• Latest
  • Trending
Boneyard Review

Boneyard Review: A Flawed Yet Well-Intentioned Tribute

Terrifier-4

Damien Leone Pledges Epic Backstory Reveal in Terrifier 4

13 minutes ago
Mountainhead

Armstrong’s Tech Billionaire Black Comedy Mountainhead Goes Live on Max at 3 a.m. ET

21 minutes ago
Donald J. Trump and diddy

Donald Trump Open to Diddy Pardon Amid Sex-Trafficking Trial

27 minutes ago
Karate Kid: Legends

Jonathan Entwistle on Crafting a Standalone Karate Kid Tale with a Nostalgic Twist

35 minutes ago
Your Friends and Neighbors

Apple TV+ Fast-Tracks Your Friends and Neighbors Season 2 for Spring 2026

1 hour ago
Day of Reckoning Review

Day of Reckoning Review: Archetypes Under Pressure in a Modern West

The Hunt Review

The Hunt Review: Charting 13 Years of Trauma and Division

Destination X Review

Destination X Review: A Game of Veiled Realities

Spray Paint Simulator Review

Spray Paint Simulator Review: Coating the Town, One Careful Layer at a Time

Tim Travers the Time Travelers Paradox Review

Tim Travers & the Time Travelers Paradox Review: Samuel Dunning Stars (and Stars, and Stars…)

Earnhardt Review

Earnhardt Review: The Anatomy of a NASCAR Titan

the last of us season 2

Laughs and Gasps: Fans Split on The Last of Us Season-Finale Tone

11 hours ago
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Gazettely Review Guidelines
Saturday, May 31, 2025
GAZETTELY
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Terrifier-4

    Damien Leone Pledges Epic Backstory Reveal in Terrifier 4

    Mountainhead

    Armstrong’s Tech Billionaire Black Comedy Mountainhead Goes Live on Max at 3 a.m. ET

    Donald J. Trump and diddy

    Donald Trump Open to Diddy Pardon Amid Sex-Trafficking Trial

    Karate Kid: Legends

    Jonathan Entwistle on Crafting a Standalone Karate Kid Tale with a Nostalgic Twist

    Your Friends and Neighbors

    Apple TV+ Fast-Tracks Your Friends and Neighbors Season 2 for Spring 2026

    the last of us season 2

    Laughs and Gasps: Fans Split on The Last of Us Season-Finale Tone

    Russell Brand

    Russell Brand Denies Historic Rape Charges in London Court

    Ming-Na Wen

    California-Shot “Mandalorian & Grogu” Eyes May Debut, Casting Rumors Swirl

    Nine Puzzles

    Disney+ Crime Hit Nine Puzzles Races Past Records in First Week

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Day of Reckoning Review

    Day of Reckoning Review: Archetypes Under Pressure in a Modern West

    The Hunt Review

    The Hunt Review: Charting 13 Years of Trauma and Division

    Destination X Review

    Destination X Review: A Game of Veiled Realities

    Tim Travers the Time Travelers Paradox Review

    Tim Travers & the Time Travelers Paradox Review: Samuel Dunning Stars (and Stars, and Stars…)

    Earnhardt Review

    Earnhardt Review: The Anatomy of a NASCAR Titan

    The Ritual Review

    The Ritual Review: An Unsettled Echo in a Somber Chamber

    Dept. Q Review

    Dept. Q Review: Edinburgh’s Gloom and a Detective’s Fractured Soul

    And Just Like That... Season 3 Review

    And Just Like That… Season 3 Review: A Stylish Step Forward, But Does It Go Far Enough?

    Sneaky Links Dating After Dark Review

    Sneaky Links: Dating After Dark Review: From Hookup to Hangup?

  • Game Reviews
    Spray Paint Simulator Review

    Spray Paint Simulator Review: Coating the Town, One Careful Layer at a Time

    F1 25 Review

    F1 25 Review: A Stunning Drive, If You Have the Right Rig

    Pipistrello and the Cursed Yoyo Review

    Pipistrello and the Cursed Yoyo Review: Whip-Smart Mechanics and Pixel Charm

    Elden Ring Nightreign Review

    Elden Ring Nightreign Review: Condensed Chaos for Tarnished Veterans

    Scar-Lead Salvation Review

    Scar-Lead Salvation Review: An Anime Perspective on a Rogue-like Path

    Fuga: Melodies of Steel 3 Review

    Fuga: Melodies of Steel 3 Review: The Taranis’s Final, Heartfelt Song

    Death end re;Quest Code Z Review

    Death end re;Quest Code Z Review: A Perilous Loop of Progress

    Wings of Endless Review

    Wings of Endless Review: More Than Just a Flight of Fancy?

