• Latest
  • Trending
City of Dreams Review

City of Dreams Review: A Glimpse of Harsh Realities, But Room for Deeper Insights

Squid Game Season 3 Review

Squid Game Season 3 Review: No Happy Endings Here

Mission Impossible - The Final Reckoning Review

‘Final Reckoning’ Nears $550 M While Budget Questions Linger

13 hours ago
Jon Watts The Fantastic Four

Jon Watts Explains Pandemic Fatigue Behind Fantastic Four Exit

13 hours ago
Love Island USA Hannah Fields

Inside the Vote That Sent Hannah Home—and Why Viewers Aren’t Over It

13 hours ago
Chicago P.D. Drops Toya Turner

Chicago P.D. Season 13 Starts Without Newest Detective as NBC Confirms Cast Cut

14 hours ago
Love Island USA Season 7 Review

Love Island USA Season 7 Review: Summer’s Hottest Guilty Pleasure Returns

The Carters Hurts to Love You Review

The Carters: Hurts to Love You Review: Angel Carter’s Courageous Testament to Surviving Family Dysfunction

Rematch Review

Rematch Review: Sloclap’s Ambitious Football Experiment Falls Short of Goals

Got to Get Out Review

Got to Get Out Review: The Most Interesting Broken Game on Television

The Bear Season 4 Review

The Bear Season 4 Review: A Contemplative, Cathartic Final Course

Scarlett Johansson

Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Bailey Share Viral Kiss as Dinosaur Franchise Roars Back

1 day ago
Sovereign

Offerman’s Radical Turn Powers July Thriller Sovereign

1 day ago
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Gazettely Review Guidelines
Friday, June 27, 2025
GAZETTELY
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Mission Impossible - The Final Reckoning Review

    ‘Final Reckoning’ Nears $550 M While Budget Questions Linger

    Love Island USA Hannah Fields

    Inside the Vote That Sent Hannah Home—and Why Viewers Aren’t Over It

    Chicago P.D. Drops Toya Turner

    Chicago P.D. Season 13 Starts Without Newest Detective as NBC Confirms Cast Cut

    Scarlett Johansson

    Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Bailey Share Viral Kiss as Dinosaur Franchise Roars Back

    Sovereign

    Offerman’s Radical Turn Powers July Thriller Sovereign

    Brokeback Mountain

    Eastwood Anecdote Reopens Debate Over Brokeback Mountain’s Oscar Upset

    MasterChef

    Sri Lanka Fires Up Its First MasterChef as ITN Takes Format into 71st Territory

    Low Life

    Disney+ Dives Into 1970s Treasure Hunt With K-Drama Low Life

    Denis Villeneuve

    Denis Villeneuve Takes the Helm of Bond 26 in Amazon’s Franchise Reboot

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Squid Game Season 3 Review

    Squid Game Season 3 Review: No Happy Endings Here

    Jon Watts The Fantastic Four

    Jon Watts Explains Pandemic Fatigue Behind Fantastic Four Exit

    Love Island USA Season 7 Review

    Love Island USA Season 7 Review: Summer’s Hottest Guilty Pleasure Returns

    The Carters Hurts to Love You Review

    The Carters: Hurts to Love You Review: Angel Carter’s Courageous Testament to Surviving Family Dysfunction

    Got to Get Out Review

    Got to Get Out Review: The Most Interesting Broken Game on Television

    The Bear Season 4 Review

    The Bear Season 4 Review: A Contemplative, Cathartic Final Course

    Daydreamers Review

    Daydreamers Review: Saigon’s Stylish But Stumbling Vampires

    Most People Die On Sundays Review

    Most People Die On Sundays Review: Resisting the Cathartic Release

    Surviving Ohio State Review

    Surviving Ohio State Review: The Weight of Witness

  • Game Reviews
    Rematch Review

    Rematch Review: Sloclap’s Ambitious Football Experiment Falls Short of Goals

    Chronicles of the Wolf Review

    Chronicles of the Wolf Review: Forging a Path Through the Past

    JDM Japanese Drift Master Review

    JDM: Japanese Drift Master Review – When Mechanics Meet Manga

    Blood Bar Tycoon Review

    Blood Bar Tycoon Review: A Bloody Good Idea, Poorly Executed

    Ghost Frequency Review

    Ghost Frequency Review: All Atmosphere, No Conclusion

    Death Stranding 2 On the Beach Review 1

    Death Stranding 2: On the Beach Review – Kojima’s Outback Odyssey

    RAIDOU Remastered: The Mystery of the Soulless Army Review

    RAIDOU Remastered: The Mystery of the Soulless Army Review: The Detective Who Couldn’t Investigate

