Barbara Robinson wrote the children’s classic The Best Christmas Pageant Ever in 1972, starring the notorious band of siblings known as the Herdman kids. Troublemakers from a young age, the unruly bunch becomes entangled in the small town’s most cherished tradition when they hijack control of the annual church pageant. Now Dallas Jenkins, director of the popular Christian series The Chosen, has brought this story to the big screen.
Set in an unspecified time, the film paints a nostalgic picture of a tight-knit community celebrating the season in the usual way—with their long-running Christmas pageant. But when disaster strikes the pageant’s leader, a kindhearted mother named Grace volunteers to step in. And just as she takes the reins, the uninvited Herdmans make an entrance, threatening to wreak havoc as only they can. Grace soon realizes putting on the show will prove more challenging than she imagined.
Portraying the Herdmans’ perspective gives the story refreshing depth. Through their involvement in the pageant, both the charming misfits and wary townsfolk gain new understandings. With heart and humor, Jenkins explores timeless themes of acceptance, redemption, and discovering meaning amid familiar traditions. Moving beyond superficial caricatures, the director upholds the book’s spirit of showing goodness often arises from welcoming “outsiders” rather than clinging to order. The Best Christmas Pageant Ever invites viewers on a joyous journey of opening minds and hearts during the holidays.
Getting to Know the Characters
What makes this story such a delight is the wonderful characters that come to life on screen. At the center are the infamous Herdman kids—a rowdy bunch, to be sure! Eldest sister Imogene takes on more of a motherly role, looking out for her five younger siblings. A tough exterior hides her softer side. Ralph is the joker, always cracking jokes, while Ollie starts more than his fair share of trouble. Kindhearted Gladys trails behind, while twin brothers Jim and Leroy are nearly inseparable. Each brings their distinct flair to the pageant roles.
Then we have thoughtful Beth. As the film’s narrator, she’s our guide through this memorable Christmas. At first skeptical of the Herdmans, her kind soul soon sees them as more than mere outcasts. Grace too possesses great warmth, willing to give an opportunity where others simply see faults. Focused on inclusion over rules, she brings new life to this celebration.
Bob lends steady support to Grace despite the antics. And the gossiping church ladies? Their disapproval stems more from rigidity than malice. Change does not come easy for traditionalists.
Over the film, we see layers emerge in all, especially Imogene. Under the bravado lies a girl assuming adult duties too soon. The pageant gifts her a chance to experience the innocence taken for granted by others. Funny and heartfelt, the characters invite us into their world and community with relatable charm. By the story’s end, distinctions between heroes and villains fade in favor of simply appreciating each person’s humanity.
Bringing the Story to Life
One thing that struck me about this film is the care put into perfectly portraying its time period setting. From the costumes reflecting 70s styles to nostalgic touches like old TVs and cars, the production encapsulates the era. It feels like a window into the past.
Cinematographer C. Kim Miles deserves credit for his work too. He wields the camera with tenderness, infusing each scene with a feeling of comfort. Every lit church or snowy landscape embraces you like a warm hug.
Lauren Graham’s narration proves the perfect host as our guide through young Beth’s memories. Her voice, reflecting on joy and life lessons learned, provides the perfect bookend framing each moment.
And really, this film belongs to its cast. Judy Greer illuminates Grace with a beautiful balance of wit and wisdom. You feel her every emotion, from exasperation to delight. But the real standout remains Beatrice Schneider’s Imogene. This young actress portrays a complex soul with raw charisma. Her evolution, confronting pain while grasping at hope, stays with you.
Director Dallas Jenkins displays his expertise at weaving together comedy and pathos. No moment feels out of place, even amid tonal shifts. His care for characters, seen throughout, ensures every performance shines.
Truly, from top to bottom, this talented crew pours heart into honoring both its beloved source material and timeless message. Their magnificence transports us to a special place, if only for a little while.
Finding our shared humanity
At its core, this story celebrates opening our minds and arms to those considered “other.” Though the Herdmans upset the town’s order, Grace recognizes their humanity—as does the audience through their beautifully messy journey.
As for Christmas’ message, it’s found not in rigid rituals but in thoughtful reexamination inspiring compassion. The pageant rekindles understanding through diverse voices, with Imogene’s fresh questions resonating most.
