• Latest
  • Trending
Materialists Review

Materialists Review: Deconstructing the Dating Game

Justin Baldoni Blake Lively

Judge Scraps Justin Baldoni’s $400 Million Defamation Case Against Blake Lively

7 minutes ago
Wicked

Wicked: For Good Trailer Soars to 113 Million Views, Sets Record for Musical Films

10 minutes ago
S.W.A.T

Shemar Moore Leads S.W.A.T. Exiles as Sony Orders 10-Episode Spinoff

13 minutes ago
Love Island: Beyond The Villa

Peacock Dates July 13 Debut for Love Island: Beyond the Villa

17 minutes ago
Magic City: An American Fantasy

Starz Schedules August 15 Premiere for Five-Part Magic City Docuseries

21 minutes ago
SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review

SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review: Bring a Friend or Go Home Hungry

Art Detectives Review

Art Detectives Review: The Case of the Brilliant Man and the Underwritten Woman

Paradise Records Review

Paradise Records Review: Spinning a ’90s Tune with Modern Charm

How to Train Your Dragon Review

How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

Meteors Review

Meteors Review: Two Friends on a Collision Course

Call Her Alex Review

Call Her Alex Review: Hulu’s Frustrating Look at a Media Titan

Grandma, No! Review

Grandma, No! Review: More Mess Than Mirth

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Gazettely Review Guidelines
Monday, June 9, 2025
GAZETTELY
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Justin Baldoni Blake Lively

    Judge Scraps Justin Baldoni’s $400 Million Defamation Case Against Blake Lively

    Wicked

    Wicked: For Good Trailer Soars to 113 Million Views, Sets Record for Musical Films

    S.W.A.T

    Shemar Moore Leads S.W.A.T. Exiles as Sony Orders 10-Episode Spinoff

    Love Island: Beyond The Villa

    Peacock Dates July 13 Debut for Love Island: Beyond the Villa

    Magic City: An American Fantasy

    Starz Schedules August 15 Premiere for Five-Part Magic City Docuseries

    Henry Cavill

    Cavill Promises Fidelity as Amazon Maps Warhammer 40K Universe

    Goat Sony Pictures

    All-Star Voice Cast Revealed as Sony Dates GOAT for NBA Weekend

    Tony Awards 2025

    “Maybe Happy Ending” Tops Tony Awards as History-Making Wins Sweep Broadway

    Sarah Snook

    Sarah Snook May Reprise Record-Breaking ‘Dorian Gray’ for Big Screen

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Art Detectives Review

    Art Detectives Review: The Case of the Brilliant Man and the Underwritten Woman

    Paradise Records Review

    Paradise Records Review: Spinning a ’90s Tune with Modern Charm

    How to Train Your Dragon Review

    How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

    Materialists Review

    Materialists Review: Deconstructing the Dating Game

    Meteors Review

    Meteors Review: Two Friends on a Collision Course

    Call Her Alex Review

    Call Her Alex Review: Hulu’s Frustrating Look at a Media Titan

    The Gold Season 2 Review

    The Gold Season 2 Review: Chasing the Ghosts of a Golden Curse

    To Barcelona, With Love Review

    To Barcelona, With Love Review: The Ghostwriter in the Bodega

    Mob Cops Review

    Mob Cops Review: All Exposition, No Execution

  • Game Reviews
    SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review

    SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review: Bring a Friend or Go Home Hungry

    Grandma, No! Review

    Grandma, No! Review: More Mess Than Mirth

    Among The Whispers - Provocation Review

    Among The Whispers – Provocation Review: More Detective Than Ghost Hunter

    Into the Restless Ruins Review

    Into the Restless Ruins Review: An Architect of Your Own Demise

    Lies of P: Overture Review

    Lies of P: Overture Review – A Perfect, Paradoxical Prelude

    Star Wars Outlaws: A Pirate’s Fortune Review

    Star Wars Outlaws: A Pirate’s Fortune Review – Hondo’s Best Outing Yet

    Mario Kart World Review

    Mario Kart World Review: The Thrill of the Race, The Emptiness of the Road

    POPUCOM Review

    POPUCOM Review: A Creative Co-op Masterpiece with Flaws

    Without a Dawn Review

    Without a Dawn Review: Introspection in a Cabin of Shadows

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Justin Baldoni Blake Lively

    Judge Scraps Justin Baldoni’s $400 Million Defamation Case Against Blake Lively

    Wicked

    Wicked: For Good Trailer Soars to 113 Million Views, Sets Record for Musical Films

