As the title suggests, Bad Newz tells a story that is as complex as it is thought-provoking. Saloni, played by Tripti Dimri, finds herself with an unexpected pregnancy—not just one baby, but twins, each fathered by a different man. Yes, you read that right. Saloni’s ex-husband Akhil and her current flame Gurbir are both potential dads due to a rare medical phenomenon.
Directed by Anand Tiwari, the film was released in 2024, starring Vicky Kaushal as Akhil and Ammy Virk as Gurbir alongside Dimri. Steeped in themes of relationships, family dynamics, and a woman’s right to choose, Bad Newz had all the markings of an insightful drama.
Color me skeptical but hopeful. A story touching on such nuanced issues deserves sensitive handling. If the movie can use its quirky situation to shine a light on modern relationships and women’s autonomy, it will prove thought-provoking. But if lightweight humor and one-dimensional characters overshadow such themes, Bad Newz may prove a missed opportunity. There’s only one way to find out: watch the movie with an open yet discerning mind.
Twins, Two Dads But Where’s the Depth?
Bad Newz tells the story of Saloni, a talented chef dreaming of winning a prestigious cooking award. After a whirlwind romance, she marries Akhil, but their relationship hits trouble when he interferes with her career goals. They divorce, and Saloni moves away, taking a job under restaurant owner Gurbir.
One drunken night changes everything. A chance encounter leaves Saloni pregnant, but with a rare medical surprise—she’s expecting twins with different fathers, Akhil and Gurbir. Word of the unconventional pregnancy spreads and sets the gears in motion for what’s to come.
With its premise of a woman’s autonomy over her body, the film taps into important themes. However, opportunities are missed to examine Saloni’s situation with real care. As the fatherhood drama between Akhil and Gurbir takes center stage, Saloni is sidelined, and her character lacks depth.
We learn little of her personal journey or views on the unplanned pregnancy. No consideration is given to her options; they are selfishly decided by those around her instead. As a talented chef, more could have been done to showcase her passion and ambitions outside of motherhood.
With a setup primed to explore modern family dynamics, the film settles for a routine romantic comedy route. Akhil and Gurbir behave like children, one-upping each other’s fatherly gestures. Their antics overshadow developing a real rapport with Saloni and understanding her needs.
The potential for nuanced social commentary disappears in a sea of slapstick humor. It’s a missed chance to say something meaningful about women’s agency or relationships in changing times. Instead, the film skims surfaces while its heroine is left wanting for proper character shading. With its depth of storyline and character, Bad Newz could have been so much more.
Twin Dads, Untapped Potential
Vicky Kaushal owns this film with his charming Akhil Chadha. His energy and comedic timing rescue many of the weaker jokes. Akhil’s immaturity is played to the hilt in an enjoyable way, though it grows tiresome by the end. Kaushal makes the most of what he’s given.
Tripti Dimri has the most intriguing role as expectant mother Saloni, yet she feels constrained. Her natural beauty is on display, yet her inner life leaves her wanting. Saloni’s goals and choices rarely drive the plot, overshadowed by male hijinks. It’s a disservice considering Dimri’s nuanced performances elsewhere. With more focus on her perspective, this could have explored thought-provoking themes instead of simplistic laughs.
Ammy Virk strives for depth as a responsible Gurbir, but the part, like Dimri’s, lacks dimension. His care for Saloni seems thoughtful, then abruptly shifts to a childish one-upmanship with Akhil. Viewers gain little understanding of who he and Saloni are as independent individuals. More three-dimensional writing may have allowed their talents to shine through and their characters to fully emerge.
Supporting artists do justice to the material, although some, like Gurbir’s dad, remain sketchy caricatures. Sheeba Chaddha stands out, utilizing her experience to inject warmth into her stock mother-in-law role. Overall, strong leads deserve scripts unlocking untapped creative potential and granting room to flesh out nuanced human stories in capable hands. When talented performers are constrained, we all lose out on what could have been.
Meandering Direction Despite Talent
Anand Tiwari has proven himself capable of much more than this. His previous projects, like Bandish Bandits, showed a nuanced touch, exploring complex emotions and relationships with care. That sensitivity is sorely missing here.
Bad Newz tends to be superficial. It relies heavily on crude jokes and one-dimensional characters. We learn little about what moves them or how they change. The focus stays on loud gags instead of probing any deeper issues.
Tiwari shows the ability to handle light themes. Yet this story, centering around a woman’s body and choices, demanded weight that its direction didn’t provide. Moments exist to delve into the strains of a modern family, but they’re rushed through for laughter that often falls flat.
The talent was there to guide messy personal circumstances towards meaningful resolution. But the meandering screenplay seems to have nudged the film off-course. It careens from one broad joke to the next without giving a steady hand to its themes or characters.
