Legendary horror scribe Stephen King once wrote, “The most beautiful things live in the woods. And the most terrible.” The woods have long captivated our imaginations as places of mystique, fear, and the unknown lurking beyond the tree line. Writer-director Teresa Sutherland taps into this primal fascination in her directorial debut Lovely, Dark, and Deep, a moody plunge into madness and terror.
In the film, we follow Lennon, a ranger assigned to a remote outpost in Arvores National Park which has a long, dark history of unsolved missing person cases. Played by Barbarian breakout star Georgina Campbell, Lennon is harboring her own tragic ties to these haunting woods and their victims. As she settles into isolation and begins investigating the area’s sinister secrets, her grip on reality starts to loosen. Is something sinister indeed lurking out there and preying on unsuspecting visitors? Or are the most dangerous demons the ones we carry within?
Sutherland excels at crafting an atmosphere thick with dread, doubling down on the fear of forces beyond our comprehension. Blending slow-burn psychological horror with cosmic terror, Lovely, Dark, and Deep will leave you scanning the tree lines with fresh unease. Backed by mesmerizing cinematography and Campbell’s captivating performance, Sutherland reimagines Robert Frost’s iconic poem about nature’s allure and darkness for the horror genre. Just remember, once you venture too far into the wilderness…no one can hear you scream.
Into the Woods: Captivating Imagery and Palpable Dread
Lovely, Dark, and Deep thrives on its breathtaking cinematography and ability to curate an ever-present sense of unease. Shot on location in rural Portugal, the film plunges us into the wild and untamed Arvores woods. Cinematographer Rui Poças delivers striking compositions and camerawork, from elegant tracking shots to unsettling Dutch angles to sweeping aerials revealing Lennon’s profound isolation. The dream-like imagery enhances her deteriorating state of mind but also captures nature’s savage, hallucinatory glory.
The forest begins almost as a refuge, rows of sturdy trunks and motes of sunlight providing Lennon solace after past trauma. But soon the treelines seem to move when we aren’t looking, the woods growing darker, more gnarled. Strange sounds echo, shadows dance – is it madness or evil forces encroaching?
Poças renders the forest alternately sublime and sinister, at one moment mossy glens basking in gold, the next an abyssal tangle constricting our lead tighter. And in contrast to the claustrophobia among the trees, wide shots depicting Lennon as a small speck amid the vast wilderness visualize her terrifying insignificance against these indifferent ancient woods.
Sutherland excels at a slow-building sense of things being slightly “off,” curating uncanny imagery and patiently escalating tension. Much like the missing persons who vanish into the brush, never to return, the film plucks at our anxieties about forces beyond comprehension lurking just out of frame. Hikers appear and disappear, overgrowth consumes structures overnight, mysterious wounds form – is madness, human evil, or the insatiable forest itself to blame? The chaos crescendos poetically, hallucinatory visions invading as Lennon appears swallowed by the ancient wilds.
The pacing superbly balances stillness and shock for maximum disorientation. We share languid moments with our lead—the crunch of an apple, crackling radio static—before jolting events disrupt the calm. The editing keeps us as unbalanced as Lennon, chaos intruding without warning. And while violence remains minimal on-screen, the implication of sinister off-screen events proves even more unnerving. We brace for darkness to emerge from the beautiful woods, not sure what reality to trust. Just like our lead Lennon, we venture too deep inside a gorgeous, surreal nightmare from which we cannot wake.
A Haunting Tale of Trauma and Obsession
At its core, Lovely, Dark, and Deep is the deeply personal story of one woman haunted by loss and willing to risk everything for answers. When Lennon’s sister vanished in Arvores years prior, the tragedy created a wound that never healed, trauma twisting into obsession. Now assigned as a ranger in the very park that stole her loved one, Lennon sees an opportunity to solve the lingering mystery.
Her motivations reveal themselves slowly as we immerse in her daily reality – scanning maps, tracking coordinates related to disappearances, waving off concerned colleagues. Increasingly Lennon’s professional duties blur with a secret off-the-books investigation, putting herself in peril. Campbell brings nuance to the complex role, capturing Lennon’s courage and compassion while suggesting deep-seated wounds that drive her recklessness.
In clever thematic strokes, Sutherland links Lennon’s arc to broader existential questions about nature’s cruelty and chaos lying beyond our comprehension. We witness Lennon voluntarily venture deeper into darkness – both the literal wilderness and her tortured psyche. Which brings us to the brilliant inversion at the film’s core: Lennon enters the woods to find lost people, only to lose herself.
Sutherland utilizes tropes of cosmic horror to manifest Lennon’s abstract fears, sending her spiraling into a reality where the very nature of time and space bends. And much like H.P. Lovecraft’s storied genre which inspires it, explanations remain ambiguous, the forest’s sentience and strange happenings left open to interpretation. This refreshing resistance to tidy explanations perfectly mirrors the unknowable chaos of grief and trauma’s lingering scars.
By the climax, Lennon finds herself irrevocably alone, consumed by forces beyond comprehension – be they internal or external. Stripped of defenses, she must confront past demons and the harsh indifference of an ancient natural world. Here Sutherland’s script transcends genre trappings, arriving at a universal and poignant portrayal of the darkness within us all, raw and unrelenting. A woman ventures into the woods to save others – only to face her own grim reckoning in the end.
“Embark on a digging adventure like no other with ‘Pepper Grinder’. Our Pepper Grinder review delves into this innovative action-platformer that combines dynamic digging mechanics with a richly crafted world, providing a fresh twist on the genre that’s both challenging and exhilarating.”
