures of Ghosts filters the past through the lens of old theaters, capturing vanished communal spaces that nurtured Filho’s love of cinema.

Like a friend sharing stories over coffee, Filho guides us through archive footage and photographs from different eras. With insight and warmth, he reveals how politics, economics, and redevelopment hollowed out Recife’s once-vibrant downtown. It’s a meditation on art, memory, and the ephemerality of cities, directed with an eye towards preserving traces of what’s been lost. Pictures of Ghosts haunts in its own ghostly way, layering the personal and the historic into a tribute to Filho’s fading hometown haunts.

While Filho’s fictional works used the mundane to find greater truths, this documentary turns his camera outwards — towards the spirits of people and places now gone. Still, Filho’s fingerprints are all over Pictures of Ghosts. This is a movie about Recife, yes, but it’s also a snapshot of the ghosts that shaped one filmmaker’s artistic vision.

Home Movies: Tracing Recife’s Shifting Face

Pictures of Ghosts opens with a tour of the apartment where Kleber Mendonça Filho grew up, ground zero for both his filmmaking origins and his front-row view of Recife’s changing landscape. Through photos, home videos, and clips from his movies, Filho tracks the transformation of his childhood neighborhood from the 60s onward. We wander the rooms where he staged his first amateur shorts as a kid, murky VHS glimpses offering snapshots of another era. Outside, gates and barriers rise over time, sealing off homes as issues like crime and overdevelopment take root.

With wry humor, Filho narrates how the local hotspot became a no-go zone after dark. He shows the vanishing of familiar fixtures, like a neighboring dog named Nico whose incessant barking once kept his family awake. Later, Nico’s barks resurface in Neighboring Sounds’ soundtrack, time folding in on itself. “Over all these years I learned how time changes places,” Filho reflects, his old apartment preserved on film while the city around it slides from past to present.

Venturing into the streets, Pictures of Ghosts chronicles Recife’s decline through the fate of its downtown movie theaters — spaces impacted by political and economic tides. As a young cinephile, Filho visited Recife’s theaters religiously, immersing himself in worlds both local and global. Decades on, modern multiplexes divert crowds as these communal sanctuaries fall vacant, transforming or shuttering entirely. It’s urban decay tied to government negligence, funds dried up and redirect towards glossy tourist developments. For Filho, the slow gutting of Recife’s cultural landmarks encapsulates the push-and-pull between past and future, between preservation and progress.

Faded Silver Screens: Recalling Recife’s Vanished Cinemas

The heart of Pictures of Ghosts lies downtown, where Kleber Mendonça Filho pays tribute to his beloved big-screen shrines. As an avatar for Recife’s cultural heyday, Filho spotlights a cluster of lost movie palaces that once brought the magic of cinema to eager crowds. We travel back to the 60s and 70s when venues like the Art Palácio, Trianon, and São Luiz theaters enthralled Recife’s cinephiles with the latest offerings.

Like secular cathedrals, these downtown screens drew together people from all walks of life. In their flickering glow, farmers brushed shoulders with city slickers, uniting through shared reverence for the moving image. Filho fondly remembers weekday matinees playing to packed houses, rapt youths worshipping new releases from Hollywood and Brazil’s Cinema Novo movement alike. As streaming fractures modern audiences, Filho recognizes what’s been lost — these public spaces that promoted understanding simply by bringing locals under one roof.

Through photos and footage, we glimpse vanished exhibition relics like Alexandre Moura, Art Palácio’s veteran projectionist, who spent over 30 years beaming movies across the heads of countless viewers. In grainy VHS interviews, Mr. Alexandre laments cops slicing subversive sex scenes during Brazil’s dictatorship, part of the invisible labor required to safely showcase daring filmmaking. As Filho billows through the empty husk of São Luiz theater, such human stories resonate — all the people and rituals now absent that once kept Recife’s cinemas alive.

So what felled these communal structures? Filho probes the social forces and governmental decisions that drained downtown Recife over recent decades. As investments dried up, cultural flagships like theaters slowly decayed along with the area’s vibrancy. For Filho, the loss of these silver screen sanctuaries goes hand-in-hand with the dilution of civic identity, their closure spelling a wholesale gutting of Recife’s historic soul.

