For over 25 years, the Pokémon series of role-playing video games has captured the imaginations of players around the world. Originally launched in 1996 for the Game Boy, Pokémon Red and Blue introduced us to a world of magical creatures that could be caught, trained, and battled. Since then, the franchise has steadily built upon its monster-catching foundation to become one of the most popular and beloved gaming brands of all time.
But which Pokémon RPGs stand out as the very best? In this ranking, we will look back on the storied history of mainline Pokémon games and highlight those that made the biggest splashes, innovated the series in exciting ways, and crafted the most complete and rewarding Pokémon journeys. We’ll be considering each generation’s initial paired versions as well as third definitive editions in tandem. From the Ground-type classics to the Dragon-type modern hits, these are our picks for the greatest Pokémon role-playing adventures so far.
To assemble this list, we weighed a number of factors that make a Pokémon game truly exceptional. Of course, sheer nostalgic value played a key role, as did the innovations and new features introduced in each generation. We also considered core gameplay mechanics, longevity, professional reviews from the era of release, and general fan reception both then and now. Focus was strictly placed on main series RPG titles, not spinoff genres like dungeon crawlers, racing games, or pinball.
Within each generation, we grouped together the initial pair of games as well as the enhanced third definitive version for the purposes of ranking. For example, Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow were weighed as a whole versus Gold, Silver, and Crystal. This accounts for how the third versions improve upon the original pair with new content and quality of life changes that, together, define the generation’s overall quality and contribution to the series.
With the criteria established, we journeyed through 25 years of Pokémon history to crown the very best Pokémon video games. Let’s begin the challenge!
#10 – Pokémon Black and White (DS)
When Pokémon Black and White released for the Nintendo DS in 2010, it marked the first time a new generation of Pokémon games debuted on a console that already had Pokémon titles. As the successors to the wildly popular Diamond and Pearl on DS, Black and White had a lot to live up to. While the games introduced a brand new region called Unova stocked with around 150 inventive new Pokémon designs, the core gameplay stuck very closely to the established formula. This led some critics and fans to feel that the series was potentially stagnating or becoming repetitive.
Still, for as iterative as they were, Black and White made some smart evolutions to the Pokémon RPG blueprint. Most notably, the games incorporated seasonal cycles into the maps – a first for the series. As seasons changed, routes would visually transform and certain Pokémon would become easier or harder to find. Black and White also introduced triple battles, allowing teams of three Pokémon on each side for new strategic depth. Small touches like animated sprites in and out of combat helped spice things up as well.
However, the core loop of journeying from town to town to collect badges and catch ’em all persisted, for better or worse. There was a sense that the Pokémon developers played it safe with Black and White, delivering more of the same experience when players may have been hungry for bolder innovation. As a result, though they reviewed well and sold massively, Black and White sometimes get labeled as the beginning of a creative downturn for the iconic RPG franchise.
#9 – Pokémon Diamond and Pearl (DS)
When Pokémon made its first foray onto the Nintendo DS in 2006, the potential to take the series online thanks to the handheld’s Wi-Fi capabilities was incredibly enticing. Pokémon Diamond and Pearl seized that opportunity by introducing the Global Trade Station (or GTS), allowing far-flung players to trade their Pokémon over the internet for the first time ever. No longer were fans dependent on Link Cables – now they had the whole world of trainers at their fingertips to find that elusive version-exclusive monster.
Beyond the pioneering online features, however, Diamond and Pearl played as extremely traditional sequels. The Sinnoh region touted 107 new Pokémon in the Pokédex, with a decent smattering of dual-type creatures. But the core experience remained largely identical to predecessors. Even the graphical upgrade to DS wasn’t pushed especially far compared to contemporaries like Mario or Zelda. Most critics considered Diamond and Pearl well-made, if predictable and unambitious.
