Name: Searching for Amani Review: One Boy’s Journey Opens Windows to Complex Crises
Item: Searching for Amani
Author: Naser Nahandian

In the small Kenyan town of Laikipia, a young boy begins an important journey. Only 13 years old, Simon Ali finds himself thrust into the role of citizen journalist after a devastating tragedy—the murder of his father. Left with little information about the circumstances of his dad’s death, Simon picks up a camera to seek the truth.

This act of determination kicks off the documentary Searching for Amani. Directed by Americans Nicole Gormley and Kenyan filmmaker Debra Aroko, the film follows Simon over several years as he conducts interviews and researches his father’s killing. We learn that Stephen Ali Apetet worked as a tour guide at the vast Laikipia Nature Conservancy before being gunned down on the job. With no arrests made, many questions remained unanswered for Simon and his grieving family.

Equipped now with filming equipment from the directors, Simon embarks on a personal quest. But his investigation soon reveals issues far larger than one man’s death. The documentary explores the deep-rooted land conflicts in the region, often stemming from colonial divisions of resources that were further exacerbated by prolonged drought. As Simon continues his search for answers, we gain insights into the desperate challenges facing pastoralist communities and the tensions over land usage in this changing environment.

Through one boy’s story, Searching for Amani shines a light on complex cultural and ecological problems impacting many in rural Kenya. With a determined young journalistic spirit as our guide, the film provides a window into these important realities.

Tracking Down the Truth

We learn that Stephen Ali Apetet was a hardworking man devoted to his job at Laikipia Nature Conservancy and his family. But one morning, all was changed when shots rang out, and the father of five fell near the beginning of his tour shift. For 13-year-old Simon and his loved ones, numbness turned to frustration as the police failed to uncover what really happened that fateful day.

This is where young Simon’s story truly starts. Given a camera by American director Nicole Gormley and Kenyan co-director Debra Aroko, the boy vows to find answers himself. His search leads him to interview those close to his dad, like his grieving mother Lucy. He also speaks with Stephen’s former coworkers at the conservancy, gaining insight into the man he was.

One of the most engaging interviews is with a tourist who witnessed the killing. Their account provides a glimpse into the attack, yet still leaves pieces missing. With each conversation, Simon starts putting together a picture of his father while exploring deeper issues surrounding the region.

We see how Simon’s quest becomes intertwined with hardships facing nearby pastoralist communities. He learns about struggles endured by the family of his friend Haron. In Simon’s determined investigation, large-scale land conflicts over grazing rights amid a worsening drought are brought to light. His journey personalizes these complex problems through one boy’s attempt to find the truth behind a senseless crime.

Unraveling the Land Issues

To grasp the full context, it helps to understand the history of the region. We learn that after colonial times, much of the fertile ground in Laikipia ended up in the hands of relatively few white settlers. This legacy of inequality has persisted into modern times.

worsening drought has dramatically compounded problems. In the north, prolonged dry spells have rendered pasturelands barren. This pushed many herders who rely on cattle to migrate south in search of grasslands. Tragically, access to areas like Ol Pejata Conservancy is now restricted.

The film offers perspective from Kuki Gallmann, who took ownership of the conservancy. However, her view that pastoralists disregard imposed conditions provides only a partial picture. A more balanced look at managing grazing practices could have informed viewers.

As resources dwindled amid the climatic crisis, tensions spilled over. We sense the dire challenges facing communities struggling to sustain large herds and families on ever more desiccated lands. For some, desperation led to the assumption that shooting intruders was seen as somehow justified.

By unraveling some of the historical complexities and pressures of drought, the documentary sheds light on why land had effectively become a matter of life and death for all involved in this high-stakes battle.

Capturing Compelling Images

One aspect that draws viewers into Searching for Amani is its visual storytelling. Campbell Brewer’s award-winning photography presents Kenya’s landscapes in all their beauty and majesty. His dreamlike shots immerse us in the region’s environs.