    Still Wakes the Deep: Siren’s Rest Review

    Still Wakes the Deep: Siren’s Rest Review – Revisiting a Sunken Legacy

    TRON: Catalyst Review

    TRON: Catalyst Review: More Style Than Substance

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movie and TV News
    Mission Impossible - The Final Reckoning Review

    ‘Final Reckoning’ Nears $550 M While Budget Questions Linger

    Love Island USA Hannah Fields

    Inside the Vote That Sent Hannah Home—and Why Viewers Aren’t Over It

    Chicago P.D. Drops Toya Turner

    Chicago P.D. Season 13 Starts Without Newest Detective as NBC Confirms Cast Cut

    Scarlett Johansson

    Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Bailey Share Viral Kiss as Dinosaur Franchise Roars Back

    Sovereign

    Offerman’s Radical Turn Powers July Thriller Sovereign

    Brokeback Mountain

    Eastwood Anecdote Reopens Debate Over Brokeback Mountain’s Oscar Upset

    MasterChef

    Sri Lanka Fires Up Its First MasterChef as ITN Takes Format into 71st Territory

    Low Life

    Disney+ Dives Into 1970s Treasure Hunt With K-Drama Low Life

    Denis Villeneuve

    Denis Villeneuve Takes the Helm of Bond 26 in Amazon’s Franchise Reboot

  • Movie and TV Reviews
    Squid Game Season 3 Review

    Squid Game Season 3 Review: No Happy Endings Here

    Jon Watts The Fantastic Four

    Jon Watts Explains Pandemic Fatigue Behind Fantastic Four Exit

    Love Island USA Season 7 Review

    Love Island USA Season 7 Review: Summer’s Hottest Guilty Pleasure Returns

    The Carters Hurts to Love You Review

    The Carters: Hurts to Love You Review: Angel Carter’s Courageous Testament to Surviving Family Dysfunction

    Got to Get Out Review

    Got to Get Out Review: The Most Interesting Broken Game on Television

    The Bear Season 4 Review

    The Bear Season 4 Review: A Contemplative, Cathartic Final Course

    Daydreamers Review

    Daydreamers Review: Saigon’s Stylish But Stumbling Vampires

    Most People Die On Sundays Review

    Most People Die On Sundays Review: Resisting the Cathartic Release

    Surviving Ohio State Review

    Surviving Ohio State Review: The Weight of Witness

  • Game Reviews
    Rematch Review

    Rematch Review: Sloclap’s Ambitious Football Experiment Falls Short of Goals

    Chronicles of the Wolf Review

    Chronicles of the Wolf Review: Forging a Path Through the Past

    JDM Japanese Drift Master Review

    JDM: Japanese Drift Master Review – When Mechanics Meet Manga

    Blood Bar Tycoon Review

    Blood Bar Tycoon Review: A Bloody Good Idea, Poorly Executed

    Ghost Frequency Review

    Ghost Frequency Review: All Atmosphere, No Conclusion

    Death Stranding 2 On the Beach Review 1

    Death Stranding 2: On the Beach Review – Kojima’s Outback Odyssey

    RAIDOU Remastered: The Mystery of the Soulless Army Review

    RAIDOU Remastered: The Mystery of the Soulless Army Review: The Detective Who Couldn’t Investigate

    Still Wakes the Deep: Siren’s Rest Review

    Still Wakes the Deep: Siren’s Rest Review – Revisiting a Sunken Legacy

    TRON: Catalyst Review

    TRON: Catalyst Review: More Style Than Substance

  • The Bests
No Result
View All Result
GAZETTELY
No Result
View All Result
City of Dreams Review

Maria Review: A Diva's Final Encore

Afraid Review: Technological Terror or Trivial Thrills?

