Set along the banks of a remote Chinese river in the 1990s, Only the River Flows presents a gripping puzzle for Detective Ma Zhe to solve. But this is no ordinary crime procedural. Behind the initial murder lies a web of unspoken secrets that will take Ma Zhe on a disturbing journey.
Directed by Wei Shujun, who has garnered acclaim for his previous films at Cannes, Only the River Flows transports viewers to a small riverside town. Here, the local police force operates from an abandoned movie theater, a fitting background given how the town’s inhabitants conceal their truths behind closed doors.
We first meet Detective Ma Zhe as he begins investigating the killing of an elderly woman. All signs point to the “madman” who lived with her. But diligent Ma Zhe senses more lies just beneath the surface. As he delves deeper, he unwittingly exposes long-buried secrets, from a forbidden romance to a person hiding their identity.
Yet this is no simple whodunnit. Ma Zhe is wrestling with personal demons, worried his unborn child may face challenges. As the investigation takes its toll, his fragile mental state starts to unravel too. Through Ma Zhe’s deteriorating perception, the film unravels the repressive social order of 1990s China that drove some to desperation. To find the real truth, Ma Zhe must first face his own.
Underlying Mysteries
The story begins along a remote Chinese river, where the body of an elderly woman is discovered. dubbed “Granny Four” by the locals, she reportedly took in a quiet man known only as the “madman.” With him as the prime suspect, it seems an open and shut case.
Leading the investigation is Chief Detective Ma Zhe and his team. Unlike most police forces, they’ve set up their operation in an old abandoned movie theater. Perhaps fitting, as this town holds many secrets behind closed doors.
Ma Zhe is a talented but troubled investigator. Plagued by worries for his unborn child and pregnant wife, Jie, a doctor’s visit has given them unsettling news: there’s a risk their baby may face disabilities.
With the “madman” quickly named as a killer, Ma Zhe’s instincts tell him the real truth runs deeper. He persists in questioning anyone connected to Granny Four. This exposes unintended revelations, like a clandestine relationship between two poetic souls. A local hairdresser also feels compelled to confess, though his story seems off.
Ma Zhe’s diving stirs unearthed more than he bargained for. This small community’s passive ways cloak undercurrents of desire, identity, and darkness. As cracks emerge in the town’s hidden lives, Ma Zhe finds his own worldview start to crack.
His investigation has become all-consuming. Distracted by fears for his family yet driven to solve this puzzle, Ma Zhe is hurtling towards a breaking point. Only by confronting the mysteries within himself and this townsfolk can he hope to bring the real killer to justice.
Dark Waters
The atmospheric cinematography of Only the River Flows transports audiences straight to 1990s rural China. Shot on 16mm film by Chengma Zhiyuan, the visuals have a lovely muddy, low-fi quality that sets just the right melancholic tone. Through hazy hazes of blue and brown, we’re immersed in the weathered townsfolk and crumbling architecture.
Every frame feels lived in, from the peeling wallpaper in interrogation rooms to etched lines on Detective Ma Zhe’s face. Subtle period details enrich our experience of this place, from svelte cars and transistor radios to the changing fashions. It’s a China that truly feels like a bygone time.
This stark, gloomy landscape reflects the troubled waters plaguing Ma Zhe’s investigation. As his search drags on with no answers in sight, the atmosphere grows ever more oppressive. Scenes shift between day and night with surreal blending, mirroring Ma Zhe’s thinning grip on reality.
His once methodical work grows sloppy, and we see this mirrored in Zhiyuan’s photography. Shots that were once steady-handed become shakier, lighting more unbalanced. Even nature seems to turn against our hero, as downpours drench his desperate tracking of loose threads.
Perhaps most unsettling is when Ma Zhe’s disturbing dreams invade the muted realism. Through a jarring shift to nightmarish first-person, we’re given a window into his unraveling psyche. These chilling intrusions leave us as unsettled as our protagonist, losing ourselves in his paranoia.
It’s a masterful employment of visual storytelling that locks us deep in Ma Zhe’s troubled headspace. Even as answers remain elusive, Chengma Zhiyuan and Wei Shujun keep us fiercely engaged through the dark waters of this psychological mystery.
Lingering Ghosts
This film has a lot on its mind beyond just tracking a killer. Throughout the investigation, deeper themes emerge that give meaningful context to 1990s China.
Non-conformity is constantly lurking under the surface. Several characters live double lives, hiding things like extramarital affairs or gender identity. Simply acting differently seemed threatening enough for others to shut you out. It’s a lonely way to exist.
Ma Zhe’s work stirring up these secrets takes a toll. As more layers peel back, he sees how oppressive social norms crushed people. Yet there’s little room in his profession for understanding such nuances. He’s expected to neatly wrap cases, ignoring wider impacts. It clearly weighs on his soul.
These themes are also mirrored in Ma Zhe’s worries over his unborn child. Faced with the possibility of disabilities, he can’t help projecting the madman suspect. It reveals entrenched prejudices that leave little grace for those outside norms. As suspicion replaces empathy, he starts crumbling under pressure.
His gradual unraveling illustrates how jobs requiring detachment can isolate people. Law enforcement demands controlling emotions, yet officers stay deeply entangled. They face trauma with few outlets. Is it any surprise tensions might explode?
On another level, the film highlights a transitional period. Collectivist uniforms give way to individual styles as China opens but holds onto control. Change brings excitement yet uncertainty, as old certainties fade with ghosts of the past lingering in spaces left behind.
