Role Play Review: The Mrs. Smith Nobody Asked For

Kaley Cuoco trades in her goofy charm as the lovable Penny on The Big Bang Theory for secret agent intrigue in Role Play, a new action rom-com premiering on Amazon Prime. She stars as Emma Brackett, a suburban supermom moonlighting as a deadly assassin for hire. Her loving but unassuming husband, played by David Oyelowo, thinks Emma’s constant business trips are just a tedious part of corporate life. But when her two worlds collide over a steamy anniversary date, this ordinary wife and mother is forced to reveal her extraordinary secret talents.

As Emma races to eliminate the threats now endangering her family, her shocked spouse struggles to reconcile this bombshell revelation with the woman he thought he knew so well. Director Thomas Vincent tries to balance laughs, thrills and heart in this playful spy caper. But despite flashes of potential, Role Play never quite finds its tone or brings the heat needed to earn comparison with similar covert couple classics like Mr. and Mrs. Smith.

With support from veterans like Bill Nighy as a charismatic rival hitman, this espionage take on mundane marital malaise assembles the ingredients for a potentially delightful diversion. Yet neither Cuoco nor Oyelowo manage to conjure the irresistible magnetism needed to transform an uneven script into effervescent summer fun. While this mixed bag of tepid action, uneven comedy and lukewarm romance might hold some appeal for diehard fans of its likable leads, Role Play falls frustratingly short of reaching its ambitious aims.

Double Trouble: Unraveling Role Play’s Twisty Plot

On the surface, Emma Brackett seems every inch the prototypical suburban supermom. Between shuttling the kids to school and cheering on the sidelines at soccer games, her life in picture-perfect surburbia appears wholesomely mundane. But while her loving husband Dave believes Emma’s frequent business trips are a tedious necessity of corporate life, they conceal a far more thrilling truth. Behind the canned tales of dreary conferences in Omaha lies Emma’s top-secret alter ego: a highly skilled assassin carrying out hits for shadowy clients.

While this deadly double agent keeps her loving family blissfully oblivious to her violent vocation, the secrets and separation take an emotional toll on her marriage to Dave. Seeking to reignite their connection, the couple plans an illicit anniversary rendezvous at a swanky Manhattan hotel bar. Posing as sexy strangers thanks to false identities and disguises, their kinky role play evening is suddenly disrupted by the appearance of a suave older gentleman. His seemingly innocent questions aimed at Emma trigger instant alarm bells, blown covers, and a dead body in short order.

In the ensuing chaos, Emma has no choice but to finally confess her covert career to her horrified husband. But sharing secrets can’t stop the avalanche already triggered, forcing Emma to evade both dogged detectives and her shady spy syndicate overseers by going off the grid in Europe. While Emma tries tracking down the threat to her family, hapless Dave reckons with the shocking revelation that his wife is a cold-blooded killer.

Despite feeling betrayed, Dave still cares deeply for Emma and unwillingly aids the authorities in tracking her overseas whereabouts. But he quickly regrets this decision when sinister suited thugs kidnap him to use as bait, hoping to finally take out their prized target. Emma catches wind of the trap and charges in guns blazing to save the day in an explosive final showdown.

While her shadowy background remains more mystery than revelation, by the closing credits Emma succeeds in eliminating the immediate dangers to her loved ones. But whether her marriage can survive the ultimate relationship ruiner of “surprise – I’m a secret assassin!” remains an open question. Despite this unorthodox premise, Role Play mines surprisingly little humor or intrigue from its dizzying double life dilemma. Between a pedestrian plot, uninspired action and missed opportunities for laughs, this spy caper never shifts into high gear. While Cuoco and Oyelowo offer glimpses of charm, overall this mixed bag aims to entertain but ends up feeling more like just another mundane trip to Omaha.

Mixed Reviews: Assessing the Stars of Role Play

In the pivotal role of Emma Brackett, Kaley Cuoco aims to follow up her acclaimed turn on The Flight Attendant by swapping comedy for action. But while flashes of her sitcom skills shine through, Cuoco never quite convinces as the cool-headed killing machine the role demands. She seems caught halfway between portraying a suburban soccer mom and a deadly assassin, unable to reconcile Emma’s dueling sides into a cohesive character.

