• Latest
  • Trending
American Dreamer review

American Dreamer Review: When Dreams and Reality Deliriously Collide

Kian's Bizarre B&B Review

Kian’s Bizarre B&B Review: The Most Original, and Flawed, Vacation of the Year

Outrageous Season 1 Review

Outrageous Season 1 Review: Champagne and Cyanide

TRON: Catalyst Review

TRON: Catalyst Review: More Style Than Substance

F1: The Movie Review

F1: The Movie Review: An Engineered Ecstasy That Sputters at the Finish

Elio Review

Elio Review: Lost in a Beautiful Cosmos

Anne Burrell

Chef Anne Burrell Dies at 55; Culinary TV Mainstay Mourned by Fans

8 hours ago
Jurassic World Rebirth

Johansson and Bailey Lead ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ to July 4 Box-Office Showdown

9 hours ago
Jhaleil Swaby

Jhaleil Swaby Joins ‘Sunrise on the Reaping’ as District 1 Tribute

9 hours ago
Ida Brooke

Twins of Arrakis: ‘Dune 3’ Finds Its Leto II and Ghanima

10 hours ago
The Rose of Versailles Review

The Rose of Versailles Review: One Heroine Can’t Save the Monarchy

Hell Motel Review

Hell Motel Review: Checking In, But Checking Out Early

FBC: Firebreak Review

FBC: Firebreak Review: Corporate Chaos and Cooperative Action

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Gazettely Review Guidelines
Wednesday, June 18, 2025
GAZETTELY
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Anne Burrell

    Chef Anne Burrell Dies at 55; Culinary TV Mainstay Mourned by Fans

    Jurassic World Rebirth

    Johansson and Bailey Lead ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ to July 4 Box-Office Showdown

    Jhaleil Swaby

    Jhaleil Swaby Joins ‘Sunrise on the Reaping’ as District 1 Tribute

    Ida Brooke

    Twins of Arrakis: ‘Dune 3’ Finds Its Leto II and Ghanima

    28 Years Later

    Sony Wows CineEurope With 28-Minute Zombie Preview and Aronofsky Heist Clip

    Rebel Wilson

    Rebel Wilson Details Blood-Soaked Set Accident Ahead of Bride Hard Release

    James Gunn

    Gunn Dismisses Director Rumors Swirling Around DC’s New Batman Film

    Simone Ashley

    Kosinski Explains Simone Ashley’s Vanishing Act in F1

    How to Train Your Dragon

    Dragons Breathe Fire into U.K. Box Office with £11.4 M Launch

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Kian's Bizarre B&B Review

    Kian’s Bizarre B&B Review: The Most Original, and Flawed, Vacation of the Year

    Outrageous Season 1 Review

    Outrageous Season 1 Review: Champagne and Cyanide

    F1: The Movie Review

    F1: The Movie Review: An Engineered Ecstasy That Sputters at the Finish

    The Rose of Versailles Review

    The Rose of Versailles Review: One Heroine Can’t Save the Monarchy

    Hell Motel Review

    Hell Motel Review: Checking In, But Checking Out Early

    In Cold Light Review

    In Cold Light Review: A Fever Dream in Neon and Dust

    Pop the Balloon Live Review 1

    Pop the Balloon Live Review: Netflix’s Glossy, Empty Remake

    K.O. Review

    K.O. Review: This Heavyweight Contender Lands Solid, If Predictable, Blows

    The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review

    The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review: The Moral Topography of a Postal Code

  • Game Reviews
    TRON: Catalyst Review

    TRON: Catalyst Review: More Style Than Substance

    FBC: Firebreak Review

    FBC: Firebreak Review: Corporate Chaos and Cooperative Action

    Date Everything Review 1

    Date Everything! Review: You’ll Never Look at Your Toaster the Same Way

    Lost in Random: The Eternal Die Review

    Lost in Random: The Eternal Die Review: All Style, Less Story

    Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster Review

    Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster Review: A Dialogue With Tradition

    Yakuza 0 Director's Cut Review

    Yakuza 0 Director’s Cut Review: Neon Lights and Brutal Fights

    Trident's Tale Review

    Trident’s Tale Review: Buried Treasure or Fool’s Gold?

