The debate surrounding religious freedom has simmered in recent years, with passionate viewpoints on both sides of the line. With his latest film Average Joe, director Harold Cronk takes on this controversial topic, telling the based-on-a-true-story tale of a coach standing up for his beliefs.
Joe Kennedy serves as head coach for the local high school football team. After overcoming difficulties in his past, he feels called to express his faith on the field in a small daily act—kneeling in prayer at midfield after each game. But not all see it that way. The administration argues it could pressure players, ordering Joe to cease the practice.
When he refuses to pray privately instead, events are set in motion that will carry the case all the way to the Supreme Court. As criticism mounts from both the community and his wife facing backlash at work, Joe’s commitment to his promise is tested. Through it all, he believes standing up for his religious freedom is the right path.
Average Joe explores this polarizing topic with nuance. While clearly sympathetic to Joe’s perspective, it also portrays opposing views with care. What results is a thoughtful, film-provoking discussion on where to draw the line between expression and coercion in an increasingly diverse society.
The Coach’s Calling
Joe Kennedy experienced plenty of challenging times earlier in life. After spending youth in foster care, he went on to serve two decades as a Marine. But his biggest struggle was still ahead—a battle for religious freedom that would take him all the way to the nation’s highest court.
We learn Joe’s story through both dramatized scenes and more lighthearted interview segments where he and wife Denise chat about their journey. This pulls back the curtain in a style similar to Forrest Gump, mixing humor with the heavier moments.
After being nudged to coach a local high school football team, Joe comes to feel called by God to kneel in prayer on the field following each game—a daily act honoring a promise that saved his marriage. He makes it clear players may join or not as they wish. While many opt to, not all see it that way.
School administrators decree Joe’s prayers could pressure kids to participate against their will. They offer alternatives like a private room, but Joe insists on obeying God in the stadium’s center. As Denise faces criticism at work due to Joe’s stand, tensions mount in their small town.
A viral social media post thrusts the situation into the national conversation. Still, Joe clings to his faith despite increasing opposition from the community and his wife under pressure. Step by step, his story of principle leads all the way to the Supreme Court in a battle for religious expression.
A Coach’s Conviction
At the center of it all stands Coach Joe Kennedy, a man steadfast in his principles. Played marvelously by Eric Close, Joe serves as the film’s moral anchor from his days in the Marines to this defining stand. Despite facing opposition, he stays true to the call he feels to openly express his faith.
His relationship with wife Denise, portrayed warmly by Amy Acker, showcases the devotion but also tensions that arise. Supporting Joe fully yet worrying for their family’s wellbeing as backlash grows, she finds her world rocked as much by his choice.
On the other side stands the administrator electing to let Joe go. While their concerns of impressionable minds feeling compelled deserve consideration, the film suggests students deserve more credit to make their own choices.
Then comes former critic Thomas, brought to life in a short but insightful scene. Rather than a caricature, he engages Joe as an equal—two individuals seeking truth, not conflict. Their dialogue hints there are always multiple sides to any issue under the sun.
Through these characters of varied viewpoints, Average Joe goes deeper than simplistic dichotomies. It sees individuals striving as best they know, from both the locker room and the lives impacted beyond its doors.
Finding the Line
Average Joe takes a defined stance in supporting Coach Joe Kennedy’s right to pray publicly, but it does so while raising thoughtful questions about religious expression that still resonate.
The film puts forth the straightforward argument that Kennedy’s short kneeling gesture after games caused no real harm. It infringed on nobody else’s freedoms. As one character notes, the coach merely prayed as was his personal choice—players faced no pressure to join.
Yet it also depicts opposing views with care. Not all see expressions of faith as acceptable in certain settings. Where exactly is the line between open worship and covert coercion? The movie poses this debate but has no simple resolution.
In showing Kennedy’s thoughtful sit-down with a former critic, it acknowledges counter-perspectives come from understandable places of diverse experience. Such discussions serve to educate rather than divide.
Average Joe leaves viewers to ponder where accommodation ends and discrimination begins in an increasingly pluralistic society. It highlights religion’s complexity as a right fiercely protected by some yet exclusionary to others.