Kindness too proves transformative, as small acts of goodwill thaw long-held prejudices on all sides. Faced with the Herdmans’ dire reality, judgments give way to empathy and care.
Even the toughest exteriors often shield deep wounds. Imogene stands out, showing how vulnerability arises not from strength’s absence but from its principled exercise even in pain. Her character’s evolution lifts spirits in the saddest of times.
At its heart, the film celebrates our shared fragility but also capacity for love. Though change meets resistance, hope remains that appreciation for each other—as complex, challenging, yet dear children of this strange world—can slowly replace fear and division. If so, perhaps the true message of Christmas endures not only in pageants but between all people wherever they are found.
A Story for All Time
This film embraces the timeless ability of Christianity’s greatest tale to mean new things to each generation. The pageant breathes fresh life into the nativity by welcoming unlikely voices that challenge assumptions.
Watching the Herdmans grapple with Mary, Joseph, and the Magi inspires new understandings. Their candid questions, free of pretense, are treated with respect. Audiences views broaden as the story grows richer for being examined from outside the usual frameworks.
Faith traditions mean most when all people feel empowered to be part of an ongoing discussion. Rather than preach answers, the movie starts important conversations. Its message resonates because no one is left out from wrestling with life’s deepest mysteries.
By bringing a familiar story to audiences of varied beliefs, common hopes emerge. A baby’s birth reminds us that salvation came for everybody—the powerful and powerless alike. God’s love stands for all, belonging to none exclusively.
At its heart lies the time-tested power of a narrative laying bare our shared fragilities yet stoking our capacity for compassion. The Christmas tale lives on enthusiastically shared, as welcoming to outsiders as its newborn king.
Moments that Resonate
It’s clear the creators poured over Robinson’s story to honor its spirit on screen. Every costume, setting, and scene rings true, immersing us in this community. Yet they enriched the source too, giving space for characters to breathe.
The visit to the Herdman house stays with me. In just a few minutes, we feel the emptiness of a home without love or stability. It leaves an ache that lingers, a reminder of realities often ignored.
Imogene especially evolves credibly thanks to nuanced writing and Schneider’s innate warmth. Her softening is subtle, never trite. We come to understand, not condemn, her walls that hide deep scars.
This delicate balancing never feels forced or manipulative. Laughs flow freely, yet sorrow sneaks in, revealing shared vulnerabilities. Relationships form through compassion instead of cloying sentiment.
Comedy buffers heavier notes without trivializing real struggles. Tears emerge unprompted from joy in human connections across perceived divides.
Details grounded it all, but the heart gave it wings. Simple truths of our shared brokenness and capacity for good endure past credits, quietly challenging onlookers to find shared hopes over fears in “others” within our own communities. Perhaps that remains its most timeless magic.
A Gift That Keeps Giving
This film has stayed with me long after the closing credits, proving some stories are meant to become Christmas traditions of their own. Its charming characters and thoughtful exploration of themes like acceptance still warm my heart when December rolls around.
By finding the humanity in all people—even those society casts aside—it reminds us that everybody deserves kindness. And through sharing such a story together, division melts away as our shared hopes are remembered.
Dallas Jenkins has crafted an adaptation doing justice to Robinson’s classic while breathing new life into old lessons. His astounding cast imbues each character with humor, fragility, and a fight that feels meaningful.
As another holiday season approaches, I can’t wait to revisit this gift of a movie reminding us the spirit of Christmas belongs not to any single group, but within hopes we all share for goodness to prevail in this unpredictable world. Maybe its message will become a tradition, inspiring further understanding for years to come.
The Review
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever
With true storytelling magic, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever finds the profound in the simple—reminding us that Christ's message belongs not to an exclusive few but to all seeking lives filled less with division and more connection, mercy, and joy. Dallas Jenkins has outdone even the book's beloved standard with this crowning adaptation, bringing us gifts to warm the heart for seasons to come. Perhaps most of all, it leaves hope that through embracing shared fragilities over differences, faith's tenderest teachings can live as ever in communities both near and far.
PROS
- Heartwarming characters and story with layers of nuance
- Subtle themes of inclusion, faith, and community
- Period setting authentically realized
- Stellar performances, particularly Greer and Schneider
- Balances humor and emotion deftly
- Pays homage while finding new depths in source
- Universally uplifting message of Christmas spirit
CONS
- Some supporting characters are less developed
- Nostalgia may outweigh substance for some