    Creature Keeper Review

    Creature Keeper Review: A Keeper’s Tale of Ambition and Issues

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Terrifier-4

    Damien Leone Pledges Epic Backstory Reveal in Terrifier 4

    Mountainhead

    Armstrong’s Tech Billionaire Black Comedy Mountainhead Goes Live on Max at 3 a.m. ET

    Donald J. Trump and diddy

    Donald Trump Open to Diddy Pardon Amid Sex-Trafficking Trial

    Karate Kid: Legends

    Jonathan Entwistle on Crafting a Standalone Karate Kid Tale with a Nostalgic Twist

    Your Friends and Neighbors

    Apple TV+ Fast-Tracks Your Friends and Neighbors Season 2 for Spring 2026

    the last of us season 2

    Laughs and Gasps: Fans Split on The Last of Us Season-Finale Tone

    Russell Brand

    Russell Brand Denies Historic Rape Charges in London Court

    Ming-Na Wen

    California-Shot “Mandalorian & Grogu” Eyes May Debut, Casting Rumors Swirl

    Nine Puzzles

    Disney+ Crime Hit Nine Puzzles Races Past Records in First Week

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Day of Reckoning Review

    Day of Reckoning Review: Archetypes Under Pressure in a Modern West

    The Hunt Review

    The Hunt Review: Charting 13 Years of Trauma and Division

    Destination X Review

    Destination X Review: A Game of Veiled Realities

    Tim Travers the Time Travelers Paradox Review

    Tim Travers & the Time Travelers Paradox Review: Samuel Dunning Stars (and Stars, and Stars…)

    Earnhardt Review

    Earnhardt Review: The Anatomy of a NASCAR Titan

    The Ritual Review

    The Ritual Review: An Unsettled Echo in a Somber Chamber

    Dept. Q Review

    Dept. Q Review: Edinburgh’s Gloom and a Detective’s Fractured Soul

    And Just Like That... Season 3 Review

    And Just Like That… Season 3 Review: A Stylish Step Forward, But Does It Go Far Enough?

    Sneaky Links Dating After Dark Review

    Sneaky Links: Dating After Dark Review: From Hookup to Hangup?

  • Game Reviews
    Spray Paint Simulator Review

    Spray Paint Simulator Review: Coating the Town, One Careful Layer at a Time

    F1 25 Review

    F1 25 Review: A Stunning Drive, If You Have the Right Rig

    Pipistrello and the Cursed Yoyo Review

    Pipistrello and the Cursed Yoyo Review: Whip-Smart Mechanics and Pixel Charm

    Elden Ring Nightreign Review

    Elden Ring Nightreign Review: Condensed Chaos for Tarnished Veterans

    Scar-Lead Salvation Review

    Scar-Lead Salvation Review: An Anime Perspective on a Rogue-like Path

    Fuga: Melodies of Steel 3 Review

    Fuga: Melodies of Steel 3 Review: The Taranis’s Final, Heartfelt Song

    Death end re;Quest Code Z Review

    Death end re;Quest Code Z Review: A Perilous Loop of Progress

    Wings of Endless Review

    Wings of Endless Review: More Than Just a Flight of Fancy?

    Creature Keeper Review

    Creature Keeper Review: A Keeper’s Tale of Ambition and Issues

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
GAZETTELY
No Result
View All Result
Boneyard Review

"Chicago Med" Secures Return of Original Cast Members for Season 10

Float Season 2 Review: A Moving Exploration of Identity

Home Entertainment Movies

Boneyard Review: A Flawed Yet Well-Intentioned Tribute

When Good Intentions Don't Make a Good Film

Mahan Zahiri by Mahan Zahiri
11 months ago
in Entertainment, Movies, Reviews
Reading Time: 7 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on WhatsAppShare on Telegram

The 2024 film Boneyard drew inspiration from a haunting true crime case in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Between 2001 and 2005, eleven women and girls went missing in the area. Tragically, their remains were discovered four to eight years later, in 2009, buried in an arid stretch of desert known as the West Mesa. The victims, aged 15 to 32, had been sexually assaulted and brutally murdered. Though police questioned persons of interest, this heinous serial killer remained at large.

