My Secret Santa joins Netflix’s 2025 slate of holiday romantic comedies with a story that uses a familiar structure and a deliberately strange premise. The film follows Alexandra Breckenridge as Taylor Jacobsen, a single mother determined to support her teenage daughter, Zoey (Madison MacIsaac). In an effort to secure a 50% tuition discount for Zoey’s prestigious snowboarding camp, Taylor accepts the only position still open at the Sun Peaks luxury ski resort: Santa Claus.
This financial pressure drives Taylor to commission extensive prosthetic makeup and assume a male persona named “Hugh Mann.” The deception quickly sets up two central conflicts. One involves the constant risk that someone at the resort might uncover her secret. The other focuses on the unexpected, emotionally charged attraction she develops for her boss, Matthew Layne, played by Ryan Eggold, who happens to be the resort owner’s son. The film builds its romantic and comic tension on this mix of disguise and desire.
The Absurdity as Cinematic Symbolism
The idea of a woman hiding inside a full Santa disguise reads as deliberately exaggerated. The premise, which recalls certain broad tendencies in global commercial cinema, functions as theatrical staging that sets realism aside. The film leans into this quality and treats the absurd setup as a heightened stage for emotional change.
The production team approaches the visual challenge with care, relying on detailed FX makeup that usually sustains the illusion and keeps the transformation from feeling like a cartoon. At times, Taylor’s chosen “Santa voice” pulls focus away from the strength of the physical transformation.
The costume functions as a clear cinematic symbol. Taylor, portrayed as a pragmatic survivor whose daily life revolves around work and her child, discovers that the “Santa” mask gives her unexpected access to the tender worries and insecurities of others. The disguise pushes her toward an inward shift. The film’s core message emerges from this process: she begins to understand the value of letting other people share her burdens and allowing herself a measure of ease. Genuine openness arrives through a performance that looks entirely artificial.
Performance and the Dynamics of Attraction
Alexandra Breckenridge plays Taylor Jacobsen as a hyper-practical parent whose sacrifices for her daughter shape every major decision. Her acting charts Taylor’s movement from a guarded, task-driven figure to someone capable of letting herself be emotionally seen. The commitment she brings to the role, particularly under the layers of prosthetics, gives the story a consistent emotional anchor.
Ryan Eggold appears as Matthew Layne, the designated romantic partner. His easy charm radiates warmth and kindness and makes Matthew an appealing presence on screen. He feels slightly out of step with the idea of an irresponsible trust-fund heir suggested early in the script.
The opposites-attract pattern between Taylor and Matthew comes through clearly, sustained by believable chemistry. Their eventual romantic union feels earned. The conflicts that separate them stay relatively light and the dramatic stakes remain modest. The love story depends heavily on the performances, since the writing around their obstacles feels thin. The supporting cast, including Zoey and several resort staff members, receive minimal development and primarily function as devices that push Taylor’s story forward.
Tonal Shifts and Genre Constraints
The film’s opening act leans heavily on holiday rom-com conventions with a pronounced “cheese factor.” Taylor’s conveniently vanished job at a cookie factory and the sudden introduction of Zoey’s unaffordable camp application both serve as early narrative triggers. This stretch asks the audience for a degree of patience.
The structure maintains a light, airy, and straightforward tone that matches the familiar ninety-minute length associated with this kind of seasonal release. The script relies on well-known ingredients: a struggling single mother, a concealed identity, and the looming exposure of the secret. The comfort of recognition drives much of the viewing experience, and predictability becomes part of the package.
Later sections of the film shift the mood toward something more tender. The narrative settles into a more emotionally sincere register. As Taylor inhabits the Santa role, she starts to resemble a therapeutic presence, offering reassurance and even addressing social tensions among Zoey’s peers.
The story finds emotional weight inside a deliberately silly premise and reveals the film’s quiet appeal. Once the plot moves away from its most generic early beats, it provides a gentle romantic tone and a clear message about the strength that comes from vulnerability, positioning the film as a likely sleeper comfort choice for the holiday season.
My Secret Santa premiered globally on December 3, 2025, and is available to stream exclusively on Netflix. The plot follows Taylor Jacobsen (Alexandra Breckenridge), a single mother who desperately needs a job to afford a prestigious snowboarding camp for her daughter. Driven to extremes, Taylor adopts a full Santa Claus disguise—complete with prosthetics and a fake identity—to secure the position at a luxury ski resort, only to find herself falling for her charming boss, Matthew Layne (Ryan Eggold), which threatens to expose her secret.
Full Credits
Title: My Secret Santa
Distributor: Netflix
Release date: December 3, 2025
Rating: TV-PG
Running time: 92 minutes
Director: Mike Rohl
Writers: Ron Oliver, Carley Smale
Producers and Executive Producers: Howard Braunstein, Alexander Braunstein
Cast: Alexandra Breckenridge, Ryan Eggold, Tia Mowry, Madison MacIsaac, Diana Maria Riva, Dominic Fox
Editors: Daria Ellerman
The Review
My Secret Santa
The film My Secret Santa overcomes its wildly implausible premise by leaning into the comedic potential of the gender-swapping disguise. While the first act struggles with excessive cheesiness and familiar tropes, the movie successfully pivots to explore genuine themes of vulnerability and the importance of connection. Alexandra Breckenridge and Ryan Eggold share an appealing chemistry that elevates the predictable romance. It serves as a warm, functional entry in the holiday genre, finding heart in its essential absurdity.
PROS
- Strong connection between Alexandra Breckenridge and Ryan Eggold.
- Successfully explores the message of vulnerability and letting go.
- The prosthetic work supports the ridiculous premise without descending into caricature.
- The movie improves significantly after the initial setup, becoming genuinely heartfelt.
CONS
- The first act is overly reliant on broad, "cheesy" tropes.
- Ryan Eggold's natural charisma works against the "irresponsible party boy" role.
- The romantic hurdles feel lightweight and lack high stakes.
- Most supporting characters lack significant depth, serving only the main plot.