    The Siege and the Sandfox Review

    The Siege and the Sandfox Review: A Pixel-Perfect Prison Break

    MindsEye Review

    MindsEye Review: A Beautifully Empty World

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Anne Burrell

    Chef Anne Burrell Dies at 55; Culinary TV Mainstay Mourned by Fans

    Jurassic World Rebirth

    Johansson and Bailey Lead ‘Jurassic World: Rebirth’ to July 4 Box-Office Showdown

    Jhaleil Swaby

    Jhaleil Swaby Joins ‘Sunrise on the Reaping’ as District 1 Tribute

    Ida Brooke

    Twins of Arrakis: ‘Dune 3’ Finds Its Leto II and Ghanima

    28 Years Later

    Sony Wows CineEurope With 28-Minute Zombie Preview and Aronofsky Heist Clip

    Rebel Wilson

    Rebel Wilson Details Blood-Soaked Set Accident Ahead of Bride Hard Release

    James Gunn

    Gunn Dismisses Director Rumors Swirling Around DC’s New Batman Film

    Simone Ashley

    Kosinski Explains Simone Ashley’s Vanishing Act in F1

    How to Train Your Dragon

    Dragons Breathe Fire into U.K. Box Office with £11.4 M Launch

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Kian's Bizarre B&B Review

    Kian’s Bizarre B&B Review: The Most Original, and Flawed, Vacation of the Year

    Outrageous Season 1 Review

    Outrageous Season 1 Review: Champagne and Cyanide

    F1: The Movie Review

    F1: The Movie Review: An Engineered Ecstasy That Sputters at the Finish

    The Rose of Versailles Review

    The Rose of Versailles Review: One Heroine Can’t Save the Monarchy

    Hell Motel Review

    Hell Motel Review: Checking In, But Checking Out Early

    In Cold Light Review

    In Cold Light Review: A Fever Dream in Neon and Dust

    Pop the Balloon Live Review 1

    Pop the Balloon Live Review: Netflix’s Glossy, Empty Remake

    K.O. Review

    K.O. Review: This Heavyweight Contender Lands Solid, If Predictable, Blows

    The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review

    The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review: The Moral Topography of a Postal Code

  • Game Reviews
    TRON: Catalyst Review

    TRON: Catalyst Review: More Style Than Substance

    FBC: Firebreak Review

    FBC: Firebreak Review: Corporate Chaos and Cooperative Action

    Date Everything Review 1

    Date Everything! Review: You’ll Never Look at Your Toaster the Same Way

    Lost in Random: The Eternal Die Review

    Lost in Random: The Eternal Die Review: All Style, Less Story

    Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster Review

    Bravely Default: Flying Fairy HD Remaster Review: A Dialogue With Tradition

    Yakuza 0 Director's Cut Review

    Yakuza 0 Director’s Cut Review: Neon Lights and Brutal Fights

    Trident's Tale Review

    Trident’s Tale Review: Buried Treasure or Fool’s Gold?

    The Siege and the Sandfox Review

    The Siege and the Sandfox Review: A Pixel-Perfect Prison Break

    MindsEye Review

    MindsEye Review: A Beautifully Empty World

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
GAZETTELY
No Result
View All Result
American Dreamer review

3 Body Problem Review: An Interstellar Odyssey of Grand Ambition

REVEIL Review: A Psychological Terror Masterclass

Home Entertainment Movies

American Dreamer Review: When Dreams and Reality Deliriously Collide

Peter Dinklage and Shirley MacLaine Forge an Iconic Cinematic Pairing in This Deliriously Offbeat Dark Comedy

Naser Nahandian by Naser Nahandian
1 year ago
in Entertainment, Movies, Reviews
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on WhatsAppShare on Telegram

In the delightfully offbeat comedy-drama “American Dreamer“, we are treated to the unlikely teaming of two actors from drastically different generations – Peter Dinklage and Shirley MacLaine. This odd couple pairing sets the stage for first-time director Paul Dektor’s feature, which takes an acerbic yet whimsical look at one man’s relentless pursuit of the elusive American dream of home ownership.