Directed by Asif Akbar, Boneyard tells a fictionalized story based on these unsolved West Mesa murders. It brought together anecdotally a cast led by Mel Gibson as an experienced FBI profiler named Pete and Curtis “50 Cent” Jackson as the local police chief. Gibson delivered a seasoned, gritty performance, but Jackson struggled more in his substantial role.

The movie followed police detectives and federal agents racing to identify the perpetrator before any other lives could be lost. Yet criticisms emerged that the multilayered plot juggled too many characters and subplots in its attempt to honor the real case. Overall, Boneyard decidedly respected the victims and general facts of its dark muse but fell short as a truly compelling thriller, perhaps due more to its writing than execution.

Boneyard’s Twisted Trail

Director Asif Akbar aimed to honor the true events that inspired Boneyard while shaping a story that kept viewers engaged. At the film’s center was the grisly discovery that unearthed unsolved killings from years past. Reawakening this cold case called seasoned lawmen to action once more.

Leading the charge were seasoned FBI profiler Pete and his local partners, Detectives Ortega and Young. Despite initial tensions, these detectives and feds tracked clues towards uncovering a serial offender. Their pursuit wove through a web of suspects, from unscrupulous cops to lonely outsiders viewed as possible perps.

Each character bore scars of their own relating to past tragedies, adding gravity to their mission. For Pete, especially, a personal need for answers to other unsolved crimes drove his determination. Through flashbacks, we saw what fueled different players to demand the truth.

Though most suspects proved false leads, the cat-and-mouse game kept viewers guessing. Twists left the real culprits’ identities in doubt until the end. Subplots detouring to explore side characters sometimes muddied the core mystery’s momentum. But richly drawn figures gave depth beyond stereotypes often seen.

While failing to solve the real West Mesa crimes, Akbar’s adaptation tugged the threads of this poignant case into a suspenseful yarn. Not every piece was neatly tied together, but his efforts reflected lives lost with compassion, not exploitation alone.

Strong Starts, Mixed Finishes

Director Asif Akbar clearly courted big names to captivate viewers, with Mel Gibson and 50 Cent topping the bill. Gibson lived up to the hype as seasoned FBI agent Pete, projecting grit and worldweariness through each scene. Despite his age, he stayed committed—one felt Pete’s drive to achieve justice.

Boneyard Review

Jackson nonetheless struggled in his sizable role as Police Chief Carter. Fine early, later lines felt stilted. While the part called for gravitas, his delivery didn’t convince. Thankfully, supporting work offsets this. Brian Van Holt owned the scenes as pragmatic lead detective Ortega, guiding action with composure. Nora Zehetner was equally absorbed as his partner, tackling roles with subtle skill.

Between them, these two detectives anchored the story’s human side. Their interplay gave the twists and turns a heart beyond procedural details alone. Elsewhere, Michael Sirow oozed smarm, playing unlikable Officer Tate to the hilt, while Camille Collard brought depth as streetwise Selena beyond what could’ve been a stock figure.

Minor roles too fleshed out the world, avoiding stereotypes. Subplots around department corruption felt realistic, not forced drama. Yet stretching character arcs too widely muddled some mysteries that might’ve stood out with tighter focus. And where the script left openings, not all grasped opportunities to shine through.

In the end, the director and cast aimed high by raising intricate issues, not exploiting true events. Strong starts made for an engaging, if imperfect, whole, with seasoned talents compensating where flaws arose. Not a masterpiece, but efforts to handle sensitive topics responsibly merit acknowledgement.

Flashes of Flair Amid Flaws

This film had flair to spare technically, even if structural flaws hindered it. Behind the camera, Asif Akbar toyed with styles that seemed fit for TV—handheld cameras whipping around chaotically. At its best, this lent an urgent realism. Yet less steady shots grew strained and distracted from the unfolding story.