Standout Lead Performance Anchors the Chaos
At the heart of Lovely, Dark, and Deep’s hypnotic descent into terror lies Georgina Campbell’s standout lead performance. Previously shining in buzzy 2022 horror Barbarian, Campbell proves utterly compelling as the haunted Lennon. With icicle focus and steely resolve, she captures Lennon’s surface-level strength and professionalism expertly. Yet Campbell suggests deeper wounds festering beneath the poised veneer via vulnerable glances and moments of naked despair. We believe in this character because Campbell grounds even Lennon’s most manic behaviors in palpable grief and devotion.
While details about Lennon’s past remain ambiguous till the end, Campbell masterfully tracks her harrowing emotional arc. We wince as Lennon’s obsessive quest strains her sanity to the brink, Campbell externalizing the mounting trauma through frantic physicality and raw outbursts.
She sells Lennon’s jarring hallucinations with panicked conviction, before segueing to brutal moments of clarity when past and present collide. Lennon may be the lone traveler venturing into darkness – but thanks to Campbell’s wrenching work, we feel the gnawing isolation and personal demons alongside her in every scene.
Despite her heavy lifting, Campbell enjoys some memorable supporting turns to briefly connect with. Fellow ranger Zhang (Wai Ching Ho) radiates wisdom and warmth, grounding early scenes with compassion. And Nick Blood exudes charisma as the missing hiker Lennon desperately tracks, their charged encounter raging with tension. But make no mistake, this remains Campbell’s showcase through and through. She keeps us invested even when the script grows opaque, bewitching viewers utterly until the final cryptic frame.
Where the Film Falls Short
For all its hypnotic imagery and committed lead performance, Lovely, Dark, and Deep suffers from an opaque narrative that may test viewers’ patience. Sutherland deliberately resists tidy explanations or exposition, aiming for enigmatic storytelling reminiscent of Picnic at Hanging Rock and other eerie art house classics.
Yet the loose plot threads may baffle those craving more clarity amidst the mesmerizing madness on display. Details remain so scarce about Lennon and the park’s history that dramatic events carry muted emotional impact. Sutherland leaves connective tissue between past trauma and current supernatural crisis largely up to interpretation, for better and worse.
The film also leans its thematic weight almost entirely upon Campbell’s stalwart shoulders as Lennon devolves further into obsession – meaning side characters fail to fully register. We needed more moments spotlighting Lennon’s bonds beyond her all-consuming quest, upping the personal stakes. As it stands, when reality itself falls away in the hallucinatory final act, we share the protagonist’sisolation but not a robust sense of what exactly she has lost beyond peace of mind.
In many ways, Lovely, Dark, and Deep plays like an eerie tone poem or lyrical fable more than a traditional plot-driven horror outing, prioritizing mood above narrative payoffs. Fans of The Witch, The Wind, or Saint Maud may best appreciate Sutherland’s patient descent into madness rendered with surreal beauty. Yet viewers craving clearly-delineated characters and story motivation may feel lost in the woods.
Where Lovely Dark and Deep shines brightest is through Sutherland’s confident command of atmosphere and imagery, realizing supernatural horror with surprising restraint. We may not fully understand the dark forces at play, but their sinister presence haunts frame after frame. Backed by mesmerizing camerawork and anchored by Campbell’s affecting lead turn, Sutherland’s tale leaves a uniquely unsettling impression not easily forgotten. She establishes herself as an emerging auteur to watch in psychological horror spaces should her future projects remedy issues of opaque storytelling.
A Stunning Directorial Debut Despite Flaws
Lovely, Dark, and Deep may leave some horror hounds scratching their heads, but remains an impressive calling card for Sutherland’s cinematic gifts. Focused world-building gives way to mesmerizing nightmare logic and indelible imagery. What lingers most is the film’s captivating sense of eerie doom masterfully sustained from first frame to last.
I would award Teresa Sutherland’s directorial debut 3.5 out of 5 stars. Viewers who preferred The Witch’s unsettling ambiguity over more conventional plotting will find the most to appreciate here. The film forgoes some emotional impact and accessibility in favor of haunting visual storytelling best appreciated by avid cinephiles. Casual horror fans may grow frustrated with the opaque narrative. But if you long for genre outings emphasized texture and provocative themes over clearly-delineated plots, Lovely, Dark, and Deep offers a uniquely unshakable experience.
Where Sutherland needs refinement moving forward lies in character and narrative cohesion to better ground her undeniable flair for the sinister. Yet the director emerges fully-formed regarding her ability to redefine familiar spaces like the family home (in The Wind) or now nature’s wonder itself into canvases for slow-burn dread.
I’ll eagerly venture into whatever weird and haunted spaces Sutherland conjures next, flaws and all. Because imperfect experiments in terror like Lovely, Dark, and Deep only come along so often against the mainstream’s sterile onslaught. What could be more horrifying than that?
The Review
Lovely, Dark, and Deep
Lovely, Dark, and Deep casts an entrancing yet opaque spell that enthralled as much as it perplexes. Sutherland emerges as an expert mood conjurer, even if characters and story cohesion remain in the shadows of her haunted forest. Backed by captivating lead work from Campbell and at times wondrous imagery, the film presents a beautiful brooding puzzle for those who prefer their horror more avant-garde. Still, I longed for deeper emotional connection to anchor the victim and pull us further into her nightmare. With refinements in pacing and clarity, Sutherland’s gifts could terrify at an Ari Aster level; for now, they mesmerize intermittently.
PROS
- Striking cinematography and landscapes
- Effective slow-burn dread and atmosphere
- Strong lead performance by Georgina Campbell
- Unique and ambiguous take on cosmic horror themes
- Haunting visuals and finale
CONS
- Opaque, confusing narrative
- Lack of character/plot development
- Frustrating lack of answers and payoffs
- Uneven pacing early on
