Lost amidst the chaotic scenes replayed endlessly in the days and months after January 6th were the real human stories of those who witnessed democracy under siege from within the halls of Congress. The Sixth, directed by Andrea Nix Fine and Sean Fine, set out to contextualize the events of that day through the lens of those directly in the line of fire rather than the sensationalized snippets that have come to define public understanding. Through largely untapped archived footage from the front lines and deeply personal interviews with eyewitnesses, the filmmakers offer a more holistic accounting of the trauma inflicted on both the targets and defenders of the insurrection alike.
On that winter day in 2021, a mob incited by the lies of a stolen election breached the US Capitol building in an attempt to overturn the presidential election results through violence. While the images broadcast to a horrified nation centered around physical damage and mayhem, the true catastrophe was experienced individually by those trapped inside the political heart of the American government. The Sixth shifts focus on how ordinary citizens like photojournalist Mel Cole and congressional staffers unexpectedly found themselves fearing for their lives while relegated to observer status in our democratic process gone criminally wrong.
Directors Fine and Fine stitch together these varied perspectives through a spartan yet empathetic approach, eschewing overt contextualization or partisan analysis in favor of letting the raw experiences speak for themselves. Their intention is to take in the sum of an history-altering event beyond just its most shocking snippets, honoring the humanity of all impacted regardless of political affiliation or social position. Through this nuanced lens, a more sobering understanding of January 6th
unfurls piece by layered piece.
Eyewitness accounts from the frontlines
The Sixth takes an immersive approach to transporting viewers to the harrowing events of January 6th. Directors Andrea Nix Fine and Sean Fine constructed the film almost entirely from archival sources like bodycam footage, photos, and videos recorded that day. Through these raw materials from the frontlines, we feel pulled directly into the chaos unfolding outside and inside the Capitol building.
However, the filmmakers supplement these real-time materials with intimate interviews from the perspective of those who endured the attack firsthand. We come to understand the traumatic experiences not just as dramatic scenes, but through the lingering trauma still weighing on survivors years later. By spotlighting eyewitnesses like Rep. Jamie Raskin, photographer Mel Cole, and staffer Erica Loewe, their emotional testimony puts a very human face on the cost of that dark day for American democracy.
These personal narratives form the backbone for how Fine and Fine piece together the larger story. Their recollections offer grounded context for the more sensational images and footage that have become seared in the public consciousness. Methodically, the film follows a non-linear structure to contrast peaceful early scenes with the increasing tensions and ultimately explosive clashes outside the Capitol building. Eyewitness vantage points mark our progress through the growing chaos and violence rampaging within the hallowed halls of government.
Through the final police interviews and Raskin’s solemn reflections, a fuller portrait emerges of both the physical attacks and the deep scars still healing. The directors handle their material with artistic care to honor those who survived while visually bringing audiences into the heart of this pivotal and traumatic moment in history through the eyes of those who witnessed it firsthand.
Survivors of the Storm
Among the most powerful voices in The Sixth are those who lived through the chaos firsthand. We hear from Rep. Jamie Raskin, who emerged from his office fearful not just for his own safety but for his daughters in the mob’s path. Mel D. Cole puts a human face on the insurrectionists through his up-close photos, while narrowly avoiding death threats himself.
Daniel Hodges’ trauma is still raw as he replays being crushed in the doorway. His calm retelling is undercut by anguish flickering just below the surface. We see the footage anew through his eyes, understanding how that moment must replay in his mind.
Also profoundly affected was Erica Loewe, who once felt honored to witness history from within the Capitol. Instead, she found herself barricaded as rioters closed in, forced to contemplate fleeing for her life. Her hope that day warped into genuine fright.
While years have passed, an emotional rawness in these survivors’ voices suggests wounds that remain far from healed. They surge with residual anger that the events could be denied or discredited. Yet they also empower the film with piercing insights unavailable elsewhere.
Through their testimony, we relive the attack not as sensational images but as a very real violation experienced by flesh-and-blood individuals. The Sixth ensures those changed by January 6th can continue sharing their truths, and we as viewers might absorb impactful lessons about democracy and dissent.
Raising the stakes
The Sixth doesn’t just show footage of the mayhem that unfolded; it puts you right in the thick of it all. Filmmakers Sean Fine and Andrea Nix heighten the tension through tactical editing that pins you down.
Sharp cuts shuttle between rioters’ closed-in views and panoramic shots from overhead. Their crisp diagrams orient you within the Capitol’s maze as the swarm surges deeper. You start to feel just how disorienting it was for everyone caught in the melee.
When police camera clips dive headlong into the mob, it’s visceral. Bear Mace burns your eyes as you swing a baton against anonymous assailants. Overwhelming numbers crush in on all sides until escape seems hopeless.
Interiors offer no refuge as panicking lawmakers describe the “medieval-style fighting” encroaching ever closer. Glimpses through officers’ fingers clutching window frames show violent figures filling the frame and flashlight beams piercing the gloom.