Boneyard Review

Joshua Reis shot with an eye for atmosphere. Gritty scenes in Albuquerque’s urban sprawl or the desolate desert evoked a true sense of place. Clever contrasts between sepia-toned nostalgia and brighter hues poking through clouds pumped mystery into the air. But tonal shifts didn’t always align logically and muddied understanding at times.

Where visuals excelled, edits let suspense flag. RJ Cooper sliced sequences together at breakneck pace, keeping interest. But reflexive cutting overlooked establishing vital context, like how clues connected across the puzzle. The result felt half-finished—moments clicked, but the full picture stayed blurred.

Had these flavors fused into a cohesive vision, this could’ve been something special. As is, flashes of flair emerged but never joined to full effect. Strong images and tense patches hinted at depth, yet direction and structure failed to weave them tight. Creative styles served well individually, even if the whole remained less than the promising parts suggested. With surer hands shaping its potential, this tale of lives lost to violence might have lingered longer in memory.

Capturing a True Crime’s Essence

Boneyard aimed to honor the victims of a notoriously unsolved case. But crafting drama from reality often demands some departure from facts. So how closely did this film align with the disturbing true events that inspired it?

Boneyard Review

The West Mesa Bone Collector murders remain an open wound in Albuquerque. Between 2001 and 2005, 11 vulnerable women met untimely ends, their remains discarded in the desert. While suspects were interviewed, the perpetrator was never brought to justice. This grim puzzle left me pondering what horrors these souls endured and whether peace could come.

To weave a story around such darkness, the script took liberties. It condensed a five-year span into a more concentrated timeline and fashioned composite characters whose real identities were unknown. These changes permitted focusing on the narrative arc. However, the essence of the crimes remained the same: disadvantaged females went missing without explanation from the same forsaken place, leaving devastated families and a confounded community.

Boneyard also embraced the gruesome details that gave the real case its bone-chilling intrigue. Finding partial skeletons scattered across the waste ground conjured a shudder, as did considering the last moments these women knew. While heightened for drama, depictions of the killer stalking victims and their shallow roadside graves clung close to documented facts. This gritty verisimilitude gave weight to individualizing each lost soul, even through fiction.

Ultimately, the film honored the West Mesa 11 by keeping their nightmare at its core. Sticking to a basic timeline, location, and victimology ensured their stolen lives drove the larger tale, rather than being supplanted or forgotten. Within the constraints of crafting cinema, Boneyard authenticated the human toll of this mournful saga, affirming that some small solace can come from remembering the real people behind real tragedies.

True Crime’s Tragedy and Triumph

Boneyard delved into unsolved suffering, seeking meaning where justice failed. Its purpose? Honoring innocence stolen while proving darkness can inspire light if memory persists.

Boneyard Review

This thriller transported haunting realities yet left questions unanswered, as with the West Mesa 11 still awaiting salvation. Its narrative, though imperfect, kept sacrifice at the fore by humanizing each soul through name and qualities alone recalled.

Fragmented clues surveying the story stretched credulity at times. And fragmented storytelling stretched the tale thin, with plot sacrificed for character moments belabored. But character is all the real victims left behind. Therein lay the film’s victory—sustaining eleven faces in an audience’s mind and ensuring none faded nameless into the desert sand.

The film’s finale emerged fittingly bittersweet. Resolution remained distant as the crimes remained unsolved in life. But tribute preserved what investigation could not—a memorial reminding us that while monsters walk free, their prey live on in hearts unwilling to forget. Some good can rise, it seems, from memories of evil and the mission to maintain them.

Though its craft left gaps, Boneyard embraced a worthy vision: that even imperfect art, by honoring haunting histories, can help keep hope alive for Justice’s day and provide solace that some light still shines in immense darkness.

Tales, True or Tall: Boneyard’s Mixed Legacy

Boneyard tackled a disturbing true crime, seeking to honor victims by facing dark details. Its strengths lay in maintaining real victims’ humanity against the urge to abstract into symbols. Yet this story remained too imperfectly told.