Whether following Simon’s investigation or illustrating the challenges of harsh seasons, Brewer’s camera conveys real depth of feeling. His roving lens transports us across the land, helping us understand conflicts at their heart. These evocative landscapes act as another key character, brimming with significance.

Of course, directors Nicole Gormley and Debra Aroko shape the cinematic influence. Their choices, like fluid reenactments, aim to engage, though they risk veering toward manipulation. At times, these dramatized sections feel overwrought beside real interviews.

Still, documentary filmmaking walks an ethical line, and one senses their imperative was honoring personal stories over sensationalism. With hindsight, a lighter directorial touch may have balanced informing audiences and respecting personal truths.

Overall, Brewer’s exquisite images remain the work’s core strengths. His roaming camera captures the land’s scope, the people’s perseverance, and Simon’s quest in ways that bring complexity to vivid life. These compulsively watchable sequences make the film’s challenges and characters utterly compelling.

Beyond the Surface

Searching for Amani touches on weighty cultural challenges beneath its personal narrative. The film references hardships facing pastoralist groups long marginalized in their homeland.

As pastoralists were pushed south by drought, desperation grew over restricted access to grazing lands. Viewers see how this fuels tensions, though some pertinent facts remain unsaid. Comparisons to other films providing deeper dives into issues like colonial legacies and equitable resource allocation could have strengthened the work.

Still, the directors avoid reducionist villanization, instead emphasizing our shared humanity. They spotlight those enduring poverty and loss of livelihood through no fault but circumstances beyond control.

While not delving into all industry violence, the focus stays on positive goals of reconciliation. Even in exploring complex problems lightly, the work deserves credit for prioritizing empathy over accusation in its examination of societal fractures.

At its heart lies a personal story of perseverance, yet the documentary hints at wider struggles bubbling beneath. With nuance, it shines light on realities impacting many unseen. Though just scratching the surface, searching for Amani opens a window to lives and landscapes whose troubles merit deeper understanding.

Balancing Guidance and Autonomy

In any documentary, filmmakers must weigh the ethics of intervention versus non-interference. Searching for Amani provides an apt case study of these challenges.

By supplying top-quality gear, the directors undeniably facilitated Simon’s investigation. However, one can’t help but question if this level of material support shaped the narrative in ways counter to the film’s aims.

Similarly, the decision to conduct many interviews in English rather than participants’ native Swahili feels inclined to favor production over authenticity. This jars against the reality that subjects likely felt most comfortable expressing deeply personal tales in their heart language.

At its worst, such influences risk pulling a documentary into reality television terrain by imposing predetermined story arcs onto subjects’ lived experiences. While Gormley and Aroko meant well in highlighting urgent issues, did Simon truly drive his own search for understanding with full independence?

Of course, the observer effect is unavoidable, and documentarians must guide complex stories into compelling form. But for a film advocating empathy, allowing subjects’ own agency and ensuring their stories remain untainted by outside forces feels equally important.

Ultimately, Searching for Amani opens a window to challenges worth ongoing discussion as the genre further develops standards of best practice around these considerations.

Bright Future on the Horizon

Through its focus on Simon’s search, Searching for Amani shines a light on weighty issues impacting Kenya—from land rights and drought to journalism as a path for change.

By following one boy’s personal quest over several years, complex topics felt accessible. Simon’s determined spirit, staying committed to tackling difficult questions, showed hope even when answers remained elusive.

Of course, further addressing socio-political nuances could have strengthened the film. But ultimately, illuminating realities too often unseen in rural Africa remained the documentary’s achievement.

Simon seems poised to carry on his father’s legacy as a storyteller, with an inquisitive mind ready to uncover deeper layers of truth. As he pursues his dreams, hopefully the film’s messages of perseverance and social justice will continue to find new audiences.

With vibrant cinematography keeping viewers engaged throughout, Searching for Amani proved a compelling starting point for raising global awareness of challenges demanding solutions. While the future holds uncertainties, this documentary leaves its mark with a spirit of optimism.

The Review