Home Entertainment Movies

City of Dreams Review: A Glimpse of Harsh Realities, But Room for Deeper Insights

When Good Intentions Don't Quite Make a Coherent Story

Mahan Zahiri by Mahan Zahiri
10 months ago
in Entertainment, Movies, Reviews
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on PinterestShare on WhatsAppShare on Telegram

Mohit Ramchandani’s City of Dreams shines a light on the dark reality of human trafficking. At its core is Jesús, a teenage boy with dreams of soccer stardom who is preyed upon and smuggled across the border. Within the dreary walls of an LA sweatshop, he endures brutal conditions while clinging to hope of escape.

Ramchandani takes on an urgent task—raising awareness of victims like Jesus. But good intentions alone don’t make a whole film. While his direction brings the sweatshop to life, other elements feel exploitative or leave key questions unanswered. Jesús’ harrowing ordeal seems to demand shock value over compassion.

This review examines City of Dreams as both a cautionary story and a flawed artistic work. Through Jesus’ resilient spirit, it provides a window into lives often unseen. But in its ambition to shock, does it lose sight of its message? By exploring its successes and shortfalls, perhaps we can further important discussions around modern-day slavery.

Jesús’ Journey

The young boy Jesús has dreams of soccer stardom. Living in Puebla, Mexico, he plays constantly but lacks opportunities to take his talents further. That changes when Jesús sees an ad for a camp in Los Angeles—a chance to hone his skills in the big leagues.

His father approves the trip, trusting the smooth-talking coyote to transport Jesús safely. But upon arriving in LA, it becomes clear this man conned them. Jesús awakens not at a training ground but inside a gloomy sweatshop where his passport was sold.

Now under the control of the ruthless El Jefe, Jesús witnesses his dreams shattered. Long hours spent slaving over sewing machines break his body and spirit. Any defiance brings severe physical abuse. Among the imprisoned children, only Jesús’ friend Elena offers comfort in their suffering.

Still, Jesús’ passion for soccer survives. In darker moments, visions of cheering crowds lift his hopes of escaping. When a chance arises during transport, Jesús makes a desperate bid for freedom. Yet in an unfamiliar city, where can one lost boy turn? With captors in pursuit, Jesús must find courage to keep running—and locate someone willing to help this migrant child in need.

His ongoing struggle highlights the human cost of such exploitation. But even in the face of such injustice, Jesús’ resilience and yearning for his true calling refuse to die. Through pain and perseverance, perhaps there remains hope he can someday fulfill the destiny that first drew him to leave home: to play ball beneath those bright stadium lights.

Capturing the Nightmare

Behind City of Dreams stood a director with an ambitious vision. Mohit Ramchandani sought to depict a harrowing reality through compelling filmcraft. But did his stylistic choices serve the story—or distract from it?

City of Dreams Review

Right away, Ramchandani immerses us in Jesus’ plight. The sweatshop scenes glow with an eerie half-light, shadows creeping in darkness. No ray of optimism shines through those windowless walls. Outside, daytime scenes brighten our reality contrasted to the boy’s entrapment. In this way, lighting painted a bleak dichotomy between hope and despair.

When Jesus’ dreams appear, fantastical sequences transport beyond the grime. We float among adoring crowds as he stars on the pitch. Though gorgeous to behold, did inserting magic realism undermine the gritty realism elsewhere? Or did these glimpses empower, reflecting Jesus’ humanity still kicking beneath mistreatment?

The director’s visual command is proven through ambitious long takes. Particularly gripping, a single-shot chase scene perfectly paced the tension as Jesús fled for his freedom. Camerawork flowed seamlessly, keeping viewers wrapped up in Jesús’ jeopardy.

Sometimes, Ramchandani peered directly into the trauma through Jesús’ eyes. Was this intimacy meant to place us in the boy’s shoes—or exploit the pain for sensationalism? A fine line exists, and not all techniques effectively balance message with empathy.

In challenging us to see through Jesús’ eyes, Ramchandani grasped a commendable goal. Not every stroke of style served it, though, and muddled premises distracted from such well-meaning aims. When story and suffering took priority over shock value, the director shone most genuine, illuminating modern slavery’s abhorrent realities.