Based loosely on a true story from NPR’s “This American Life”, the film follows the tragicomic exploits of Phil Loder (Dinklage), an embittered and underemployed economics professor. Phil’s white whale? Acquiring a sprawling multi-million dollar mansion, despite his decidedly un-mansionlike finances.

His wildly improbable path to residential nirvana emerges when a too-good-to-be-true deal presents itself – a chance to move into a lakeside palace under the caveat that its elderly owner, the cantankerous Astrid (MacLaine), be allowed to remain until demitting the premises…permanently.

Dream Turns Delirious

Twice-divorced Phil Loder lives a rather dreary existence as an adjunct economics lecturer, novelist manqué and frequent attendee of real estate open houses far outside his modest means. However, this sad sack’s wildest fantasies appear to materialize when an unbelievable opportunity lands in his lap – the chance to purchase a sprawling lakeside mansion for a mere $240,000. The catch? He must share the premises with its current owner, the elderly widow Astrid Finnelli, until her eventual demise transfers full ownership to Phil.

Assured the spry Astrid is on death’s door, Phil liquidates his savings to secure the Faustian deal. But upon taking up residence in the estate’s dingy servants’ quarters, he discovers his “dream home” has turned a nightmarish corner. Not only is Astrid healthier than advertised, she is far from childless – her judgmental daughter Maggie is intent on protecting Mom from Phil’s perceived chicanery by any means necessary.

As farcical scenarios compound and Phil’s unraveling intensifies, he’s forced to confront whether his relentless lust for materialistic status has caused him to lose perspective on what truly matters. Astrid’s own reevaluation of her hermetic existence further blurs the lines between who is supporting who in this unorthodox living arrangement.

Acting Tour de Force

At the core of “American Dreamer” are two phenomenal lead performances that breathe vivid life into the film’s flawed yet sympathetic central oddballs. As the relentlessly obsessive Phil Loder, Peter Dinklage delivers a masterclass in nuanced tragicomedy. The actor’s prowess at mixing biting sarcasm with an underlying yearning for acceptance and love is unparalleled.

American Dreamer Review

Despite Phil’s avalanche of poor decisions and self-destructive tendencies, Dinklage imbues him with a compelling vulnerability that keeps us invested. We cringe at his delusional antics and blunt appraisals of others, yet can’t help rooting for this chronically unlucky dreamer to finally catch a break. Dinklage’s dextrous handling of both the dramatic and comedic swings ensures Phil remains a well-rounded human rather than a mere comedic punching bag.

Matching Dinklage stride-for-stride is the legendary Shirley MacLaine as the irascible Astrid. At 88 years young, the screen veteran loses none of her famed comedic timing and acid-tongued line deliveries. Hers is a richly layered portrayal of a prickly curmudgeon whose tough exterior conceals reservoirs of loneliness and regret over paths not taken.

MacLaine shines in releasing brief glimpses of Astrid’s warmth and hard-won wisdom from beneath her cantankerous veneer. Her chemistry with Dinklage is electric, with their barbed banter and gradual bonding emerging as the film’s beating heart. Their spark elevates even the most absurdist plot detours into something resonant and affecting.

The supporting cast members color the proceedings with equally indelible turns. As the oily real estate agent Dell, Matt Dillon slithers through scenes with deliciously dry comic relish. Danny Glover is hysterical as a curmudgeonly private eye with surprisingly precious sensibilities. And Kimberly Quinn makes a priceless impression as Astrid’s no-nonsense daughter whose icy demeanor eventually, amusingly thaws.

Deconstructing Dreams and Dreaming

On its surface, “American Dreamer” satirizes the very notion of the “American Dream” itself – skewering the misguided belief that accumulating wealth and material possessions alone can constitute true happiness and self-actualization. Phil Loder’s quixotic quest for residential opulence despite his meager earnings lays bare the delusions of grandeur and rampant status-seeking that fuels such pursuits.

American Dreamer Review

However, director Dektor seems to have loftier philosophical goals than merely mocking materialism. At its core, the film dissects the inextricable link between human connection and genuine contentment. Phil’s futile chasing of real estate “dreams” is clearly a manifestation of his profound loneliness – a surrogate for the loving family and sense of belonging he so desperately craves.