    S.W.A.T

    Shemar Moore Leads S.W.A.T. Exiles as Sony Orders 10-Episode Spinoff

    Love Island: Beyond The Villa

    Peacock Dates July 13 Debut for Love Island: Beyond the Villa

    Magic City: An American Fantasy

    Starz Schedules August 15 Premiere for Five-Part Magic City Docuseries

    Henry Cavill

    Cavill Promises Fidelity as Amazon Maps Warhammer 40K Universe

    Goat Sony Pictures

    All-Star Voice Cast Revealed as Sony Dates GOAT for NBA Weekend

    Tony Awards 2025

    “Maybe Happy Ending” Tops Tony Awards as History-Making Wins Sweep Broadway

    Sarah Snook

    Sarah Snook May Reprise Record-Breaking ‘Dorian Gray’ for Big Screen

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Art Detectives Review

    Art Detectives Review: The Case of the Brilliant Man and the Underwritten Woman

    Paradise Records Review

    Paradise Records Review: Spinning a ’90s Tune with Modern Charm

    How to Train Your Dragon Review

    How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

    Materialists Review

    Materialists Review: Deconstructing the Dating Game

    Meteors Review

    Meteors Review: Two Friends on a Collision Course

    Call Her Alex Review

    Call Her Alex Review: Hulu’s Frustrating Look at a Media Titan

    The Gold Season 2 Review

    The Gold Season 2 Review: Chasing the Ghosts of a Golden Curse

    To Barcelona, With Love Review

    To Barcelona, With Love Review: The Ghostwriter in the Bodega

    Mob Cops Review

    Mob Cops Review: All Exposition, No Execution

  • Game Reviews
    SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review

    SEDAP! A Culinary Adventure Review: Bring a Friend or Go Home Hungry

    Grandma, No! Review

    Grandma, No! Review: More Mess Than Mirth

    Among The Whispers - Provocation Review

    Among The Whispers – Provocation Review: More Detective Than Ghost Hunter

    Into the Restless Ruins Review

    Into the Restless Ruins Review: An Architect of Your Own Demise

    Lies of P: Overture Review

    Lies of P: Overture Review – A Perfect, Paradoxical Prelude

    Star Wars Outlaws: A Pirate’s Fortune Review

    Star Wars Outlaws: A Pirate’s Fortune Review – Hondo’s Best Outing Yet

    Mario Kart World Review

    Mario Kart World Review: The Thrill of the Race, The Emptiness of the Road

    POPUCOM Review

    POPUCOM Review: A Creative Co-op Masterpiece with Flaws

    Without a Dawn Review

    Without a Dawn Review: Introspection in a Cabin of Shadows

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
GAZETTELY
No Result
View All Result
Materialists Review

Meteors Review: Two Friends on a Collision Course

How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

Home Entertainment Movies

Materialists Review: Deconstructing the Dating Game

Zhi Ho by Zhi Ho
3 hours ago
in Entertainment, Movies, Reviews
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on WhatsAppShare on Telegram

In a city like New York, every choice can feel like a transaction, and love is no exception. Celine Song’s Materialists plants its flag firmly on this uncomfortable ground. We follow Lucy, a matchmaker for the city’s elite, who operates less like a cupid and more like a high-stakes systems analyst.

Her job is to pair wealthy clients by running the numbers—income, status, height—and her core philosophy is that a stable partnership is a well-executed equation, not a matter of unpredictable passion. She has designed a life built on this pragmatic principle.

Any good system, however, can be broken by unexpected inputs. For Lucy, they arrive in the form of two men. One is Harry, a wealthy “unicorn” who represents the logical endpoint of her entire philosophy, a perfect match on paper who is interested in her. The other is John, her ex-boyfriend, a broke but passionate artist who represents a past she deliberately left behind.

The film immediately establishes a choice not just between two men, but between two fundamentally different operating systems for a life. It forces her, and us, to confront a stark question: when you’ve built a career quantifying human connection, what happens when your own heart introduces a variable that defies calculation?

Dating as a Dialogue Tree

The film’s central “hub world” is the matchmaking agency, Adore, and it’s a masterclass in environmental storytelling. At first glance, the office is all feminine energy and celebratory bar carts. But stay a moment longer, and you see the truth: the desks are cramped and look ready to collapse, the bar cart itself is wobbly.

It’s a flawless visual metaphor for the precarious relationships the agency builds. Here, love is gamified. Clients are reduced to character sheets (“Peter C,” “Charlotte B”), and compatibility is a checklist of stats. A marriage isn’t a union; it’s a successful merger, the “quest completed” screen for a long campaign.

Celine Song uses sharp, witty montages of client consultations that feel like watching a player navigate a series of dialogue trees with very specific win conditions. Much like a BioWare RPG, choosing the “right” options leads to romantic progression, while one wrong move can lock you out of a questline.

