Alice & Jack focuses on the turbulent, on-again off-again relationship between two complex characters – the nameless title duo portrayed by talented actors Andrea Riseborough and Domhnall Gleeson.
Riseborough brings to life the mercurial Alice, a successful but cynical financier whose spiky exterior masks a traumatic childhood. She breezes in and out of Jack’s life capriciously over 15 years, leaving chaos in her wake. Gleeson plays the mild-mannered Jack, a biomedical researcher whose romantic optimism blinds him to Alice’s unreliability. Their unlikely magnetic connection defies reason or explanation.
While neither character easily wins our affection, both leads turn in strong performances that compellingly sell this perplexing relationship. Riseborough in particular does excellent work bringing nuance and intrigue to the divisive Alice.
Aiding the leads is a sparse but superb supporting cast including Aisling Bea as Jack’s ill-fated wife Lynn, and Sunil Patel as Jack’s hilariously deadpan coworker. With its complex characters and talented cast, Alice & Jack makes for an emotionally intense, if not always enjoyable, viewing experience.
Complex Leads Anchored by Strong Performances
At the heart of Alice & Jack lies the turbulent relationship between two complex characters brought vividly to life by talented lead actors.
Andrea Riseborough turns in a stellar performance as the mercurial Alice, a successful but cynical London financier. With her severe hairstyle and intense stare, Alice cuts an imposing figure. Her spiky exterior masks deep childhood trauma, making her emotionally volatile and unable to commit to relationships. She breezes capriciously in and out of Jack’s life over 15 years, leaving chaos in her wake. It’s a testament to Riseborough’s acting skill that she brings nuance and magnetism to such a divisive character.
As Alice’s counterpart, Domhnall Gleeson plays the mild-mannered Jack, a diffident biomedical researcher whose romantic optimism blinds him to Alice’s unreliability. Gleeson brings an earnest warmth to Jack, though the character’s passivity in the face of Alice’s mind-games frustrates viewers. We never fully understand what draws these two together besides a perplexing magnetic connection that defies reason. Still, Gleeson’s emotional authenticity helps sell their dynamic.
The sparse but superb supporting cast aids the leads beautifully. Aisling Bea turns in a vibrant performance as Jack’s ill-fated wife Lynn, bringing much-needed wit and heart. Sunil Patel also shines as Jack’s hilariously deadpan co-worker Paul, delivering biting comic relief.
With its mercurial lead duo portrayed by two powerhouse actors, Alice & Jack makes for an intense, if polarizing viewing experience. We may not always like these characters, but it’s hard to look away thanks to the magnetic performances.
A Tumultuous 15-Year Romance
At its core, Alice & Jack depicts the tumultuous on-again, off-again romance between the two enigmatic title characters over 15 rollercoaster years.
We first meet Alice and Jack when they have an intense one-night stand after meeting on a dating app. The self-sabotaging Alice promptly kicks the lovelorn Jack out of her apartment, telling him not to call. Yet somehow they develop an magnetic connection that keeps pulling them back together, no matter how destructive it proves.
The series features frequent time jumps, charting the ups and downs of Alice and Jack’s relationship against the backdrop of their separate lives. Though they try to date normally, Alice disappears for months or years at a time, throwing Jack’s world into chaos whenever she resurfaces. During one break, Jack marries the warm-hearted Lynn and they have a baby – only for an ever-capricious Alice to breeze back and wreck his domestic bliss.
We witness the collateral damage their unhealthy obsession causes to those around them. Yet Alice and Jack seem addicted to their own drama, prioritizing intense passion over stability time and again. Even when apart, they can never quite quit each other.
After 15 years, their connection remains as bewildering as ever. For all the anguish it causes, they cannot deny its profoundly personal hold. Alice & Jack refuses easy answers, instead depicting love as an irrational, undeniable force that defies logic or explanation.
Exploring the Irrationality of Love
At its heart, Alice & Jack is less about plot than an exploration of the irrational nature of love itself. Despite the dysfunction of their relationship, Alice and Jack cannot quit their mutual obsession. What makes it so compelling?
The series poses love not as a choice but an uncontrollable force – mysterious, irrational and defiant of logic. We never fully understand why these two are so drawn together, but that is precisely the point. Their connection seems to exist outside of conscious reason.
This central idea gives the show a distinctly melancholy, thoughtful tone. Moments of witty banter and comic relief aside, Alice & Jack dwells in emotional intensity. The mood grows increasingly morose as the characters’ self-destructive decisions compound, causing bitter heartbreak for all involved.
Yet as much as we may wish for Alice and Jack to move on from their toxic dynamic, we relate to their inextricable bond on a human level. Haven’t we all pined for someone confusingly alluring but utterly wrong for us? Alice & Jack holds up love as an eternal mystery – one that compels against our better judgement.
In defiantly refusing pat resolutions, the series achieves a raw emotional truth about the madness of love. Alice & Jack lingers with viewers not for tidy plot outcomes, but for evoking the hopeless yearning at love’s dark heart.
Polarizing Writing and Dialogue
One of the most debated aspects of Alice & Jack proves to be the writing itself. Creator Victor Levin cultivates an artsy, minimalist style light on plot and heavy on romantically poetic monologues. The heightened dialogue often veers into pretension, feeling more like philosophical musing than natural conversation.
When it works, the writing takes on a dreamy, introspective quality that aptly captures the characters’ intense inner worlds. But at other times, the overly literary lines ring hollow, undermining believability. Critics argue no one talks like this – waxing poetic one minute, then spouting odd non-sequiturs the next.