His unexpected bonding with the equally adrift Astrid thus takes on great symbolic significance. Their intergenerational friendship, founded on bickering banter, morphs into a mutually sustaining life raft – each coming to rely on the other for the nurturing they’ve long lacked. Their relationship suggests that the “dream” need not constitute ownership of property, but simply being present with those who see and appreciate us for who we truly are.

Tellingly, Phil’s most jarring nightmares visualize a life subsumed entirely by material wealth yet devoid of intimate human connections. Dektor seems to posit that the naive, consumption-oriented “American Dream” is ultimately arib and the real dream worth striving for is personal growth, human understanding, and prioritizing spiritual over mercantile values.

Artful Blend of Pathos and Pandemonium

From a technical perspective, “American Dreamer” proves an impressive tightrope-walk of seamlessly fusing pathos and pandemonium into a tonally cohesive whole. Debut director Paul Dektor demonstrates a deft hand at balancing the film’s darker, more introspective dramatic elements with moments of absurdist humor and slapstick tomfoolery.

American Dreamer Review

Theodore Melfi’s idiosyncratic screenplay strikes a careful equilibrium as well – allowing breathing room for profound character insights and thematic ruminations on the human condition, while injecting ample zingers and farcical set pieces to keep things buoyant. The wittily barbed dialogue rings consistently true.

Cinematographer Brett Jutkiewicz’s camerawork highlights both the story’s opulent trappings and earthy, everyman sensibilities. His lush, almost fetishistic framing of the palatial Finnelli estate subtly reinforces the allure of such materialistic splendor. Yet he maintains an intimate, unvarnished approach during the homier character interactions, keeping the larger philosophical perspectives front-and-center.

Throughout, Dektor’s assured direction keeps all these narrative and technical elements cohesively gelled. The film’s blend of wry comedy and hard-truth drama never feels jarring or disjointed – a filmic high-wire act deftly pulled off with crowd-pleasing charisma.

Tarnished Treasures Amid the Madcap Merriment

For all its deliriously madcap merriment and resonant philosophical underpinnings, “American Dreamer” is not without its share of tarnished imperfections. Still, this quixotic dark comedy undoubtedly displays more assets than liabilities in itsatingexploration of materialism, companionship, and life’s priorities.

American Dreamer Review

Carrying the lion’s share of the film’s successes are its two iconic lead performances. Peter Dinklage’s endlessly watchable turn as the caustic yet achingly lonely Phil Loder is a masterwork of tragicomic restraint. He keeps us firmly invested in Phil’s ill-advised exploits by grounding his buffoonery in deep reserves of hard-earned empathy.

As his scene-stealing co-lead, the legendary Shirley MacLaine savors every delectable line reading as the mercurial Astrid Finnelli. Her effortless commitment to Astrid’s prickly exterior and gentle insights into mortality summon decades of big-screen mastery into a compulsively watchable turn. The pair’s banterous chemistry alone is worth the price of admission.

Director Paul Dektor also deserves plaudits for his adept tonal calibrations mixing slapstick hijinks and grounded emotional truth. He and writer Theodore Melfi largely stick the landing in balancing wry humor with somber intergenerational drama – no small feat.

However, “American Dreamer” does stumble somewhat in its overstuffed subplotting. Extended detours involving Phil’s ill-advised affairs and extra legal woes often disrupt the narrative’s graceful flow rather than enhancing it. Such asides frequently undercut the hard-won character shadings of Phil and Astrid with more one-dimensionally zany antics. A more disciplined focus on fleshing out their dynamic might have cemented the film as a minor classic rather than a flawed gem.

As is, it registers as a fascinating if imperfect rumination on life’s true priorities – favoring human connections and self-actualization over mere material acquisition. In that thematic ambition, it reminds one of cult comedies like “Harold and Maude” in its ability to mine both hearty guffaws and poignant soul-searching from its eccentric characters. While not achieving those lofty heights, Dektor’s debut remains an entertainingly idiosyncratic reminder that the dream of attaining “things” will eternally rank second to dreaming of ways to cherish those around us.

