Ishana Night Shyamalan makes her directorial debut with The Watchers, a supernatural thriller set in a dense Irish forest. As the daughter of renowned twist-master M. Night Shyamalan, she was bound to tap into the vein of mysterioso genre storytelling that made her father famous.
The film centers around a lonely young woman named Mina, who finds herself trapped in the eerie woodland. She joins a group of strangers holed up in a bare-bones bunker, where every night they line up before a two-way mirror to be observed by unseen entities known as The Watchers.
This isolated setting, with unknown observers lurking in the shadows, holds plenty of unsettling potential. The film initially draws us in as the characters work to uncover the ominous rules and history of their situation. However, The Watchers struggles to maintain its atmosphere of mystery and dread.
As more explanations are offered, the plot grows increasingly convoluted with competing twists and convoluted backstories. Character development is also lacking, with our heroine and her fellow forest fevers having little depth to make their circumstances feel truly high-stakes. While it shows glimpses of chilling intrigue, The Watchers ultimately loses its way in an overgrown patch of narrative confusion.
Mina’s Lost Journey
Mina lives with grief in Galway, still mourning the loss of her mother from years past. Working at a pet shop helps keep her busy but does little to lift her brooding spirit. All this changes when she is tasked with delivering a rare parrot to a client in Belfast. Setting out on the journey, perhaps she hopes the change of scenery will do her good.
However, things take a dark turn once Mina enters the sprawling woods. Her car mysteriously breaks down inside, with no sign of how or why. As night falls, the forest exudes an unnatural menace, as if exerting some strange hold over anyone who enters. While searching for help, Mina spots an elder woman in the distance, beckoning her towards an old shelter deep within the trees.
The safe house, dubbed “The Coop,” contains three others who have similarly become trapped there over time. Their de facto leader, Madeline, welcomes Mina and divulges the ominous situation. By night, spectral figures known only as The Watchers descend to peer through the two-way mirror enclosing them. Strict rules are in place to avoid arousing their ire, though the true motives of these phantom observers remain unclear.
As the latest addition to this unlikely woodland cohort, Mina finds herself embroiled in a chilling mystery. What dark power has seized control of the forest? And will any of its unwilling residents ever regain their freedom?
The Forest’s Foreboding Grip
Little is revealed in the film’s opening moments, yet an unsettling tone emerges. Without exposition, viewers sense danger in these dense woods that appear on no map. As one man races in panic through the trees, an unseen threat follows, and his final words hint at the forest’s disorienting power.
Mina too becomes ensnared when delivering the parrot, as her vehicle mysteriously disables within the forest. Now she must find a way out before night falls. Approaching a lone cabin, an elderly woman’s call to “run” had been unneeded advice, for the woods manifested as unpredictable and uninviting. Inside, Mina finds others similarly trapped, mysteriously observing unknown entities beyond the two-way mirror after dark.
The film proves deftly intriguing through the suspense of limited information. Like Mina and her new companions, viewers piece together forest rules cautiously, unsure what to believe about the Watchers or how long inhabitants have endured. Clues emerge at a regulated pace through ominously brief dialog, keeping audiences as much in the dark as the characters.
Even when revelations provide answers, they raise new questions, maintaining an unsettling atmosphere. Like the characters watching beyond the two-way mirror, viewers proceed carefully through the forest’s narrative maze. Though responses remain just beyond sight, the audience continues cautiously forward, compelled along the journey despite the unknowns ahead in the forest’s foreboding grip.
Misty Woods Mysteries
The dense forests of Ireland are filled with mystery. Tourists venture within, seeking natural beauty, only to find something more ominous lurking in the shadows. Such is the premise of Ishana Shyamalan’s supernatural thriller, The Watchers, which traps its characters in a forest where nothing is as it seems.
We meet pet store worker Mina, still mourning her mother’s tragic death years ago. When her car breaks down in a remote wood, she finds refuge in a solitary concrete bunker with three strangers who have been imprisoned there for months. Their prison warden, Madeline, imparts strict rules regarding the forest’s invisible observers, known as The Watchers. Only after nightfall do these beings emerge, peering through a two-way mirror at the humans now under their control.
Mina and the others scramble to piece together how such a surreal situation came to be. They uncover clue after clue within the bunker’s hidden depths, unearthing both artifacts and alarming revelations about The Watchers and those who came before. Videos and documents left behind shed light on the creatures’ mysterious origins and relation to Irish folklore.
Yet with each new discovery, the plot grows more convoluted. Infodumps of dense exposition replace the intriguing atmosphere and suspense built early on. Before long, we learn far more than we cared to about shifty changelings, fallen elves, and mystical histories. The complex mythology threatens to overpower the personal dilemmas that first drew us in.
