The documentary Men of War delves deep into the disastrous failed coup attempt in Venezuela known as Operation Gideon. Led by former U.S. Green Beret Jordan Goudreau, the operation in 2020 aimed to overthrow President Nicolás Maduro but ended in catastrophe. Directors Jen Gatien and Billy Corben peel back the layers of this incredible true story to reveal both the hubris and humanity of those involved.
We learn how Goudreau’s lifelong love of combat began from a childhood spent playing war games. As a soldier in Iraq and Afghanistan, he thrived on mission-driven work. However, unsigned PTSD from his service led the army to dismiss him. Restless, Goudreau formed a private security firm and fell in with Venezuelan opposition figures eager to topple Maduro’s corrupt regime.
Corben and Gatien reveal how Goudreau conspired with resistance fighters, U.S. officials, and a jailed Venezuelan general to launch an incursion from Colombia. Though supposedly to “free” 30 million people, the $200 million contract was surely a huge motivator. With ragtag recruits and little planning, the mission was doomed from the start.
The film balances Goudreau’s testimony with contrary narratives. Through recorded meetings and interviews, each participant spins events to their benefit. As contradictory stories emerge, the complex truth remains elusive. But one theme resonates: when fantasy overrides reality, tragedy ensues. Men of War compellingly depicts the human impacts of broken systems and untreated wounds, both in individuals and nations, in a story as engrossing as any Hollywood tale.
The Soldier’s Long Road
From a young age, Jordan Goudreau was fascinated by all things military. Growing up playing endless games of war in fatigues, he dreamed of becoming a soldier. With combat experience off limits in Canada, the ambitious Goudreau trained to join the elite US Green Berets. He spent over a decade deploying to some of America’s toughest battlegrounds, like Iraq and Afghanistan, carrying out dangerous operations. Honored with medals for bravery, Goudreau seemed to thrive under the intense pressures of service.
However, the toll was also growing. Multiple tours spanning the post-9/11 wars left their scars, both visible and unseen. Though diagnosed with PTSD, Goudreau continued re-up, unable to adjust to civilian life back home. By his later missions, army evaluators saw signs of untreated trauma impacting his judgment. Despite protests, Goudreau refused to stop until finally medically discharged.
Adrift without the structure of military life, Goudreau launched Silvercorp USA, a private security company. Providing protection at Trump rallies introduced him to figures in the president’s inner circle. Through them, Goudreau’s focus shifted abroad, becoming involved with Venezuelan dissidents fiercely opposing the Maduro regime. They saw in the experienced soldier a potential ally in their fight.
Eager for a new mission, Goudreau fully committed to the Venezuelan opposition’s cause. But after so many battles, did he truly understand the enormous challenges of toppling an authoritarian government? And with his own demons still unchecked, was Goudreau really fit to lead others into the uncertainty of regime change? The decisions made in the following months would lead to a disastrous outcome, transforming a lifelong soldier into the complex, compromised figure at the heart of Men of War’s unforgettable true story.
Operation Gideon: A Disastrous Dream
Jordan Goudreau was certain he had the answer to Venezuela’s problems—himself. As a former Special Forces soldier, he believed only direct action could free the country from Maduro’s tyrannical grasp. So in 2019, Goudreau hatched a bold but barely coherent plan to launch an incursion from neighboring Colombia.
Dubbing it “Operation Gideon,” Goudreau signed a $1.5 million contract with representatives of Juan Guaidó, the opposition leader recognized by the U.S. as Venezuela’s legitimate president. From there, delusions of grandeur took over. Goudreau recruited a ragtag group of several dozen Venezuelan dissidents and ex-American soldiers with promises of liberating their homeland.
However, minimal training and scant logistics planning left the would-be freedom fighters woefully unprepared. On the night of May 3, 2020, two rickety fishing boats carried the men on the first leg of Goudreau’s imagined triumph. But British BVIs guards spotted and halted the vessels, packed far beyond capacity with men, weapons, and no supplies.
The much-delayed mission had lost the element of surprise before truly starting. Those on board surrendered immediately, ending any hopes of a coordinated uprising. In Caracas, Maduro’s feared SEBIN agents brutally interrogated and imprisoned the captured mercenaries.
With Goudreau’s dream dashed in an instant, the operation earned just mockery. Newspapers dubbed it the “Bay of Piglets” for its amateur bungling on a scale far smaller than the Cuban fiasco. Goudreau’s grand plan to spark a revolution had resulted in only failure and human costs, a sobering impact of one man’s misguided delusions of soldierly valor.
Behind the Intrigue
At the heart of Men of War lies its captivating—and confounding—central figure, Jordan Goudreau. As a former Special Forces soldier, he’s portrayed as both deeply heroic yet undeniably flawed. His experiences in combat clearly left scars, seen in signs of untreated PTSD that lingered long after leaving the military.
Such trauma would twist anyone’s perspective, and in Goudreau it manifested as an all-consuming hero complex. Believing his destiny was saving others through violence, he cooked up increasingly chaotic plans, seeing adversaries around every corner. Goudreau thinks himself the protagonist in his own action movie, though reality grows further from his fiction with each misstep.