Last year’s remakes Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl for Switch duplicated Diamond and Pearl with enhanced fidelity. But the games were criticized for sticking too closely to the originals and passing up opportunities for meaningful innovation. Still, the foundation remains strong, and getting to originally adventure through Sinnoh with online trading capabilities was a milestone for the franchise at the time. It kept the series moving forward while clinging hard to its proven puzzle-solving RPG core.
#8 – Pokémon Sun and Moon (3DS)
When Pokémon Sun and Moon released for the 3DS in 2016, they transported players to the lush, tropical Alola region. Inspired by the real-world Hawaii, Alola was a vibrant and exciting new land filled with unique traditions, island challenges, and quirky characters. After years of exploring regions based on Japan, Sun and Moon’s fresh setting and cast helped reinvigorate the storied RPG franchise.
On top of the new coats of paint, Sun and Moon made some fan-friendly mechanical improvements as well. Character customization saw a notable upgrade, with far more options to personalize your avatar than in any previous Pokémon game. The games also introduced Alolan form Pokémon – regional variants of classic monsters like Raichu and Exeggutor that took on new appearances and types adapted to the environment.
While Sun and Moon didn’t overhaul the Pokémon formula, they proved the series still had surprises up its sleeve. Unique island trials replaced traditional gyms, Totem Pokémon presented impactful mid-dungeon boss battles, and the slowly unfolding mystery behind the legendaries and island guardians all built to an exciting crescendo.
Just a year later, Game Freak followed up Sun and Moon with enhanced versions called Ultra Sun and Ultra Moon. These incorporated a handful of new features, like extra Alolan forms and the excellent Mantine surfing minigame, though the differences were marginal. Still, Sun and Moon remain excellent examples of breathing new life into the Pokémon RPG structure without fundamentally altering the core essence fans loved.
#7 – Pokémon Sword and Shield (Switch)
When the Pokémon series made its proper debut on Nintendo Switch in 2019 with Pokémon Sword and Shield, fans were eager to see what cutting-edge innovations the powerful new hardware would enable. Controversially, the major change Game Freak touted before release was pruning the Pokédex, as Sword and Shield would not support importing or catching every single previous Pokémon. Only the new Galarian regional forms and additions to the Pokédex would be obtainable.
This change caused some consternation within the Pokémon community initially. However, once players dove into the Galar region, most deemed the streamlined Pokédex a reasonable concession. The games still included over 80 new Pokémon alongside 13 regional variants, introducing interesting monsters like Wooloo, Corviknight, and Yamper. Even without every Pokémon available, there was plenty of catching to do.
Sword and Shield did deliver compelling new features, like the Wild Area – vast open landscapes teeming with roaming Pokémon. Max Raid battles let groups of players team up to take down gigantic Dynamax Pokémon. The expansions Isle of Armor and Crown Tundra then reintroduced many past legendary Pokémon through engrossing post-game content. Though different, Sword and Shield brought the core monster battling experience to Switch in grand style.
#6 – Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire (GBA)
When Pokémon jumped to the Game Boy Advance in 2002 with Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, it marked the end of the series’ 16-bit era. The expanded graphical capabilities of the GBA allowed Ruby and Sapphire to finally depict the Pokémon world in full color. Sprites were more vibrant, environments were richer, and small animations breathed new life into battles and cutscenes. After two generations on Game Boy, the visual overhaul made the Hoenn region feel totally modern.
Beyond presentation, Ruby and Sapphire introduced several new gameplay concepts that became franchise staples. Abilities like Flash Fire and Huge Power added passive effects that could influence battle strategy. Natures modified a Pokémon’s stats to make each feel slightly more unique. Double battles let players pit two Pokémon against two at once.
However, Ruby and Sapphire also removed some popular features that left certain fans disappointed. The day/night cycle from Gold and Silver was axed, limiting encounters based on time of day. And the lack of connectivity to older Game Boy Pokémon titles meant leaving your classic monsters behind – the first major lack of backwards compatibility.