All in all, solid cases exist on both sides. Rather than conclude, the film starts a conversation as nuanced as the issues themselves. It presents no easy truths, for in real life seldom does any controversy have a black-or-white answer.
Behind the Lens
Director Harold Kronk and writer Stephanie Katz tread carefully with Average Joe’s sensitive subject matter. Rather than villainize dissenters, they crafted thoughtful adversaries to move discussions forward. Scenes like Joe’s coffee chat showcase this nuanced approach.
Some of the most intriguing aspects come from filmmaking choices—especially the documentary-style format breaking the fourth wall. Hearing Joe and Denise chat directly with the viewer feels fresh. It injects humor to lighten heavier moments while remaining informative.
Of course, none of it would succeed without top-tier acting. Eric Close and Amy Acker imbue their characters with charm and complexity. Even during comedic interview segments, they convey underlying stakes through subtext alone.
Additionally, the witty script deserves praise. Average Joe may center on weighty themes, yet it’s also enjoyable. With deftness, humor balances drama to keep engagement high. A little joke or amusing exchange between the leads proves the perfect tonic.
All in all, under Kronk’s skilled direction and the creative efforts behind the scenes, Average Joe succeeds in starting thoughtful discussions through entertainment. It highlights the power of inclusive storytelling to bring people together instead of pushing them apart.
A Call to Stand Up for What You Believe
At its heart, Average Joe aims to inspire. It finds meaning through Coach Joe Kennedy’s unwavering dedication to his faith regardless of blowback. Though facing opposition on all sides, he stands up for religious principles without reservation.
The film suggests such courage in our own convictions is worthy of admiration. When we truly believe in something, whether popular or not, doing anything less than fighting for it with vigor discredits our character. Joe serves as proof one person can change the world through not backing down.
Not through sensationalism but reason, it addresses complex topics, equipping audiences with facts to thoughtfully consider multiple angles. Rather than accusations, Average Joe extends an open hand—could your perceptions be reexamined? Different views may reveal new dimensions instead of crude “othering.”.
By starting discussions more than ending them, perhaps prejudices will lessen as understanding grows. Disagreed principles might be debated with less hostility when approaches feel inclusive rather than overtly “us versus them.”.
Most importantly, for all its message, Average Joe remains entertaining. By bringing people together over shared joy, maybe common ground forms on which progress becomes possible. Its greatest impact could lie not in rigid stances but in shifted stances—an openness to further shift.
A Call for Understanding
Overall, Average Joe tells a compelling tale that’s worth your time, whether you fully align with its perspective or not. At its core, the film strives to advance understanding instead of division.
Skillfully directed by Harold Kronk, it brings complexity to debates that often lack nuance. While clearly championing Coach Joe Kennedy’s principles, his story acts as a reminder that truths rarely fit simple boxes. Multiple realities can coexist in a pluralistic world.
Through moving performances and thoughtful handling of clashing viewpoints, this film based on real events provokes valuable discussion. Even as disagreement remains on where to draw lines between expression and intrusion, progress emerges from acknowledgment of others’ humanity rather than devilish caricatures.
Joe’s fight shows the power one unyielding man can wield for what he believes serves higher purposes. But perhaps his greatest impact comes not from victory but validation—that diverse outlooks each hold shreds of truth worth jointly pondering.
By sharing this slice of recent history with care, Average Joe leaves minds broadened and preconceptions loosened. Its parting message encourages understanding over vitriol in pursuing justice for all.
The Review
Average Joe
In wrapping up this thoughtful film, it's clear Average Joe rises above merely confirmation bias through balanced portrayal of believers and dissenters alike. While disagreement endures, greater solidarity emerges from recognition of shared hopes for equitable treatment of all.
PROS
- Thoughtful, balanced examination of a complex issue
- Strong lead performances that bring the real story to life
- An inspiring message about persevering for one's principles
- Provokes valuable discussion on religious freedom and expression
- Avoids propaganda by respecting multiple viewpoints
CONS
- Some may see the documentary format as distracting at times.
- The theme of religious expression may be off-putting for secular audiences.
- Skips over some controversial details from the true story
- Slow pacing through dramatized scenes limits entertainment.
- Focus on Christianity may ignore perspectives of other faiths.