Boneyard Review

Conflicting accounts and an excess of plot threads left its narrative arch convoluted and lacking cohesion. Strong performances from seasoned talent like Gibson were undermined by weaker counterparts and the stilted delivery of demanding dialogue. While its unsolved ending mirrored real life, narrative loose ends frustrated where tighter scripting could have satisfied.

As a thriller, it succeeded least in generating that edge-of-seat dread defining the genre. Technical elements like cinematography were not enough to overcome shortcomings in pacing and atmosphere. And an overabundance of padding seemed to be aimed more at spotlighting the cast  than serving the story.

In the end, this film became just another B-flick exploiting tragedy, not the respectful tribute it envisioned. Still, the faces and names it sustained from obscurity may provide families with a modicum of solace. Its uneven yet earnest bid to transform trauma into testimony merits some recognition, even if the final product fell far from its high-minded hopes. As with the case it depicted, justice remains incomplete, but memory survives, and that is no small matter when dealing with lives cut short.

Some tales demand better telling than this to be done with full honor. But perhaps the weakest yarn, when recounting truths too terrible, still bears a duty—to remind us that behind all facts lie people, and as long as one still recalls their names, no evil can ever wholly erase them.

The Review

Boneyard

5 Score

Boneyard's intentions to honor tragic lives lost in a still-unsolved case are laudable. However, its uneven storytelling and cast do more injustice to the victims' memory than justice. While technically competent, it fails to thrill or move as either a drama or a crime film. An imperfect but well-meaning tribute, it remains too flawed dramatically to stand as anything more.

PROS

  • Attempts to honor the real victims of an unsolved crime
  • Strong performances from experienced actors like Mel Gibson
  • Raises awareness of tragic true events

CONS

  • Convoluted plot with numerous unnecessary subplots
  • Underdeveloped characters and thin/clichéd dialogue
  • It fails to generate suspense or drama as a thriller.
  • Uneven direction and editing compromise entertainment value.

Review Breakdown

  • Overall 0
Tags: 50 CentActionAsif AkbarAvail EntertainmentBoneyardBoneyard (2024)Brian Van HoltGabrielle HaughLionsgateMel GibsonNora ZehetnerThrillerVincent E. McDaniel
Previous Post

“Chicago Med” Secures Return of Original Cast Members for Season 10

Next Post

Float Season 2 Review: A Moving Exploration of Identity

Try AI Movie Recommender

Gazettely AI Movie Recommender

This Week's Top Reads

  • The Librarians: The Next Chapter

    The Librarians: The Next Chapter Season 1 Review – Bridging Eras with Spellbinding Charm

    26 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Death Valley Review: A Witty Welsh Wander into Cosy Crime

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Cannes Film Festival 2025 — Complete Winners List

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Boglands Review: Shadows and Whispers in the Irish Mist

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Nine Puzzles Season 1 Review: Puzzle Pieces, Pain, and Police Procedurals

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • MobLand Season 1 Review: Family Ties and Underworld Intrigues

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Better Sister Season 1 Review: Not Quite a Killer Thriller

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Must Read Articles

Destination X Review
Entertainment

Destination X Review: A Game of Veiled Realities

9 hours ago
Earnhardt Review
Entertainment

Earnhardt Review: The Anatomy of a NASCAR Titan

10 hours ago
The Ritual Review
Entertainment

The Ritual Review: An Unsettled Echo in a Somber Chamber

1 day ago
Dept. Q Review
Entertainment

Dept. Q Review: Edinburgh’s Gloom and a Detective’s Fractured Soul

1 day ago
And Just Like That... Season 3 Review
Entertainment

And Just Like That… Season 3 Review: A Stylish Step Forward, But Does It Go Far Enough?

1 day ago
Loading poll ...
Coming Soon
Who is the best director in the horror thriller genre?

Gazettely is your go-to destination for all things gaming, movies, and TV. With fresh reviews, trending articles, and editor picks, we help you stay informed and entertained.

© 2021-2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

What’s Inside

  • Movie & TV Reviews
  • Game Reviews
  • Featured Articles
  • Latest News
  • Editorial Picks

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About US
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Review Guidelines

Follow Us

Facebook X-twitter Youtube Instagram
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movies
  • Entertainment News
  • Movie and TV Reviews
  • TV Shows
  • Game News
  • Game Reviews
  • Contact Us

© 2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

Go to mobile version