Her action scenes largely fall flat, lacking the crisp precision of a Keanu Reeves or the slinky menace of a Charlize Theron. And her attempt at smoldering seductiveness feels more goofy than alluring in Role Play’s centerpiece hotel bar sequence. While Cuoco succeeds in eliciting a few laughs, she lacks the gravitas and physicality this part requires. And her lackluster romantic chemistry with co-star David Oyelowo further hampers her performance.

As the unwitting husband forced to confront his wife’s unsettling secret life, Oyelowo makes the most of an underwritten role. His talent for physical comedy shines through in moments of stunned disbelief upon learning Emma’s truth. While Oyelowo’s range extends far beyond such comedic beats, he scores Role Play’s biggest laughs with his incredulous reactions to each new jaw-dropping revelation. Yet his charm and skills feel constrained by generic dialogue and uninspired direction.

The bright spot among the cast is Bill Nighy, who briefly steals the show as a rival hitman oozing wit and intrigue. In just a few short scenes, Nighy brings an irresistible mix of urbane charm and underlying menace that highlights what’s lacking in the story’s central romance. His captivating presence leaves you yearning for more before his unceremonious early departure from the film. Nighy’s magnetic talent feels almost cruelly wasted in such a thankless and truncated supporting turn.

While Cuoco, Oyelowo and Nighy each demonstrate their respective strengths, the characters ultimately feel like little more than placeholders. Role Play‘s uneven script and direction fail to provide either the action or comedy these compelling performers require to truly shine. Surrounded by mediocrity and leaning on genre cliches, even these winning actors can’t rescue Role Play from its own lackluster execution.

“Explore the reimagined world of espionage in our Mr. and Mrs. Smith 2024 review. See how Donald Glover and Maya Erskine redefine undercover marriage. Read more now!”

Missing the Mark: Role Play’s Direction and Writing Woes

In juggling thrills, laughs and romance, director Thomas Vincent never finds a consistent tone or style to elevate Role Play above forgettable Hollywood cliches. The action scenes are marred by static camerawork and choppy editing that leech away any sense of tension or excitement. For a film centered on a deadly assassin, its set pieces are surprisingly dull. Even at a brisk runtime, the pacing feels sluggish.

Flat cinematography and uninspired staging fail to bring Role Play’s lackluster script to life. Vincent seems uncertain whether he’s crafting a slick spy thriller or family-friendly comedy. In trying to serve both masters, Role Play succeeds at neither. The by-the-numbers execution leaves no distinctive stamp to engage the viewer.

That generic feel extends to writer Seth Owen’s workmanlike screenplay. The central relationship between Emma and Dave lacks depth or complexity. We’re simply told their marriage has grown stale rather than shown any substantive problems to invest in. The sparse attempts at humor derive mostly from absurd situations rather than character-driven wit.

Backstory about Emma’s career as a killer for hire is similarly vague. The shadowy organization pulling her strings remains ill-defined, sapping the espionage elements of intrigue. With murky motivations all around, the stakes feel low. When threats emerge, they lack narrative weight. The plot proceeds on clunky rails towards a predictable conclusion without surprises or originality along the way.

Stuck between genres, Role Play avoids leaning fully into comedy, thrills or romance. The action lacks the slick style of films like Atomic Blonde, while the laughs fall short of classic couples capers like True Lies or Date Night. Emma and Dave’s relationship is painted in the broadest strokes, making it difficult to invest in their emotional journey.

With such thin character development and uninspired plotting, even a charismatic cast would struggle to elevate the material. But surrounded by mediocre filmmaking, Role Play’s talented stars can only do so much to mask its fundamental flaws. While occasional moments land, Vincent’s uneven direction and Owen’s formulaic script prevent Role Play from living up to its intriguing premise. This spy romp without the fun or thrills proves doubly disappointing.

Surface Appeal: Assessing Role Play’s Technical Merits

On a superficial level, Role Play hits all the requisite marks of a sleek spy thriller. But dig deeper, and its technical execution falls short of delivering style or substance. Cinematographer Maxime Alexandre fails to develop a visually engaging aesthetic. The action scenes lack kinetic impact, undermining any sense of danger. Alexandre’s uninspired compositions and coverage give the film a workmanlike, generic look.