We see women who require a certain height attribute and men who will only accept partners under a specific level cap. Lucy is the master of this system. Her pronouncement to a client, “You’re not ugly, you just don’t have money,” isn’t just a line; it’s the game’s core mechanic revealed in plain sight.

She understands the rules better than anyone. This establishes a world governed by a brutal, clear logic. But it also makes you wonder about the emotional toll of a game where the primary objective is to market yourself as the ultimate prize.

Two Competing Questlines

Every great RPG presents the player with a critical choice, and for Lucy, the re-emergence of her ex-boyfriend John is like finding an old, abandoned questline suddenly active in her journal. John, played with a compelling weariness by Chris Evans, is the path not taken.

Materialists Review

He is a struggling actor, and a flashback to a disastrous, cash-strapped anniversary dinner serves as the ‘failed mission’ log that explains why Lucy abandoned this route years ago. He represents a high-risk, high-reward emotional build—all passion, but with terrible loot.

In stark contrast is Harry, the main quest the game seems to be pushing Lucy toward. As played by Pedro Pascal, he is the ultimate “unicorn”—a wealthy, suave partner who lives in a penthouse that feels like a premium unlockable area. He even shares her transactional view of love, making him a systems-approved match.

There’s a telling moment where Lucy, in his apartment for the first time, seems more captivated by the real estate than the romance, like a player marveling at the high-resolution textures of a new zone.

This setup moves beyond a simple love triangle. It’s a conflict that reminds me of the Paragon/Renegade choices in Mass Effect. Harry is the logical, orderly Paragon path that promises stability. John is the chaotic, emotional Renegade path that threatens to upend the entire system.

Lucy’s struggle isn’t about picking a guy; it’s about choosing her character build. Does she stick with the pragmatic, optimized version of herself she has become, or does she respec and embrace the passionate, unpredictable person she left behind? The film poses a fascinating question about whether we are defined by the path we are currently on, or by the one we can never quite delete from our quest log.

Rendering Two Realities

Celine Song directs with the precision of a thoughtful game designer; nothing is left to chance. The sharp, naturalistic dialogue carries the narrative weight, avoiding clumsy exposition and instead letting the film’s ideas breathe. This confidence in the script allows the cinematography and sound to do some heavy lifting. The film essentially renders two entirely different versions of New York, each with its own visual and audio language, depending on which man Lucy is with.

Materialists Review

Cinematographer Shabier Kirchner shoots scenes with Harry with a pristine, stable quality, like a polished pre-rendered cutscene. It’s a world of perfect lighting and expensive objects. By contrast, scenes with John feel like raw gameplay footage: the camera is roving and dynamic, capturing the grit and unpredictable ambient sounds of the city.

Daniel Pemberton’s gentle score acts as the main emotional soundtrack, but it’s the choice needle-drops—a technique used to great effect in another great anti-rom-com, The Worst Person in the World—that punctuate key moments.

It’s a design choice that recalls how different districts in a game like Cyberpunk 2077 have their own distinct aesthetic and soundscape. The craft is so effective at building these two separate worlds that you start to wonder if Lucy is choosing between two men, or simply deciding which reality she’d rather inhabit.

Breathing Life into the Code

A narrative structure this clear-cut lives or dies by its performances, and the trio at the heart of Materialists succeed by making their archetypes feel human. They take what could be simple character classes and give them complex, unpredictable inner lives.

Materialists Review

Dakota Johnson anchors the film, moving beyond her usual on-screen persona with a sharp, forceful energy. Her cool, professional front is a perfectly calibrated defense mechanism, and the real art is in how she lets the cracks show, revealing the vulnerable, doubting person beneath the polished avatar.

This film also feels like a fantastic “character select” screen for its male leads. Chris Evans completely sheds his blockbuster skin, imbuing the struggling artist John with a tender exhaustion that feels painfully authentic. It’s the lingering love tangled with the bitterness of failure that makes him so resonant.

Meanwhile, Pedro Pascal ensures Harry is more than just a rich suitor with maxed-out stats. He brings a guarded, almost sad quality to the “unicorn,” hinting at his own unseen baggage. It’s the kind of subtle work that recalls the best performances in narrative games like The Last of Us, where the voice actors infuse every line with a history that isn’t explicitly scripted. Because these actors make their characters feel so real, Lucy’s choice stops being a theoretical exercise. It becomes a deeply human dilemma with no easy answer.

When the System Breaks

For much of the film, Lucy’s transactional world operates like a clean, well-designed game. Then, the system breaks. The subplot involving her client Sophie, who suffers a traumatic ordeal on a date Lucy arranged, is the critical failure that sends the whole machine haywire.