While creativity merits applause, an engaging story risks losing its way when laden with overly elaborate backstories. Perhaps with time and experience, Shyamalan will learn to trust audiences to imagine alongside her rather than under-explaining each minute detail. For now, the intense mysteries of the Irish woodlands remain partly shrouded in shadow, leaving viewers to wonder what other fables may still lurk within.
The Cooped-Up Characters
Being stuck with strangers in an enclosed space with unexplained rules and lurking threats outside provides rich material for character development and dynamic interactions. The Watchers, though, fail to fully realize this potential. While the film establishes an intriguing setting and premise, it neglects to flesh out its characters with the complexity viewers crave.
We never get below the surface with Mina and her lingering grief. Flashbacks hint at trauma from her mother’s death but reveal little about who Mina is today and what truly drives her. Likewise, the other inhabitants remain enigmatic. Daniel comes across as volatile, while Ciara keeps her cards close, but their personalities feel one-dimensional. Madeline remains an aloof and imposing presence more than a fully realized character.
Trapped together under intense circumstances, tensions and alliances would naturally emerge. Yet the interactions between inhabitants lack dimension. No true interpersonal drama unfolds as they search for answers and strive to survive their unusual plight.
Viewers never bond closely with any character or feel invested in how their fates play out. With limited insight into these individuals, it’s hard to care about their predicaments or root for them to break free of the woods’ strange hold.
Focusing more on peeling back layers of the inhabitants’ psychologies and forging deeper connections between them could have elevated the film’s human themes. By leaving its confined crew of characters underdeveloped, The Watchers missed a prime opportunity to generate compelling drama and unnerving unease from their abnormal situation. With more fully fleshed individuals at its center, this tale of those watching and being watched might have proved harder to shake off.
The Woods Come Alive
Ishana Night Shyamalan shows real talent for crafting unsettling atmospheres. Ballinastoe Woods, the primary shooting location, becomes a looming presence unto itself, branching fingers reaching into the frame. Tall, angular pines tower darkly, their shadowed depths concealing unknown threats. Shots pull back to reveal Mina tiny and alone within this forbidding landscape, the creeping score enhancing her isolation.
Some sequences are brilliantly handled, like the moment a figure is at last glimpsed through the trees. Sparse lighting and oblique camerawork build dread before revealing a twisted shape snarled in the shadows. Inside the safehouse too, tension simmers. Strangers standing vigilant before the mirror offer no answers but many questions. You feel eyes watching from the other side, though the watchers remain out of sight.
It’s clear Shyamalan understands suspense. She holds shots just long enough for uncertainty to settle in, cutting only as curiosity peaks. Her characters may be thin, but the director fleshes out the wordless spaces between them.
It’s a polished debut that shows promise, even if the film drags in spots. With experience, Shyamalan could learn to trim narrative flaws and keep audiences on sharper hooks. For now, her skilled visuals promise this won’t be the last we see of her haunting imaginings. The woods may hold yet more mysteries to uncover.
Forest of Discovery
The Watchers sets up an intriguing premise that promises suspense and scares deep in the Irish woods. At first, the mysterious rules and unseen threats keep viewers on the edge of their seats, wondering what lurks beyond the treeline.
However, as more of the mythology is revealed, the film loses some of its allure. While effective moments show Ishana Night Shyamalan has skills behind the camera, her script fails to flesh out characters or craft a cohesive story.
By the end, feelings are mixed. We caught glimpses of the chiller this could have been if not for an overabundance of exposition. Still, Shyamalan demonstrates promise, and with time and experience, she may master balancing information and intrigue. The foundations are there for a talent wanting to cultivate suspense rather than explanations.
With a focus on character and suggestion over detail, her next project could wind viewers around her finger as the woods do those who wander too far. For now, The Watchers gets partially lost in its own narrative foliage. But this young director shows seeds that, given the right creative conditions to take root, might bloom into rewarding genre storytelling. The forest remains one of discovery, and I look forward to seeing where Shyamalan’s path may lead.
The Review
The Watchers
While The Watchers shows flashes of promise, it ultimately tries to pack too much lore into its plot at the expense of character, suspense, and scariness. Ishana Night Shyamalan possesses budding technical skills, but this debut effort would have benefited from more focus on atmosphere over exposition. With experience, she could master the balance required to keep audiences glued to the screen. For now, The Watchers gets mildly lost in its own twisty narrative and leaves viewers with more questions than thrills.
PROS
- The intriguing premise and setup of mysterious rules and threats in the woods
- Some effectively unsettling moments that show directorial skill
- Ambitious adaptation of complex source material
CONS
- Overly complex mythology explained through tedious exposition
- Shallow, underdeveloped characters
- Loses the scare factor and suspense as the plot is revealed.