This leaves performances as really the only thing keeping viewing interesting. But even talented actors can only do so much without strong direction to realize their roles’ full potential.
Technical aspects perform workmanlike jobs alone. Music provides some enjoyable tracks, yet none with real memorability. Cinematography captures sights competently, if unremarkably. Editing flows adequately, but a lack of cohesive narrative dulls any impact.
Bad Newz represented an opportunity to entertain with insight. But under haphazard guidance, it remains content, floating on surface amusement alone. With focus and care, this story and cast could have resonated far more powerfully. As is, it offers little for the mind or heart to seize upon.
There’s lightness in comedy need not come at depth’s expense. When great ability goes astray, what might have been eclipses any assessment of what was. Maybe next time, this team will steer their talents towards truer and more rewarding expression.
Faltering where it could have flourished
Saloni’s story stumbles in its portrayal of modern issues that cry out for care. A capable chef with career dreams, her consent and agency received surface laughs instead of thoughtful reflection.
We meet Saloni full of culinary ambition, hoping to win high honors through her craft. Yet her goals slip to the sidelines while men dominate the plot. A messy night brings twins from different fathers, and her dilemma becomes cause for male humor over considered commentary.
Consent passed in a breath without sensitivity to what its substance demanded. In a land gaining abortion rights, not pausing over her options voiced a missed chance. Her wishes to avoid kids earned no respect either, reducing her wants to a humorous inconvenience.
As the rain fell in Mussoorie and tensions rose between men, her voice softened. Their actions drove the tale, with little focus on her burden. Carrying twice the responsibility with autonomy alone, the care-finding understanding for her predicament amounted to too little.
Scenes hinted at the profundity available: a reconciling mother discussing her own choice and a willingness to raise non-biological kin. But lazy writing rushed past openings for impact, lessons fading beneath redundant jokes.
With moving performances and true events as inspiration, this story could have flourished. Instead, it stalled, prioritizing surface over substance in topics demanding nourishment. A thoughtful look at the opportunities presented may have grown understanding for lives unlike our own.
Stirring Conversation, Squandered Potential
Bad Newz arrived amid buzz around its unique premise. Folks were talking—a comedy addressing stigma through an unconventional family situation? Unfortunately, the film fails to match this potential.
By turning complex issues into lazy jokes, Bad Newz misses chances to meaningfully shape attitudes. Saloni’s ambitions and autonomy deserve depth, yet they are trivialized. Her consent is played for laughs where sensitivity is needed.
This squanders opportunity. Today, many people reconsider traditions narrowly defining women’s roles. This story could have informed discussion by showcasing a woman’s right to choose motherhood and career. Instead, it assumes she must accept either path imposed on her.
Medical truths also brought opportunities. Explaining an uncommon condition could challenge misconceptions. Rather than educate, the film exploits this solely for melodrama.
Culturally, it represents a step back. While earlier films pushed boundaries, Bad Newz retreats into familiar tropes of gender roles and regressive humor. The result feels aimed not at progress but at pleasing the prejudices of an older audience.
Of course, many will find the comedy and star power entertaining. Bad Newz seems set for commercial success. But any film sparks wider effects, especially one with such a premise. It’s unfortunate that this story, which began an engaging conversation, ultimately had so little meaningful to say. Our culture is deprived where it could have been enriched.
An Unreached Potential
Bad Newz held promise that ultimately went unfulfilled. At its center lay a premise ripe for exploring relationships and cultural change. But where depth could have emerged, there remained only superficial humor.
The film mostly moves from scene to scene rather than developing its characters. We learn
little about what moves them beyond brief backstories. Saloni in particular deserves more—her journey deserves weight, yet she remains a passive observer of events.
This leaves interactions feeling hollow. The potential for thoughtful discourse in modern families dissipates in frivolous jokes and contrived drama. Cultural attitudes remain unexamined rather than furthered.
Not all is without merit. Vicky Kaushal shines with his famously lively charm, keeping moments entertaining. But even his talent reaches limits without substance to work from.
Overall, Bad Newz fails to realize the richness its starting point suggested. While a few laughs emerge, a little lingers in memory. One leaves perhaps pleasantly diverted but ultimately still wanting—wanting the conversations this story could have sparked, wanting.
The Review
Bad Newz
Bad Newz had all the ingredients for an insightful comedy, yet ultimately served up an unfocused and fleeting viewing experience. With bolder storytelling and more nuanced characters, it could have sparked meaningful dialogue. As it stands, Carrige of Opportunities remains unanswered.
PROS
- Strong performances from Vicky Kaushal, Tripti Dimri, and Ammy Virk
- Humorous moments and entertaining scenes
- Addresses taboo topics in a non-judgmental way.
CONS
- Weak and superficial storytelling with one-dimensional characters
- Fails to explore meaningful themes or cultural issues
- Uneven pacing with jokes that often fall flat