While divisive in some regards, Ruby and Sapphire succeeded in transitioning Pokémon into the 32-bit era. Visually impressive with some smart mechanical additions, Ruby and Sapphire laid strong foundations for the Advance-based games that followed. And the Hoenn region’s tropical landscapes, abundant water routes, quirky evil teams, and bevy of legendary titans made it one of the most memorable Pokémon worlds.
#5 – Pokémon X and Y (3DS)
As the first mainline Pokémon RPGs built for the Nintendo 3DS, 2013’s Pokémon X and Y had big shoes to fill. Not only did the game mark the series’ first steps into 3D, expectations were high that Game Freak would implement ambitious new features to justify Kalos on the new hardware. On both fronts, X and Y largely delivered.
The Kalos region absolutely dazzled, bringing Pokémon to full polygonal life for the first time. Cities glistened, battle animations popped, and seeing familiar monsters from new camera angles added cinematic flair to the iconic turn-based battles. Mega Evolutions unlocked temporary powered-up forms for fully evolved Pokémon, adding strategic considerations. And the new Fairy typing helped balance the meta by countering Dragon-types.
On top of the major changes, X and Y came packed with bonus content and quality of life changes. Super Training made EV and IV optimization more accessible. Sky Battles took fights to the air against Flying-types. Horde battles let you battle swarms of low-level Pokémon for quick XP. And mini-games like Pokémon-Amie let you bond with your Pokémon.
While the story didn’t introduce many new innovations, the move to 3D alone made X and Y feel like the bold new era many fans hoped for. Stacked with features and bursting with colors and life, X and Y shone as one of the brightest examples of Pokémon on a new Nintendo handheld.
#4 – Pokémon Legends: Arceus (Switch)
Of all the Pokémon video games, 2022’s Pokémon Legends: Arceus marked the most radical reinvention of the tried-and-true monster catching formula since the franchise debuted in 1996. Set in the feudal Hisui region that would eventually become Sinnoh, Arceus’s open-world structure, real-time battles, and free-roaming Pokémon fundamentally changed how the longstanding RPG systems operated. Nearly everything fans took for granted was rethought and rebuilt from the ground up.
Instead of turn-based random encounters, wild Pokémon visibly inhabit Hisui’s rich biomes, letting you observe behaviors and catch them more organically via action-based mechanics. Battles seamlessly occur against monsters directly on the overworld. Stealth, decoys, and specialized Poké Balls add nuance to the capturing process. Ancient variants of familiar species helped create an evolutionary offshoot timeline centuries before modern Pokémon settings.
By abandoning rigid structures and traditions, Arceus enabled a spirit of freedom and discovery that invigorated the time-tested Pokémon loop. Exploration was rewarding thanks to crafting items from gathered materials and filling the first real open-world Pokédex. The reimagined turn-based battle system remained deep but more dynamically connected to environments. Even with familiar faces from the Sinnoh region, Arceus managed to make catching Pokémon feel fresh again.
As the most experimental and mold-breaking Pokémon RPG ever, Arceus proved to hesitant fans that significant reinvention was truly possible while retaining the signature series charm. It laid exciting foundations for the future while celebrating the franchise’s mythical past.
#3 – Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow (GB)
It all started here. When Pokémon Red and Blue released outside of Japan in 1998, they introduced the world to a stunningly original concept: a story-driven RPG centered around capturing, training, and battling inventive monsters called Pokémon. With charming 8-bit visuals, elaborate stat systems, and highly addictive collection mechanics, Red and Blue laid the blueprint for decades of portable role-playing greatness.
The 151 original Pokémon designs ran an impressive gamut – from cute and cool to weird and sinister. Clever balance between Pokémon types meant constructing a balanced team took time and knowledge. Moves, evolutions, and growth mechanics had wonderful depth. The save-the-world narrative that unfolded between the main quest and post-game set compelling stakes. And the ability to trade Pokémon between Red and Blue encouraged social engagement and community bonding.