The filmmakers handle Goudreau and others involved with consistent impartiality. Representatives for Juan Guaidó hardly acknowledge their dealings with Goudreau, desperate to avoid accountability for the botched raid. Ex-General Alcalá plays both coconspirator and scapegoat, jailed while denying involvement.
Most heartbreaking are the brothers of captured American mercenaries. Their anguish at loved ones dragged into danger is visceral, one accusing Goudreau of manipulation. Through it all, directors Gatien and Corben let no character dominate our interpretation, instead delivering a kaleidoscopic telling befitting such a convoluted true story.
With no easy answers to be found, they shine light on the real victims—those left bearing scars as tangible as Goudreau’s, yet without his ability to narrate his own role. Men of War proves a remarkable profile of ordinary people swept into extraordinary darkness and the human costs paid for lives lived in fiction rather than fact.
Piecing Together the Puzzle
Directors Jen Gatien and Billy Corben had the difficult task of adapting Jordan Goudreau’s unbelievable true story into a cohesive documentary. By utilizing a strategic blend of materials, they triumphantly sorted through the chaotic contradictions to deliver Men of War.
A huge boon was Goudreau’s own recorded footage from the buildup to Operation Gideon. His candid interviews were candid yet delusional, generating intrigue. Editing his claims alongside contrary testimonies from other figures crafted real-time “fact checks” that kept viewers enthralled.
Archival clips and contemporaneous recordings likewise injected authenticity. Whether through shaky FaceTime from a jailed ex-general or text messages allegedly with top officials, these raw snippets grounded complex events.
Weaving between Goudreau’s narrative and rebuttals without resolution invited audiences to solve the puzzle. Contradictions remained deliberately unclear, mirroring reality when “truth” varies by perspective. This mosaic approach brought cinematic energy fitting such a strange-but-true saga.
Layering various viewpoints within a taut structure, Corben and Gatien balanced coherency with complexity. Their editing assembled a suspenseful unfolding of jaw-dropping twists and turns, despite actual outcomes already known. The outcome felt like a political thriller, although anchored in real human impacts, a testament to non-fiction’s power when handled with nuanced mastery.
Hard Truths From Failed Dreams
Men of War unpacks profound themes that have shaped recent history and hints at enduring tendencies within human nature. At its core, the film critiques America’s forever-war mindset and how it pervaded one man in particular.
Jordan Goudreau embodied a soldier’s addiction to conflict, unable to break from battles even after being diagnosed with PTSD. Through him, the documentary lays bare the wounds such endless wars leave and questions whether strategic half-measures do more harm than good overseas.
Corruption within Venezuela’s opposition also faces scrutiny. Some allegedly exploited people’s very real grievances against Maduro while protecting personal fortunes and ambitions over ordinary citizens’ welfare.
Perhaps most unsettling, the film suggests how easily fantasy can overwhelm fact for those seeking meaning through direct action. Goudreau and others believed their own hype, discounting warning signs that reality diverged from their perceived heroism’s script.
In troubling ways, their misguided quest and its costs for innocent lives reflect the human urge to ignore uncertain truths when control feels threatened. We wish to author our own narratives, forgetting the outside world’s indomitability.
Men of War offers no easy answers. Instead, it raises difficult queries through emotional, compelling storytelling. While fiction might reimagine such tales towards happy ends, this non-fiction work honors real impacts through hard-won understanding of messy truths beyond tidy resolution.
True Stories that Resonate
Men of War brings Goudreau’s unbelievable true story to life in a way that shows nonfiction’s ability to capture our imagination. Director Gatien and Corben deftly balance intrigue and insight, crafting a film as suspenseful as the best thriller yet grounded in profound themes.
This documentary dissects the human impacts of unchecked ambition and fractured systems with compassion. Goudreau emerges as a complex figure embodying how easy it is for reality to slip from our grasp in turmoil’s wake. By sourcing his recordings and weaving multifaceted perspectives, the filmmakers construct a nuanced, piercingly relevant portrait.
Their examination of fragile national psyches fueling endless wars and the corrupting influence of fleeting ideals still rings true. While fiction could twist this tale to feel-good resolution, the film honors real-world consequences through thoughtful storytelling.
Even knowing outcomes, Men of War grips viewers from start to finish. Beyond entertainment, it sparks critical thinking on timeless issues. With deft direction and vivid non-fiction storytelling, Gatien and Corben crafted one of the most compelling documentaries in recent memory—essential viewing for any lover of both cinema and the profound truths it can convey.
The Review
Men of War
Through masterful direction and an unforgettable true story, Men of War proves documentaries' power to stimulate both mind and soul. Gatien and Corben craft an engrossing film that illuminates the human condition with empathy, humor, and an unflinching gaze.
PROS
- Compelling characters led by Jordan Goudreau as a complex protagonist
- Well-paced blend of interview, archival footage, and recorded dialogue
- Provided insightful perspectives on war, politics, and human psychology.
- Raised thought-provoking questions about America's foreign interventions
- Achieved suspense like a thriller despite revealing real-life outcomes
CONS
- A convoluted web of characters and timelines made the plot challenging to follow.
- Lacked clarity on U.S. government and Trump administration involvement
- Could have delved deeper into effects on victims like captured soldiers.