Materialists Review

It’s a devastating narrative beat, reminiscent of the gut-punch moments in games like Spec Ops: The Line, where a player is suddenly forced to confront the horrific human cost of their in-game actions. Sophie’s accusation that Lucy is a “pimp” shatters the professional abstraction, revealing the ugly truth beneath.

The film smartly avoids a simple fairytale ending. Instead of a perfect score, it offers something quieter and more authentic. It suggests that finding genuine value in another person isn’t about mastering the existing game. It’s about recognizing that the game itself is rigged. The story leaves you with the idea that perhaps the only way to truly win is to stop playing by the established rules and start writing your own.

Full Credits

Director: Celine Song

Writers: Celine Song

Producers and Executive Producers: David Hinojosa, Christine Vachon, Pamela Koffler, Celine Song, Timo Argillander, Len Blavatnik, Taylor Shung, Danny Cohen, Andrea Scarso

Cast: Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, Pedro Pascal, Zoë Winters, Marin Ireland, Dasha Nekrasova, Louisa Jacobson, Sawyer Spielberg, Eddie Cahill, Joseph Lee, John Magaro

Director of Photography (Cinematographer): Shabier Kirchner

Editors: Keith Fraase

Composer: Daniel Pemberton

The Review

Materialists

8.5 Score

Materialists brilliantly disguises a sharp, cynical drama as a glossy rom-com. Celine Song crafts a world where love is a system to be gamed, using thoughtful direction and a razor-sharp script to explore the transactional nature of modern relationships. Anchored by three fantastic, layered performances that breathe life into the code, the film is a deeply intelligent and emotionally resonant examination of how we quantify human value. It’s a stellar follow-up for Song that challenges its audience more than it comforts them, and is all the better for it.

PROS

  • An intelligent script that smartly subverts romantic-comedy expectations.
  • Layered, compelling performances from Dakota Johnson, Chris Evans, and Pedro Pascal.
  • Stylish and deliberate direction that uses cinematic language to enhance its themes.
  • A thought-provoking and timely exploration of love, money, and self-worth.

CONS

  • Pacing falters slightly with some predictable late-film plot resolutions.
  • Its serious, analytical tone may alienate viewers seeking a light-hearted romance.

Review Breakdown

  • Overall 0
Tags: 2AMA24Celine SongChris EvansComedyDakota JohnsonDasha NekrasovaFeaturedKiller FilmsLouisa JacobsonMarin IrelandMaterialistsPedro PascalRomanceSawyer SpielbergTop PickZoë Winters
Previous Post

Meteors Review: Two Friends on a Collision Course

Next Post

How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

Try AI Movie Recommender

Gazettely AI Movie Recommender

This Week's Top Reads

  • Boglands Review

    Boglands Review: Shadows and Whispers in the Irish Mist

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Amongst the Wolves Review: A Gritty yet Compassionate Directorial Debut

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Stick Season 1 Review: Owen Wilson Drives a Heartfelt, Flawed Dramedy

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mad Unicorn Review: Ambition and Its Echoes in the Global Stream

    5 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Survivors Season 1 Review: A Town Drowning in Secrets

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Death Valley Review: A Witty Welsh Wander into Cosy Crime

    3 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Mortician Season 1 Review: Inside a House of Horrors and Profiteering

    7 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Must Read Articles

How to Train Your Dragon Review
Movies

How to Train Your Dragon Review: Recapturing Lightning in a Live-Action Bottle

2 hours ago
Materialists Review
Movies

Materialists Review: Deconstructing the Dating Game

3 hours ago
The Gold Season 2 Review
TV Shows

The Gold Season 2 Review: Chasing the Ghosts of a Golden Curse

5 hours ago
Mario Kart World Review
Reviews Games

Mario Kart World Review: The Thrill of the Race, The Emptiness of the Road

2 days ago
Echo Valley Review
Movies

Echo Valley Review: Moore Shines in a Flawed Thriller

2 days ago
Loading poll ...
Coming Soon
Who is the best director in the horror thriller genre?

Gazettely is your go-to destination for all things gaming, movies, and TV. With fresh reviews, trending articles, and editor picks, we help you stay informed and entertained.

© 2021-2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

What’s Inside

  • Movie & TV Reviews
  • Game Reviews
  • Featured Articles
  • Latest News
  • Editorial Picks

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About US
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Review Guidelines

Follow Us

Facebook X-twitter Youtube Instagram
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movies
  • Entertainment News
  • Movie and TV Reviews
  • TV Shows
  • Game News
  • Game Reviews
  • Contact Us

© 2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

Go to mobile version