Viewer Discretion Advised explores the ascent of the popular content creation platform OnlyFans and the role it played in a highly publicized murder case. The documentary examines how the site launched in 2016 as a venue for diverse self-expression but soon attracted notoriety as an outlet for pornographic material. Creators like Courtney Clenney found both financial success and controversy through their risque posts on the platform.
Clenney rose to fame as an OnlyFans model making a lucrative living. However, her life took a tragic turn when she was accused of killing her boyfriend Christian Obumseli at their Miami apartment in 2022. Initial reports suggested self-defense, but further investigation indicated Clenney may have intentionally stabbed him during a domestic dispute. Her case sparked intense media coverage and placed renewed scrutiny on her activities.
The film focuses its dual narrative on charting OnlyFans meteoric growth over recent years while also chronicling the disturbing details of Clenney’s relationship and subsequent arrest. By the end of 2020, the site boasted 200 million users and generated billions in revenue, appealing to a wide user base, from modest earners to celebrities like Bhad Bhabie.
Yet the shadow of violence also loomed as viewpoints clashed over the role the platform may have played in Clenney’s toxic relationship. This gripping documentary offers insights into both the opportunities and consequences presented by our interconnected digital lives.
The Rise of a Platform
OnlyFans got its start in 2016 as a new kind of online community. The site allowed anyone to earn dollars directly from dedicated fans by sharing talents, hobbies, or other creative projects through PayPal content. In the early days, people posted an assortment of homemade videos on topics like cooking, exercise tips, or cryptocurrency trading.
It wasn’t long before the platform became widely known for hosting adult content. Sex workers and influencers utilizing OnlyFans saw a chance to profit from and control their image in a way few other venues allowed. Through intimate behind-the-scenes glimpses into their lives, these creatives engaged paying subscribers and commanded impressive followings. The documentary shares the stories of successful creators, like a single mom turning to the site after she lost her teaching job. She mentions the freedom and financial security OnlyFans provided.
By 2020, OnlyFans was booming with over 200 million users, thanks in part to pandemic lockdowns. The document highlights how the site’s hands-off approach to censorship and emphasis on user empowerment cultivated a supportive community for all manner of creators. Yet controversy also emerged. Some celebrities, like Bhad Bhabie, faced backlash for “teasing” adult content without delivering. The film also explores accusations that elite influencers don’t reflect the day-to-day realities for most workers in the industry. As the site’s popularity exploded, so did debate around its cultural impact and role in people’s lives.
The Tragic Downfall
Courtney Clenney seemed to have it all—a lavish lifestyle, adoring fans, and financial success through her risqué modeling. But in 2022, clouds gathered over the popular OnlyFans star.
Her tumultuous relationship with Christian Obumseli had been rocky. The documentary reveals alarming details of domestic disputes between the couple. On the fateful day, police arrived at their Miami apartment to find Clenney distraught and covered in blood. She claimed Obumseli’s fatal stabbing was an act of self-defense during a fight.
Authorities initially accepted this story amid a lack of evidence against Clenney. However, a deeper investigation painted a more complex and troubling picture of the events. Text messages and witness accounts called her self-defense claim into serious question. Video footage even showed Clenney, who towered over Obumseli, as the likely aggressor.
Public opinion swiftly turned against Clenney. Her flashy appearance fueled accusations that she received preferential treatment due to wealth and beauty. After months in rehab, she was finally arrested and charged with second-degree murder. Her upcoming trial promises to be highly publicized and contentious. Whatever the outcome, it’s clear Clenney’s career and life will never be the same after the fateful night that led to Christian Obumseli losing his own life.
Examining the Approach
Viewer Discretion Advised adopts a familiar true crime format with its flashbacks, talking head interviews, and reenactments of pivotal moments. Director Victoria Duley draws upon her experience handling heavy subjects in shows like Surviving Jaws. Her direction keeps the violent aspects of Clenney’s case from becoming gratuitous.
However, the documentary never truly delves deep with any of its experts. We hear surface opinions from various commentators but little rigorous analysis. A criminologist briefly touches on domestic violence dynamics, yet the film fails to meaningfully explore the complex realities of Clenney and Obumseli’s relationship.
More perplexing is the constant promotional tone regarding OnlyFans. The platform is given ample time to tout financial successes, but no critic is given equal footing. Viewers leave understanding little about its drawbacks or pitfalls designers may face.
Balancing these dual narratives was surely a challenge, but the result feels imbalanced. The line between informing and advertising proves blurry at times. While sex positivity and worker empowerment are worthwhile missions, the constant sales pitches strain credibility.
With a running time of over an hour, a tighter edit focused on investigative journalism could have served audiences better. As is, sensationalism wins out over delivering a true understanding of the intersecting issues at play. A mix of styles fails to uncover deeper truths about the human impacts of social and sexual revolutions online.
Assessing the Views
Viewer Discretion Advised brings in a range of voices to discuss the pressing social issues at play. A criminologist offers perspective on abuse dynamics, while clinicians provide psychological context. Writers give their take on changing cultural norms.
Most valuable are those who moved discussion forward in meaningful ways. Dr. Kahina Beasley stands out for her nuanced analysis of how trauma affects behaviors, challenging simplistic narratives. Her viewpoints left a lasting impression.
Some feel more like decoration than contribution. What insight was gained from podcast host Stunt Lifestyle beyond surface-level Miami stereotypes? Viewers deserved experts wielding depth of knowledge, not just flashy credentials.
Balanced conversations require challenging all preconceptions, yet certain stances are given short shrift. No critic of OnlyFans’ business practices gets equal time. A full picture remains out of focus without addressing both benefits and shortcomings.
By prioritizing only affirmative stances towards its primary subject, Director Duley fell short of the documentary’s duty to inform versus promote. By mining insightful experts like Dr. Beasley further, understanding could have flourished.
Worth a Look, With Reservations
Viewer Discretion Advised takes on pressing topics of gender roles, sex work, and abuse in an era of online upheaval. Its true crime component maintains interest throughout. However, an overdependence on lurid details and shallow experts holds it back from meaningful insights.
While Courtney Clenney’s situation raises thought-provoking points, the film fails to seed deeper discussion. Sensationalism overshadows social commentary needed to do justice to these complex issues.
Those intrigued by prurient and legal aspects will find it passably engaging. However, viewers seeking understanding warrant aheads-up of its shortcomings. With tighter focus on investigative journalism versus promotion, it could have thrived as a thought-provoking documentary.
If curious about how new platforms shape human behaviors and relationships, there may be value in its themes. Yet quality is uneven and agenda is thinly veiled. Recommended for mature audiences willing to look past superficiality and form their own opinions. Two stars out of five.
The Review
Viewer Discretion Advised: The Story of OnlyFans and Courtney Clenney
While Viewer Discretion Advised presents an intriguing real-life case at its center, it falls short of meaningful analysis due to an overly salacious tone and unbalanced priorities. The film opts for sensationalism over insight, prioritizing promo over prose. Though tackling issues worthy of discussion, it does little to further understanding. All in all, Viewer Discretion Advised proves a missed opportunity to say something of substance on its multi-faceted subjects.
PROS
- Engaging the true crime component maintains interest.
- Presents pressing topics around sexuality, relationships, and online platforms.
CONS
- Overly salacious and sensationalist tone
- Fails to offer meaningful analysis or insight
- Prioritizes promotion over substance
- Shallow experts not suited to subjects' complexity
- Missed potential for investigative journalism
