“Dreams” emerges as a raw cinematic exploration, revealing the fractures of contemporary life. The film depicts a world where privileged calculations intersect with youthful yearning. Michel Franco’s uncompromising vision crafts a narrative that examines the uncomfortable connection between social structures and the delicate breakdown of human bonds.
The story centers on an American patron and a talented Mexican ballet dancer. Their interaction spans San Francisco’s urban landscape, Mexico City’s complex terrain, and the stark border regions—a space where artistic expression and survival converge.
The narrative explores a relationship defined by contradictions: opulent distance and an intense search for significance. Each scene probes deeper questions about human experience, where longing and disillusionment collide amid social disparities. The fragile connection reveals existential struggles, prompting reflection on ambition’s cost and the erosion of innocence.
Fractured Paths and Shifting Tides
The film begins with a scene so intense that the despair radiates from a truck filled with desperate individuals. Muffled cries and chaotic moments reveal humanity stripped to its essence.
Fernando emerges amid this turmoil, his journey marked by danger and fleeting hope. His path traverses unforgiving landscapes into an indifferent urban expanse—a cityscape mirroring his internal coldness.
Within this intricate story, Jennifer and Fernando’s connection develops through whispered intimacy and explicit power dynamics. Their secret meetings, once hidden in shadows, evolve into stark, unyielding confrontations where control becomes a battleground.
Dimly lit spaces and brief moments of tenderness transform their relationship into a raw exploration of human vulnerability and defiant struggle. The transition from covert interactions to confrontations that shatter cultivated appearances unfolds through scenes alternating between muted longing and brutal openness.
Michel Franco constructs this sequence with sharp precision, his scenes cutting abruptly yet with calculated control. Each segment shifts with a rhythm that builds unavoidable tension. The tempo suggests an inevitable fate, as if every moment propels the characters toward an inescapable climax. The film probes deep questions about human connection, power, and survival in a world offering minimal compassion.
Masks of Power and Fragile Longing
Jennifer McCarthy commands the screen as a complex character—both formidable and deeply vulnerable. Her public persona radiates confidence, a guardian of wealth and social standing. Beneath this polished exterior, internal conflicts simmer.
Her meticulously constructed world of strategic philanthropy and calculated ambition masks a profound struggle with personal identity. Her actions reveal a constant negotiation between family expectations and a raw, unfiltered desire. Each movement suggests an attempt to manage decay or seek genuine connection within a life of manufactured perfection.
Fernando emerges as a portrait of quiet strength. Shaped by ballet’s demanding discipline and immigrant experiences, he navigates between disparate worlds. Cultural displacement weighs heavily on him, etching emotional scars across his being. His stage performance becomes a sanctuary—a delicate expression of inner resilience against societal indifference.
Moments of passionate artistic revelation contrast sharply with his underlying fragility. His transformation from hopeful newcomer to a person trapped between competing identities explores themes of survival and artistic expression.
Peripheral characters deepen the narrative’s complexity. Jennifer’s father and brother represent an entrenched system of privilege, their presence creating a suffocating environment of control. Subtle figures—a silent Mexican waitress, Fernando’s family struggling with systemic challenges—illuminate broader human experiences, revealing unspoken dynamics of power and personal struggle.
Shattered Ideals and Fractured Realities
The film depicts border crossing as a visceral physical challenge and metaphor for human fragmentation. Migrants endure a nightmarish journey, embodying souls pursued by an elusive promise—a dangerous temptation leading to extreme risk.
The supposed dream of transformation reveals itself as a brutal deception, where hope drowns beneath relentless suffering. Invisible geographical boundaries become psychological wounds, separating social classes and cultural experiences.
Jennifer’s privileged world reflects a detached superiority. Her environment of calculated philanthropy conceals deep exploitation. Her connection with Fernando exposes underlying social disparities. Power operates through silent cruelty, each interaction highlighting the distance between wealth and vulnerability. Their relationship critiques a form of assistance that masks self-interest behind charitable gestures—a system where empathy becomes another method of control.
