Seth Rogen has admitted he doubted Jake Gyllenhaal’s performance while the two filmed “Donnie Darko,” a verdict he now treats as a lesson in how little an actor on set can judge. Rogen shared the memory in a New York Times oral history marking the cult film’s 25th anniversary on Monday.
“I remember seeing [Gyllenhaal] on set and being like, ‘I don’t know how this is going to land,’” said Rogen, who played bully Ricky Danforth in his first film role. He noted that Gyllenhaal was not playing a charming version of the lead role, and that the actor had put in more thought than Rogen had realized an actor could. Rogen said he also wondered if the film would turn out really good or end up a weird B-movie.
The risk Rogen sensed was real. Director Richard Kelly built the story around a troubled teenager haunted by a figure in a rabbit costume who warns that the world is about to end. The film struggled to find a distributor and nearly went straight to home video. It opened to weak box office, in large part because its advertising was limited after the Sept. 11 attacks.
Kelly saw the lead differently from the start. He has said that within 30 seconds of meeting Gyllenhaal in Drew Barrymore’s office, he knew he had the right Donnie. Gyllenhaal came aboard after Jason Schwartzman left over scheduling conflicts. He also contributed the lead’s heavy-lidded stare and the idea of casting his sister, Maggie Gyllenhaal, as Donnie’s sister. On the last shooting day, Gyllenhaal told Kelly with a smirk that he had been mimicking him the whole time.
The film found its audience later. DVD and VHS sales, midnight screenings and reissues turned it into a cult classic. Rogen said that a good, resonant movie will find its people. Fathom Entertainment brought a 4K restoration back to theaters starting Oct. 2, with Kelly on hand to discuss it. Kelly marked the anniversary with a novelized sequel that reopens the film’s mysteries.
Rogen’s recollection carries weight because of who made it. He is now an Emmy-winning star and co-creator, and he arrived on this set as a newcomer with little reason to doubt his own instincts, which makes his later admiration for Gyllenhaal’s commitment more telling.














