Throughout, director Shujun keeps interpretation open. But lingering in his frames are questions about a society emerging from turmoil and still learning to accept diversity in all its complexity. Some wounds are cut too deep to heal with simple solutions or verdicts in a court of law. Only time will lay lingering ghosts of the past fully to rest.
Tracing Torment
Shujun’s directorial hand is evident throughout in creative ways big and small. Clever visual metaphors sprinkle clues, like ping pong balls foreshadowing Ma Zhe’s unraveling. Scenes feel tactile thanks to location filming and Chengma Zhiyuan’s cinematography. Grainy film lends an authentic 1990s atmosphere, echoing Ma Zhe’s clouded mindset.
Production design amplifies this effect. Abandoned buildings hint at societal decay. Meanwhile, the repurposed cinema symbolizes a changing system, a refuge clinging to past ideals. Not all techniques land perfectly. Overly sourced music parallels Ma Zhe’s plight yet periodically interrupts organic tension. Overall design subtly shapes mood.
Of course, none of this would work without Zhu Yilong’s compelling lead performance. He breathes empathy, vulnerability, and depth into Ma Zhe without overstatement. As the character cracks, Zhu ensures subtleties resound far more than any outburst could. His physical transition mesmerizes, a symbol incarnate. Co-stars offer strong support, from fatherly chief to uneasy wife.
Together, cast and crew trace the contours of a man losing control, peeling back layers concealing unresolved trauma. Shujun avoids simple answers. Like the river ever flowing, life’s complexity eludes capture. But his mosaic fragments offer entry points, glimpses behind society’s orderly facade. Technical prowess serves atmospheric storytelling, highlighting humanity’s shared fragility and resilience in facing darkness within. Under Shujun’s guidance, the whole becomes more than the sum of its parts, leaving a lasting impression long after the closing credits roll.
Piercing the Surface
Only the River Flows offers more than its murky procedural plot initially suggests. Through Ma Zhe, we’re placed in the role of observer, struggling as he does to comprehend the people and place around him. Shujun crafts the character not as an infallible genius but as a flawed, complex man whose surface-level understandings are picked away.
Ma Zhe chases answers yet remains detached, never truly knowing those he investigates. Like himself, they hide inner worlds society cannot contain. An illicit lover, a gender-bending stylist—all defy expectations to live outside boxes crafted by others. Their need for secrecy hints at judgment preying on lives, refusing simple explanation. As shades are pulled back too, we view even our guide in a less certain light.
The film peels perspectives like onion skins. Dreams blur reality, forcing reexamination of “facts” and driving Ma Zhe to the brink. Details once deemed incidental weave intriguing patterns retrospect lends meaning to. Shujun trusts us to piece disparate fragments into a mosaic resisting definitive boards. Life overflows such manmade frames, its currents mysteries even to those swept up in turmoil’s tide.
Detachment fosters not understanding but distance between people. Ma Zhe’s impending fatherhood turns his inquiries personal yet amplifies misunderstandings, as one life seen through his fears becomes a’madman’. Only the River Flows leaves lingering disquiet by lifting deceptive surfaces yet providing no easy answers, for its characters reflect life’s messier truths defy full comprehension. In darkness, it finds not despair but humanity’s shared frailties and complexities that no rigid perspective can encompass. Its effective frustration stems from piercing facades to pose questions few stories dare unveil.
Exploring Society’s Shadows
This review delves into Only the River Flows’ nuanced crafting of a mystery steeped in subtlety. Director Wei Shujun takes you on a voyage of discovery through a small Chinese town. As Ma Zhe untangles secret lives, deeper truths emerge about a society shouldering conformity’s weight.
Shujun invites reflection without feeding answers. Complex characters, layered with empathy, reveal faces behind facades. Ma Zhe cracks under pressures both professional and personal, mirroring turmoil bubbling beneath calm waters. Visual storytelling, absorbing you in a long-gone world, enhances this journey of unfolding realization.
Rewards lie in patience. Only the River Flows demands repeat visits to unravel intricacies woven between raindrops on a window. While leaving some stones unturned, it offers glimpses into shadows few explore. Technical craft brings both eras and emotions to life, keeping its enigmatic pull.
Chinese cinema gains strength telling stories like these. Shujun’s deliberate pace honours subtleties lost in brief attention. His fascinated gaze finds beauty in life’s imperfections, and light in darkness, inviting us to do the same. Some puzzles have no answers, but meaning emerges in looking. This film, and its lingering insights, deserve wide appreciation.
The Review
Only the River Flows
Only the River Flows is a moody, subtle mystery that rewards those willing to dig beneath its surface. While the fate of its characters remains mired in murkiness, the film ultimately illuminates shared aspects of the human experience. Director Wei Shujun crafts a multifaceted portrait of a society through the cracks in one man's failing psyche. Though short on clear answers, it leaves lingering questions and a richly layered sense of place. Chiefly, Only the River Flows proves a thought-provoking work that demonstrates the continuing creative strength of Chinese cinema.
PROS
- Layered storytelling and plot that unravels secrets in an intriguing way
- Strong visual storytelling and cinematography that enhances atmosphere
- Thought-provoking exploration of themes around human relationships and society
- complex, multi-dimensional characters
- Provokes discussion and rewards repeat viewings.
CONS
- The plot can feel vague and ambiguous at times.
- Ending does not provide definitive resolutions.
- May be too subtle for some viewers seeking a straightforward mystery.