Eccentric Indulgence Earns Its Sentimentality

For all its occasional narrative missteps and scattershot subplotting, “American Dreamer” remains a curious and compelling watch – a distinctively eccentric blend of melancholic character study and deliriously broad comedy. Its greatest strengths emerge from the exquisitely nuanced work of leads Peter Dinklage and Shirley MacLaine, whose rapport electrifies even the most outlandish story beats with hardscrabble authenticity.

American Dreamer Review

Director Paul Dektor’s tonally audacious debut ultimately lands as a refreshingly idiosyncratic ode to human connection’s ability to foster contentment over empty material pursuits. By turns gut-bustingly funny and soul-bearingly reflective, the film makes a persuasive case that the oft-mythologized American Dream is better achieved by nurturing our interpersonal dreams instead.

For the sheer delight of watching its iconic stars riffen with relish, to say nothing of its admirably big-hearted yet clear-eyed existential perspectives, “American Dreamer” easily earns a recommendation. An eccentric indulgence well worth savoring.

The Review

American Dreamer

8 Score

While hardly perfect, with some uneven subplots and tonal detours diminishing its impact, "American Dreamer" still emerges as a wonderfully idiosyncratic gem. The riveting dual performance from Dinklage and MacLaine, allied with Dektor's admirable narrative ambitions in satirizing materialism while extolling human connection, render this darkly comedic fable a poignant and riotously entertaining must-see. An eccentric cinematic treasure worth embracing.

PROS

  • Phenomenal lead performances from Peter Dinklage and Shirley MacLaine
  • Deftly balances dark comedy with poignant drama
  • Insightful satirization of the materialistic "American Dream" myth
  • Explores profound themes of loneliness, human connection, and finding purpose
  • Excellent dialogue and character chemistry, especially between the leads
  • Strong technical merits like cinematography and direction

CONS

  • Some uneven subplots and superfluous detours dilute the main narrative
  • Occasional tonal inconsistencies with the broad slapstick humor
  • Certain supporting characters and motivations feel underwritten
  • The film's ambitions slightly exceed its ultimate grasp

Review Breakdown

  • Overall 0
Tags: American Dreamer (2022)ComedyDanny PudiFeaturedKimberly QuinnPaul DektorPeter DinklageShirley MacLaine
Previous Post

3 Body Problem Review: An Interstellar Odyssey of Grand Ambition

Next Post

REVEIL Review: A Psychological Terror Masterclass

Try AI Movie Recommender

Gazettely AI Movie Recommender

This Week's Top Reads

  • Art Detectives Review

    Art Detectives Review: The Case of the Brilliant Man and the Underwritten Woman

    107 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Deep Cover Review: A Script for Chaos, Left Unread

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Boglands Review: Shadows and Whispers in the Irish Mist

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mix Tape Review: A Story Told on Two Sides of a Cassette

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Marshmallow Review: These Woods Hide Unexpected Secrets

    4 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Survivors Season 1 Review: A Town Drowning in Secrets

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Patience Review: Challenging Stereotypes in Crime Drama

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Must Read Articles

F1: The Movie Review
Movies

F1: The Movie Review: An Engineered Ecstasy That Sputters at the Finish

7 hours ago
Elio Review
Movies

Elio Review: Lost in a Beautiful Cosmos

7 hours ago
K.O. Review
Movies

K.O. Review: This Heavyweight Contender Lands Solid, If Predictable, Blows

18 hours ago
The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review
Entertainment

The Chelsea Detective Season 3 Review: The Moral Topography of a Postal Code

1 day ago
Bride Hard Review
Movies

Bride Hard Review: Something Borrowed, Something Broken

1 day ago
Loading poll ...
Coming Soon
Who is the best director in the horror thriller genre?

Gazettely is your go-to destination for all things gaming, movies, and TV. With fresh reviews, trending articles, and editor picks, we help you stay informed and entertained.

© 2021-2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

What’s Inside

  • Movie & TV Reviews
  • Game Reviews
  • Featured Articles
  • Latest News
  • Editorial Picks

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About US
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Review Guidelines

Follow Us

Facebook X-twitter Youtube Instagram
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movies
  • Entertainment News
  • Movie and TV Reviews
  • TV Shows
  • Game News
  • Game Reviews
  • Contact Us

© 2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

Go to mobile version