Pokémon Yellow followed shortly after, recreating Red and Blue in the anime’s image. Letting Pikachu follow you everywhere and weaving in familiar characters injected additional flavor without sacrificing the games’ splendid balance. Pairing addictive monster catching systems with thoughtful turn-based battling, Red, Blue, and Yellow crafted a gameplay loop for the ages. The Pocket Monsters franchise has come incredibly far since, but it could never have become a worldwide phenomenon without these pioneering 8-bit RPGs.
#2 – Pokémon Gold, Silver, and Crystal (GBC)
When Pokémon Gold and Silver released for the Game Boy Color in 2000, they built upon the rock-solid foundation of Red and Blue while innovating the monster collecting formula in exciting new ways. Gold and Silver struck a perfect balance – delivering 100 excellent new Pokémon plus fan favorites in an all new Johto region, while also integrating many brand new features that became core tenets of the franchise.
The time and day mechanics added immersive depth, with certain Pokémon only appearing at specific hours. Introducing new Dark and Steel-type Pokémon balanced the game systems. Hold items granted passive bonuses during battle. Pokémon now bred, producing eggs with inheritable moves and stats. Shiny Pokémon offered ultra-rare alternate color variants. And being able to travel back to Kanto after becoming Champion provided a staggering amount of content.
Then Pokémon Crystal came a year later, enhancing Gold and Silver with key additions like the choice to play as a male or female trainer. Alongside smaller improvements to storytelling and presentation, Crystal allowed players to fully experience Johto and Kanto in a more polished package. HeartGold and SoulSilver for DS later remade the second generation games faithfully and beautifully.
With enormous regions to explore, long-lasting RPG mechanics, and two generations of monsters to catch, Gold, Silver, and Crystal represented Pokémon reaching its full potential. The sequels masterfully augmented Red and Blue’s blueprint to craft the deepest and most rewarding Pokémon adventures yet at the time, voted by fans as some of the finest games in the storied series.
#1 – Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen (GBA)
For many Pokémon fans, nothing beats the nostalgia of the original 151 Pokémon from the Kanto region. Thus, when enhanced remakes Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen launched in 2004, they represented the perfect confluence of nostalgic bliss and modern upgrades. FireRed and LeafGreen took fans back to the beginning, while introducing numerous quality of life improvements that truly made Kanto feel definitive.
The vibrant 32-bit visual overhaul made every classic location pop with new flair. Conveniences like PC item storage reduced old frustrations. Dizzying expansions to move sets, items, abilities, natures, and more brought new battling depth without sacrificing simplicity. The Sevii Islands postgame content extended the adventure. And crucially, FireRed and LeafGreen allowed connectivity with the Hoenn-based Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald – expanding your arsenal of collectable creatures.
No Pokémon remakes before or since have so expertly balanced honoring the source material with enriching it for the modern era. From the charming chiptunes to the iconic sprites, FireRed and LeafGreen let us rediscover Kanto with fresh eyes while retaining every ounce of nostalgic glory. For these reasons and more, FireRed and LeafGreen emerge as the quintessential entries to revisit for the ultimate, unforgettable Pokémon adventure.
Pokémon Stands the Test of Time
Over 25 years, the Pokémon series has steadily built upon itself with each new generation – introducing fresh features and quality of life improvements that result in increasingly polished gameplay experiences. Modern entries like Pokémon Legends: Arceus showcase just how far the franchise has come from modest origins.
Yet throughout its evolution, that original simple charm of catching Pokémon to create your dream team still shines through. The sheer variety of collectible monsters, the addictive grind of growth and discovery, and the gratification of strategic battling remain core to the formula. This ranking has illustrated how the very best Pokémon RPGs are those that blend nostalgia and innovation in harmony – whether revamping the past like FireRed and LeafGreen or revolutionizing systems like Arceus.
Ultimately, Pokémon games are about setting out on grand adventures, catching fascinating creatures, and forging lasting bonds. This winning combination ensures collecting gym badges remains engaging and fun for diehard Trainers and newcomers alike. Here’s to another 25 years of catching ’em all across fantastical new Pokémon worlds.