Art and dance create spaces of personal resistance against oppressive structures. Fernando’s stage movements articulate rebellion against societal constraints, functioning as both protest and spiritual expression. His performance radiates against a landscape of exclusion, entangled with the isolation stemming from cultural and linguistic barriers. Through dance, he channels an urgent cry revealing the tension between creative spirit and systemic indifference.
Echoes in Stillness and Shadows
Michel Franco crafts the film with an uncompromising approach that eliminates unnecessary elements, allowing extended, uninterrupted shots to reveal human suffering’s core. His method relies on visual storytelling—where silence and measured rhythm speak more eloquently than words.
Franco’s technique of avoiding explicit explanation forces viewers to interpret the subtle nuances within each frame. Tension grows through the calculated removal of emotional excess, with graphic moments serving as sharp interruptions in a relentless narrative.
Yves Cape’s cinematography complements this austere vision, creating a visual landscape of emotional distance. The film’s visual language reflects characters’ internal emptiness—a world where light and darkness intertwine to express emotions beyond verbal description. Fernando’s ballet sequences capture movement’s beauty against a backdrop of systemic destruction.
Harsh border scenes, bathed in unforgiving light and oppressive silence, intensify feelings of isolation and existential despair. The deliberate absence of traditional music allows ambient sounds to transform each pause and breath into a haunting element of this visual elegy.
Echoes in Quiet Spaces
The film’s sound emerges as a landscape of silence, broken by subtle ambient noises instead of traditional musical accompaniment. Wind rustling and distant urban echoes become a raw emotional language, highlighting the isolation within each character’s internal struggle. Moments of complete quiet intensify the tension where words fail, giving weight to unspoken emotions.
Minimal dialogue connects two distant individuals like delicate strands. The script’s brief interactions carry intense meaning—each line carefully etched to reveal character depths. A graphic sexual exchange strips away social pretenses, exposing the raw dynamics between desire and control.
Production design creates sharp visual contrasts. Luxurious, modern spaces oppose the sun-scorched landscapes surrounding the narrative. Jennifer’s sleek, ordered interiors represent a carefully constructed existence, isolated from external chaos. Mexican border regions and urban spaces present rough textures that speak to unrelenting human struggle, highlighting the constant tension between restraint and personal freedom.
Final Reflections Amidst Shattered Realities
The film’s twin narratives—personal despair intertwined with a stark socio-political critique—hover like specters over every frame. Its narrative of individual loss and systemic decay lingers, evoking an awareness of human suffering that is as intimate as it is institutional.
A quiet desolation permeates the portrayal of those who chase an ideal tainted by the weight of fractured identities and dashed hopes. The interplay among character, theme, and visual execution leaves an indelible mark, inviting contemplation of a world where the promise of renewal is steadily undermined by the realities of power and isolation.
In this dark mosaic, the plight of an immigrant and the sterile grandeur of a privileged existence converge. The film exposes a stark disparity: the tender vulnerability of those forced to risk everything for survival stands in bitter contrast with the calculated coldness of inherited influence. There exists an unsettling tension, as each encounter—a whispered secret or a heated dispute—reveals the relentless pressure of societal expectations and the inescapable pull of personal disillusionment.
The sparse dialogue and the measured cadence of images combine to construct an intricate portrait of an era defined by both beauty and brutality. Every meticulously crafted scene compels the viewer to confront the often hidden interplay between authority and fragility, and the unpredictable cost of ambition. Even as the narrative refrains from offering clear resolutions, it leaves behind a persistent echo of unanswered questions—a quiet challenge to reflect upon the interplay of art, power, and the inherent contradictions of the human condition.
The Review
Dreams
Dreams is a stark portrayal of human disintegration amid a fractured society, balancing personal tragedy with systemic indifference in a relentless meditation on isolation and power. Its restrained narration and piercing imagery unsettle and provoke deep reflection. The film confronts us with the weight of ambition and the cost of privilege, leaving behind a somber echo that lingers long after the credits roll.
PROS
- Striking visual storytelling
- Powerful performances from the leads
- Thought-provoking socio-political critique
- Minimalist direction that amplifies tension
CONS
- Deliberate pacing may test viewer patience
- Sparse dialogue might feel remote
- A persistently bleak tone can be overwhelming