“Unravel the mysteries of ‘Red Island’, a gripping tale of isolation and survival. Check out our Red Island review for a deep dive into this suspenseful narrative that explores the dark secrets of a seemingly idyllic retreat turned deadly.”

Wider Lens: External Forces Reshaping Recife

While Pictures of Ghosts spotlights cultural erosion, Filho also acknowledges how outside pressures have continually molded life in Recife. In tracing the city’s changing face, the influence of authoritarian rule, foreign control, and economic divides comes to the fore.

Under Brazil’s military dictatorship (1964-1985), censorship from authorities directly impacted what played on Recife’s screens. Films featuring provocative political messages or sexuality faced routine cutting by government officials, restrictions recalled by Art Palácio’s projectionist. Through censorship, the regime’s clampdown on civil liberties entered the dream worlds of theaters.

In an unsettling reveal, Filho also notes how Recife’s downtown cinemas were slated to spread Nazi propaganda in the late 1930s. With Nazi support, venues like the São Luiz theater were set to blast German ideological content before the plan was scuttled. Decades later, Hollywood asserted its own cultural dominance when US studios opened local offices that gave Brazilians access to glossy Americana.

Outside geopolitics, gentrification also looms over Recife’s landscape. As affluent neighborhoods expand, downtown and working-class areas feel the pinch. The death of theaters signals vanishing communal sites where Recife’s diverse social strata once intersected. As in his fiction films, Filho examines how urban development divides communities as much as unites them — the paradoxical push-pull of progress.

Reel Reflections: Kleber Mendonça Filho’s Cinematic Origins

In the intimate spaces of his childhood apartment, Brazilian director Kleber Mendonça Filho embarked on a cinematic journey that would eventually capture the essence of his evolving hometown, Recife. “Reel Reflections” delves into this personal nexus where Filho’s early amateur films first flickered to life, a formative playground where his storytelling skills were nurtured. These nascent works, brimming with the raw energy of a young auteur, laid the groundwork for his later masterpieces.

Filho’s notable fiction films, “Neighboring Sounds” and “Aquarius,” serve as milestones in his oeuvre, each clip a mosaic piece reflecting the changing urban tapestry of Recife. These films, steeped in the rhythms of everyday life, echo the director’s deep engagement with his surroundings, transforming ordinary locales into extraordinary cinematic landscapes.

Beyond mere documentation, Filho’s work probes into the realms of nostalgia and preservation, intertwining these themes with an imaginative truth that transcends the screen. His films become more than stories; they are archival treasures, preserving the ephemeral moments of a city in flux. Through this lens, Filho examines the delicate balance between remembering and evolving, between holding onto the past and embracing the future. His cinema is not just a mirror to Recife’s shifting identity but a testament to the power of film in capturing the fleeting spirits of time and place.

Echoes of Recife: A Concluding Reflection

In “Pictures of Ghosts,” Kleber Mendonça Filho masterfully weaves a tapestry of art, memory, and change, encapsulating the soul of Recife through its cinematic past. The documentary stands as a poignant commentary on the evolving priorities of urban development, where the fading grandeur of old movie theaters becomes a metaphor for the city’s shifting cultural landscape.

These theaters, once vibrant hubs of communal experience, now serve as silent witnesses to the relentless march of time and modernization. Filho’s film transcends a mere chronicle of architectural decay; it is a meditation on the ghosts of people and places that linger in our collective consciousness. These spectral remnants, embedded in the walls of abandoned cinemas and the memories of those who frequented them, evoke a profound sense of loss and nostalgia.

Through Filho’s lens, the audience is invited to contemplate the ephemeral nature of communal spaces and the enduring impact they leave on the human spirit. “Pictures of Ghosts” is not just a story about Recife; it’s a universal tale of the places we hold dear and the inexorable transformations they undergo, leaving behind the ghosts of what once was.

Also Read:

Red Island Review: Paradise’s Ghosts Linger in Nostalgia Dahomey Review: Reckoning with Colonial Ghosts Small Hours of the Night Review: The Ghosts of Authoritarianism Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden Review – Haunting Tale of Romance & Regret