The editing similarly does little to elevate the material, cutting action sequences together awkwardly. This hampers narrative momentum, making the brief runtime feel longer than it should. Role Play lacks the propulsive, stylish editing required to sell its central conceit.

While the production design checks the boxes for glamor and intrigue early on, it lacks inspiration. As Emma’s circumstances grow more perilous, the settings continue looking like an off-the-rack thriller rather than evolving visually. And the costume design similarly leans on shopworn tropes, failing to chart Emma’s shifts from suburban mom to fugitive fighter through wardrobe.

With cleaner editing and slick cinematography, Role Play’s flaws could perhaps fade into the background more seamlessly. But surrounded by mediocrity on all fronts, its sparse highlights feel increasingly isolated. While the film assembles all the requisite technical pieces of a spy caper, it lacks the skill or vision to transform them into an engaging final product. Polished on the surface yet hollow underneath, Role Play’s disappointing execution extends from the script to the screen.

Skin Deep: Thematic Shortcomings in Role Play

On the surface, Role Play gestures at engaging with resonant themes about the tensions between career and family. Emma’s literal double life could allow thoughtful exploration of work-life balance through an absurdist lens. But the film lacks the nuance to meaningfully explore these ideas.

The marital stagnation between Emma and Dave is simply stated rather than insightfully depicted. Their emotional dilemmas are broadly sketched rather than felt. Likewise, Role Play half-heartedly acknowledges the moral quagmire of Emma’s contract killing through lightweight jokes about taking a class instead. But it fails to genuinely grapple with the complications of her choice beyond superficial lip service.

At its core, the thematic substance never moves past the elevator pitch concept. Emma’s spy antics are just a plot device rather than a means to thoughtfully examine subtext about suburban ennui or modern marriage. The action and humor only engage these ideas on a surface level.

While Role Play assembles the ingredients to support richer thematic development, neither the script nor direction dig below the basic setup. For all its narrative convolution, the storytelling remains shallow throughout. Without meaningful character depth or nuance, Role Play ends up firing blanks – an intriguing concept exploring marriage, work and morality in thoroughly innocuous fashion. A sharper execution could have mined substantial food for thought from the same promising premise.

Closing Thoughts: Role Play’s Squandered Potential

Despite a seemingly can’t-miss high concept, Role Play fizzles as a lackluster jumble of action, comedy and romance. It aims to emulate charm-drenched couples capers like True Lies and Mr. & Mrs. Smith but lacks the style, thrills and chemistry that make those classics sing. An appealing cast led by Kaley Cuoco and David Oyelowo can’t overcome the one-note script and uninspired direction.

Director Thomas Vincent never locks into a consistent tone, leaving Role Play stranded awkwardly between genres. The action offers neither laughs nor excitement while the central relationship remains too superficial to carry real dramatic weight. Promising performers like Cuoco and Oyelowo struggle against the material, undone by weak dialogue and their own absent sparks as a couple.

In its best moments, Role Play offers flashes of witty fun from Oyelowo and a captivating supporting turn by Bill Nighy. But these high points feel like isolated bright spots rather than signs of a great film waiting to emerge. For all its convoluted plotting, the storytelling rarely ventures beyond skin deep.

What could have been a subversive, exhilarating spin on work-life balance ends up an altogether forgettable affair. Role Play follows the predictable spy caper playbook without enough charm or originality to distinguish itself. Despite its intriguing premise, this lukewarm attempt at marrying action, comedy and romance is ultimately more mundane trip to Omaha than thrilling adventure abroad. With its lackluster execution across the board, Role Play wastes a stellar cast on mediocre material that elicits neither laughs nor thrills.

Also Read:

Mr. & Mrs. Smith Review: Playing at Marriage With A License to Kill 29 Frequently Asked Questions on How to Make Dough Answered Avatar 3: This Star From Game of Thrones Will Play the Lead Role Three Women Will Play a Huge Role in Death Stranding 2