The Faces of Suffering

At the heart of City of Dreams stood Jesús, brought to life by young actor Ari Lopez. Without uttering a word, Lopez conveyed the boy’s torment vividly through eyes brimming with pain. His resilient spirit endured the worst of abuses, inspiring hope even in darkness. Jesús’ silent bravery reminded us that even society’s most vulnerable find ways to resist oppression.

City of Dreams Review

Co-starring was Alfredo Castro’s chilling El Jefe. His malicious presence towered, inflicting terror with chilling ease. Yet Ramchandani offered viewers glimpses of his own faded dreams, adding complexity where a simpler villain may have sufficed. Castro embodied a warning—how any life can slip into cruelty when stripped of humanity.

Andrés Delgado also left an impression as Cesar, El Jefe’s ruthless right hand. His brutality seemed crafted to shock, but Ramchandani imbued hints of the man’s stolen future. A college wish hinted that not all oppressors start as monsters, questioning what societal forces can twist a life astray.

In minor roles, the ensemble brought Jesús’ dire circumstances to life. Their shared anguish reinforced that modern slavery steals childhoods indiscriminately. Each performer, even in small doses, brought nuance that deepened our understanding of trafficking’s diverse victims and perpetrators alike.

Through dynamic leads and supporting players, City of Dreams populated its nightmarish industrial compound with complex, fully-felt individuals. Their interwoven hardships underlined how societal problems entrap entire communities—and the resilience of human spirits that persevere, searching still for justice and peace.

Shining a Light, or Just Provoking Fear?

City of Dreams took on timely themes that deserved exploration. Yet did it meaningfully comment—or merely generate heat over light?

City of Dreams Review

Trafficking’s harsh realities received no sugarcoating. Through Jesus, we witnessed exploitation’s toll on the migrant dream and basic human rights. But was this grim realism exploited for sensation? Shock value risks numbing audiences, not mobilizing them.

Ramchandani seemed to grasp trafficking as a systemic societal failure over isolated acts of cruelty. Alas, his script scattered focus, bouncing from theme to theme without diving deep. Politics received blame but sparse solutions; trafficking’s roots went unexamined.

Well meaning at its core, the film’s “call to action” landed hollow. It name-dropped agencies but offered viewers no tangible next steps. A problem so immense demands community—yet City of Dreams left crowds to disperse alone in the darkness.

At its best, the film sparked dialogue on vulnerable populations. But its purpose remained muddled—was awareness the true aim, or box office totals? A complex issue like this merits care, not carelessness.

If a work intends to shed light, it must see with clarity, not heat. City of Dreams glimpsed important truths but ultimately lost sight of its mission. By steering messily between message and masquerade, did it help or hinder the fight against modern slavery? That remains an open question.

Beneath the Surface

While City of Dreams faced constraints, craftspeople brought the sweatshop to chilling life. Production design transported viewers straight to the heart of darkness within Los Angeles.

City of Dreams Review

The windowless compound stood as both a physical and metaphorical prison. Dank corridors felt like claws grasping Jesús further from sunlight. El Jefe’s throne room oozed authority through imposing scale. Each nick added verisimilitude, completing the hidden world Ramchandani aimed to uncover.

Though dialogue proves a mixed bag, atmosphere resonated through silences. Claustrophobic tension amplified the grinding machines and muffled cries. Absence of music highlighted natural audio, pulling one deeper into sweat and suffering.

Cinematography painted shades of hell through shadows and gloom. Yet hopeful shards of humanity emerged even in hell’s gloomiest corners, as when Jesús finds fleeting comfort in a girl’s arms. Within confinement, filmic craft hinted at spirits that cannot be broken.

Ramchandani tapped talent willing to bring troubling stories to light without frills. Their diligence ensured City of Dreams transported audiences irrespective of budget. While other parts falter, the film’s visual world stands as a testament to transforming dark themes into beautiful, haunting art.

A Glimpse of Truth, A Call for More

City of Dreams shed urgently needed light on modern slavery’s brutal realities. Through Jesus, viewers witnessed sheer will to survive against all odds. His resilient spirit reminds us of humanity’s indomitable strength even in darkness.

City of Dreams Review

In these ways, Ramchandani’s film succeeded in its aim. But good intentions alone don’t make a coherent story. While production talent brought the sweatshop setting alive, other elements seemed to prioritize sensation over message.