The characters’ baffling decision-making also strains credulity. We’re given little coherent rationale for why Alice and Jack destroy relationships to endlessly reunite, beyond a simplistic “love is irrational” argument. Their magnetic chemistry feels implied rather than shown. As such, some find the writing self-indulgent versus insightful.
However, the polarizing dialogue proves well-suited for the leads to showcase their acting talent during emotional one-on-one scenes. And the uniqueness of Levin’s eccentric voice makes Alice & Jack feel wholly original. Audiences may argue over quality, but the writing style undeniably makes a strong creative statement.
For better or worse, the idiosyncratic dialogue and plotting place character study above realism – prioritizing Alice and Jack’s inner worlds over viewer satisfaction.
Visual Flair Anchors Melancholic Mood
While Alice & Jack proves polarizing on paper, few can fault its technical artistry. The series unfolds with the visual panache of an indie film versus a standard TV drama.
Much credit goes to directors Juho Kuosmanen and Hong Khaou, who establish a highly cinematic style. Scenes often play out in extended handheld takes amidst striking settings like minimalist galleries and rainy London streets. The intimate camerawork amplifies the leads’ emotionally intense performances.
Through color palette and lighting, the visuals mirror the melancholy story. Alice particularly is associated with a cold, haunted aesthetic, often framed alone staring listlessly out shadowy windows. Yet cinematographers Xavier Grobet and Mikhail Krichman find poetic beauty in her isolation.
Composer Stephen Rennicks’ haunting piano and strings score similarly channels quiet despair – all mournful minor chords and restless perpetuum mobile passages underscoring the characters’ inner turmoil. A sublime soundtrack album could easily stem from the series.
Some may contest Alice & Jack’s writing and character decisions. But with its sheer visual artistry and panoramic soundtrack channeled to bolster mood, few could call this show visually uncreative or sonically dull. Technical flair anchors the emotional weight where the script falters, making disappointment easier to forgive.
An Anti-Romance for the Normal People Age
With its years-spanning romantic saga premise, comparisons inevitably arise between Alice & Jack and Sally Rooney adaptation Normal People – or the new Netflix hit One Day, tracking a couple across decades.
Indeed, Alice & Jack owes a debt to the Normal People-sparked trend of brooding millennial relationship studies. From its melancholy piano score to characters self-destructively prioritizing passion over stability, the parallels show.
Yet rather than feeling derivative, Alice & Jack emerges as an anti-romance refutation of its predecessors’ romantic ideals about star-crossed soulmates. While the latter depict loves worth pining for, Alice and Jack’s connection breeds only dysfunction.
Additionally, Alice & Jack eschews tidy happy endings about lovers finally united. “Our exes are exes for a reason,” the show pointedly reminds. Instead, it dwells in love’s darkness – how feelings that seem predestined, especially in your 20s, may in truth slowly sour and twist people over time.
In an era where media romanticizes tortured modern relationships, Alice & Jack provides a bracing reality check. An anti-rom com for the Normal People generation, it follows the cynicism of that show through to a bitterly realistic conclusion: some connections, however intense, reach a point where walking away becomes the only sane option.
A Frustrating But Fearless Portrait of Dysfunction
For all its narrative issues, Alice & Jack unquestionably makes bold creative choices. Following two unlikable leads across 15 years as they compulsively self-destruct makes for an utterly unique, if polarizing viewing experience.
The show frustrates yet compels as we witness smart people make terrible decisions, continually prioritizing temporary passion over lasting happiness. But perhaps that irrationality lies at the crux of Alice & Jack’s appeal as an anti-romance. It dares to explore the ugliest sides of love: jealousy, codependency, toxicity.
With its determinedly downbeat tone and defiantly ambiguous ending, the series clearly rejects crowd-pleasing catharsis. Instead, it offers a window into the gnarled psyches of two damaged people stuck in unhealthy patterns – consequences be damned.
Landing amidst a sea of romantic fantasies, Alice & Jack deserves some credit for biting the rose-tinted glasses off love stories with clear-eyed candor. Is it an enjoyable viewing experience? Often not. But the sheer boldness of vision stands out in today’s risk-averse TV climate.
For those seeking a feel-good diversion, look elsewhere. Yet viewers numbed by formulaic TV may appreciate Alice & Jack’s emotionally messy authenticity – if they can withstand the necessary frustrations involved. As portraits of dysfunction go, they don’t come much more defiantly fearless than this.
The Review
Alice & Jack
For all its narrative frustrations, Alice & Jack deserves some credit for capturing the ugliest sides of love with clear-eyed candor. Those seeking a feel-good romance should look elsewhere, but viewers numbed by formulaic TV may appreciate the emotional authenticity - even if it comes bound to necessary frustrations surrounding two leads chained to toxicity. Boldly made yet exasperating to watch, Alice & Jack emerges as a defiant anti-romance vision likely to polarize yet reward patient audiences with an utterly unique portrait of dysfunction.
PROS
- Powerful lead performances from Andrea Riseborough and Domhnall Gleeson
- Visually striking cinematography and direction
- Melancholic, emotionally intense mood and atmosphere
- Ambitious and uncompromising creative vision
- Ruthlessly honest depiction of dysfunctional relationships
CONS
- Unlikeable, frustrating lead characters
- Self-indulgent, pretentious dialogue
- Lack of chemistry between the central couple
- Plot and character motivations strain believability
- Extremely bleak tone with no catharsis