The film inhabits multiple perspectives to ratchet up unease from all angles. Shots from above of the horde swallowing up diminutive police lines pack more punch knowing their on-ground views. It’s a masterclass in controlled suspense that burrows under your skin.
Fine and Nix immerse you as a fly caught in the mayhem, never letting claustrophobia or dread dissipate. Their technical prowess makes potent what could have been distant images we’ve seen many times before. Through their lens, the realities of January 6th feel brutally fresh and right on your heels once more.
Shining light on shadows
Some called it merely a “tourist visit,” but The Sixth shows that day’s dark truth. It casts needed light on shadows lingering over America’s political landscape.
We see a mob’s violent insurrection aimed at democracy’s heart. Their fury, stirred by election falsehoods, is vividly clear—not sightseers streaming relaxed through halls.
Polarized divisions that day tore open wounds that perhaps healed too fast. Filmmakers respected speaking from all sides, leaving some as thoughtful. Yet questions about how such madness arrived unanswered still linger like miasma.
Will understanding what drove thousands to act help guide political ships from such rocks? Or risk an excuse where accountability’s due? Hard paths either way when conscience and country split.
Deeper probes may reveal democracy’s health relies on basic trust in our system and leaders’ willingness to bind rather than divide for power’s sake alone. January 6th shows the grim fruits when these bonds break.
Healing divisions takes time, good faith on all sides, and honest reflection—not denial or dogma. The sixth contributes by facing hard facts, not fears, and giving space for open souls to process trauma’s lessons. May its light guide future steps toward unity and truth.
Facing Hard Truths
The Sixth holds great power as a documentary. It presents a vision at odds with those aiming to brush off violence that day. Through raw footage and testimony, viewers witness history, and its impact lingers long after.
Archival clips from the event give unprecedented viewpoints. Police bodycams plunge us into mayhem. Citizen journalist Cole’s photos show grim realities that swirled around him. Painfully, these primary sources contradict false claims of a harmless tour through the Capitol.
By providing space for those directly caught up to share quietly after time passes, the film bolsters understanding too. Raskin, still shaken, relives his worst fears for loved ones locked down with an enraged mass approaching. Officer Hodges calmly walks through the terror of that moment, crushed at the door. Their memories, plus evidence entered to convict others, leave no doubt of the danger America faced.
Though difficult to watch, such documentaries serve to process trauma. By facing hard truths again in a safe space, viewers may find closure that those who were there still seek. We also gain perspective to curb revisionism drifting from facts. Revisiting darkness through this lens affirms democracy’s fortunes nearly slipped that day—and shows work still ahead to mend rifts tested then.
The Sixth accomplishes much by showing reality simply as it unfolded and those affected. In recounting an event seared into many minds, it strips away self-serving spin and moves discussions forward with care, honesty, and empathy. Its message will continue to resonate with those reflecting on how far we’ve come but also how far we have yet to go.
Navigating shared trauma
The sixth brings January 6th full circle. Through harrowing footage and contemplative accounts, it captures the attacks’ intensity while honoring the resilience of those targeted. Raskin, Cole, and others transport us into the terror of that day and the years since, now steadily processing pain through brave testimonies.
The Sixth ReviewThe Sixth Review
Fine and Nix provide an intimate look seldom afforded. By humanizing an array of perspectives—whether defending the Capitol or caught within the mob—viewers gain fuller context. Though understandably fixated on perpetrators’ punishment, the film declines simplistic villainizing and suggests shared scars run deeper.
As a record for history, its commitment to portraying reality stands as a light in an era of darkening truth. But it also serves as a reminder of democracy’s fragility when fear and division prevail. As Americans continue struggling to find common ground after shockwaves from that January still spread, its message of reflecting with care, not rage, feels needed now as when released.
The Sixth leaves marks that will linger for all, changed by a day when insurrection struck the heart of the U.S. government. In moving discussions ahead in a spirit of openness, not accusatoryness, perhaps we move closer to national healing too.
The Review
The Sixth
The Sixth delivers a compelling and unflinching re-examination of the January 6th attacks. Through the tactical integration of raw footage and thoughtful first-person accounts, directors Andrea Nix Fine and Sean Fine immerse viewers directly in the chaos and ongoing aftermath and trauma. While difficult to watch, this intensive documentary fulfills a vital role in setting an authoritative record of events that day.
PROS
- Comprehensive use of primary source footage provides an immersive narrative experience
- Prioritizes a diversity of perspectives, including defenders and participants
- Facilitates a deeper understanding of escalating events and long-term impacts
- Establishes an authoritative factual record amid attempts to downplay attacks
CONS
- Some scenes of violence and trauma may be difficult for sensitive viewers
- Offers limited psychological profiling of insurrection participants
- Fails to adequately explore reports of some officers aiding mob entry