A complex issue like trafficking demands care, not carelessness. Viewers deserved more clarity guiding discussions, not provocation standing alone. Jesús’ harrowing experience gave us a window into lives unseen, but for the window to truly impact minds and spur action, the frame around it must feel thoughtfully crafted.

In the end, City of Dreams glimpsed troubling truths too many wish unseen. But for its message to empower change rather than simply provoke, the full complexity of modern slavery demands depictions with even more compassion and care in their construction. Perhaps this film can light further works to illuminate this darkness through wisdom, not heat, and truly inspire the action victims like Jesús so deserve.

The Review

City of Dreams

6 Score

City of Dreams shone a necessary light on modern slavery but faltered in crafting its message. Ramchandani grasped an urgent task but fell short on coherence, prioritizing shock value over a fully realized story. Jesús' resilience-inspired yet stylistic choices distracted more than empowered. With a defter hand, this grim realism could have profoundly impacted viewers rather than provoking alone. The film glimpsed harsh truths deserving illumination—may its flaws guide future works to truly transform awareness into compassionate action.

PROS

  • Shed important light on modern slavery and child trafficking issues.
  • Jesús' character and Ari Lopez's performance conveyed resilient spirit.
  • Ambitious production design vividly portrayed harrowing sweatshop setting
  • Raising awareness of real-life victims through Jesus' story

CONS

  • Narratively unclear and at times exploitative stylistic choices
  • Overly provocative at times, prioritized shock value over full messages
  • Underdeveloped characters and plots distracted from central themes
  • Incomplete depiction of trafficking issues and limited call to action

Review Breakdown

  • Overall 0
Tags: Ari LópezCity of DreamsCity of Dreams (2023)Diego CalvaDramaFeaturedJon GrahamKyle StroudLuis MandokiMatthew DiezelMohit RamchandaniP2 FilmsPaulina GaitánPierce BrosnanRenata VacaRufus ParkerSean WolfingtonThrillerYalitza Aparicio
Previous Post

Maria Review: A Diva’s Final Encore

Next Post

Afraid Review: Technological Terror or Trivial Thrills?

Discussion about this post

Try AI Movie Recommender

Gazettely AI Movie Recommender

This Week's Top Reads

  • Alma and the Wolf Review

    Alma and the Wolf Review: Ethan Embry Shines in a Flawed Fever Dream

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Smoke Review: The Year’s Most Unpredictable and Unsettling Show

    7 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Marshmallow Review: These Woods Hide Unexpected Secrets

    4 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Boglands Review: Shadows and Whispers in the Irish Mist

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mix Tape Review: A Story Told on Two Sides of a Cassette

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Outrageous Season 1 Review: Champagne and Cyanide

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 7 Biggest Station Wagons on the Market

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Must Read Articles

Squid Game Season 3 Review
Entertainment

Squid Game Season 3 Review: No Happy Endings Here

3 hours ago
Love Island USA Season 7 Review
Entertainment

Love Island USA Season 7 Review: Summer’s Hottest Guilty Pleasure Returns

14 hours ago
The Bear Season 4 Review
Entertainment

The Bear Season 4 Review: A Contemplative, Cathartic Final Course

23 hours ago
Surviving Ohio State Review
Movies

Surviving Ohio State Review: The Weight of Witness

1 day ago
Countdown Season 1 Review
TV Shows

Countdown Season 1 Review: Assembling the Parts of a Soulless Machine

1 day ago
Loading poll ...
Coming Soon
Who is the best director in the horror thriller genre?

Gazettely is your go-to destination for all things gaming, movies, and TV. With fresh reviews, trending articles, and editor picks, we help you stay informed and entertained.

© 2021-2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

What’s Inside

  • Movie & TV Reviews
  • Game Reviews
  • Featured Articles
  • Latest News
  • Editorial Picks

Quick Links

  • Home
  • About US
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Review Guidelines

Follow Us

Facebook X-twitter Youtube Instagram
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Movies
  • Entertainment News
  • Movie and TV Reviews
  • TV Shows
  • Game News
  • Game Reviews
  • Contact Us

© 2024 All Rights Reserved for Gazettely

Go to mobile version