Eric Larue Review: No Easy Answers in This Unsparing Drama

Michael Shannon’s directorial arrival, “Eric Larue,” unfurls not as a story easily told, but as a shard of existence held to the light. Adapted by Brett Neveu from his own stark stage play, the film presents Janice and Ron LaRue, parents suspended in the temporal void that follows catastrophe. A year has passed since their son, Eric, tore through his high school, extinguishing three lives and his own former self, now a name on a prison roster.

We are invited not to observe a plot, but to witness the atomization of two souls, their grief a chasm between them, their methods of survival divergent paths into an unmapped wilderness. The film breathes the chilling air of questions that haunt the periphery of parental being: what monstrous seeds might lie dormant in the soil of our love, what solace, if any, can be found when the unthinkable erupts from within one’s own blood?

Janice: A Constellation of Internalized Night

Janice LaRue moves through her days like a ghost haunting the ruins of her own life. Judy Greer crafts a portrait of a woman calcified by sorrow, her home a self-imposed cell, Eric’s closed bedroom door a silent, monumental accusation.

Each object, each shadow, seems to whisper of what was, and what can never be again. She is a cartography of pain, meticulously mapped by shame, by a public gaze that sears, by the unanswerable ‘why’ that echoes in the hollows of her heart. She has not yet dared to cross the threshold of the prison, to face the physical manifestation of her torment.

Her son’s violence is a splinter lodged deep within her, and she wrestles not with the act alone, but with the prescribed emotional responses society dictates for the mother of a monster. Simplistic comforts, the immediate balms offered by well-meaning spiritual guides, find no purchase on the barren ground of her despair; she seems to understand that some abysses demand to be sat with, not hastily papered over.

Greer’s performance is a masterclass in implosion, her anguish a palpable presence, her gaze holding oceans of unshed tears, a quiet fury simmering beneath the permafrost of her humiliation. Her brief, reluctant interactions with the outside world, particularly with her pastor or the mothers of her son’s victims, are like watching a creature flinch from an anticipated blow.

Ron: The Architecture of Evasion

Against Janice’s landscape of desolation, Ron LaRue, her husband, erects a different kind of structure. Alexander Skarsgård, almost spectral in his transformation, embodies a man clutching at the straws of fervent, newfound religiosity.

He seeks refuge in the insistent embrace of a different church, a community promising immediate absolution, a swift passage through the valley of shadows. “You will have immediate peace!” he proclaims, the words themselves a desperate incantation against the darkness that Janice seems to determinedly inhabit. Is this genuine spiritual awakening, a lifeline in the tempest?

Or is it the architecture of evasion, a carefully constructed denial painted in the bright, unyielding colors of zealotry? Skarsgård navigates this ambiguity with a disquieting skill, his Ron a figure of almost pitiable frailty, his pronouncements of faith feeling at times like a performance for an unseen, perhaps unconvinced, deity within himself.

His path is further illuminated, or perhaps complicated, by the eager fellowship of Lisa, portrayed by Alison Pill with an unnerving effervescence, a beacon of insistent cheer in Ron’s chosen sanctuary. Their shared spiritual fervour hints at a different kind of human seeking, a warmth found perhaps too easily amidst the ruins.

Shepherds in a Desolate Valley

The spiritual shepherds who tend to this blighted flock offer their own dissonant chorus. Pastor Steve Calhan, Janice’s guide, played by Paul Sparks, extends a hand that seems both earnest and profoundly out of its depth. His attempts to navigate the treacherous currents of Janice’s grief, his orchestration of a summit between her and the bereaved mothers, become exercises in controlled futility.

He speaks of healing, of dialogue, yet his interventions often feel like the fumbling of a man trying to reassemble shattered glass with well-intentioned, yet inadequate, tools. Across town, Tracy Letts’ Pastor Verne offers Ron a more robust, perhaps more unyielding, brand of faith.

The film watches these figures, these anointed mediators between the human and the divine, and seems to ask whether any system of belief, any prescribed ritual, can truly encompass the raw, jagged edges of such a singular horror. Does the societal, the communal, impulse towards rapid forgiveness and a neatly packaged resolution merely serve to silence the deeper, more unsettling truths of grief and irreducible guilt?

The Unblinking Eye of the Camera

Michael Shannon’s direction is an unflinching gaze, a refusal of sentimentality. The film’s visual language speaks in muted tones, a drained palette that mirrors the exsanguination of hope. Backgrounds blur, a subtle rendering of Janice’s suffocating interiority, the world beyond her pain rendered indistinct, irrelevant.

This aesthetic choice amplifies the claustrophobia of her experience, a life lived in the harsh, unwavering spotlight of a personal hell. The film’s theatrical lineage is perceptible, its power concentrated in charged encounters, in dialogues that dissect the raw nerves of human connection, or its impossibility. When Janice finally confronts Eric, portrayed by Nation Sage Henrikson with a chilling composure, the screen becomes a crucible.

His words, his very presence, offer no easy catharsis, instead posing new, unsettling questions about remorse, the genesis of darkness, and the terrifying opacity of the human heart. The film does not resolve into simple drama or outright satire, but hovers in an uncomfortable space between, observing the absurdities of human coping mechanisms without blunting the edge of the tragedy. It leaves us adrift with its characters, in the disquieting silence that follows an unanswered cry, questioning the very nature of accountability in a world where meaning so often frays into ambiguity.

Eric LaRue premiered at the 2023 Tribeca Film Festival on June 10, 2023, and was released in the United States on April 4, 2025.

Full Credits

Director: Michael Shannon

Writer: Brett Neveu

Producers: Sarah Green, Karl Hartman, Jina Panebianco

Executive Producers: Jeff Nichols, R. Wesley Sierk III, Byron Wetzel, Meghan Schumacher, John D. Straley, Declan Baldwin

Cast: Judy Greer, Paul Sparks, Alexander Skarsgård, Alison Pill, Tracy Letts, Annie Parisse, Kate Arrington, Nation Sage Henrikson, Lawrence Grimm

Director of Photography (Cinematographer): Andrew Wheeler

Editor: Mike Selemon

Composer: Jonathan Mastro