Mob stories have fascinated the public for decades. The danger, violence, and illicit activities make for dramatic tales of crime families and the charismatic criminals who run them. Few mob bosses capture the imagination quite like John Gotti, head of the powerful Gambino family in New York during the 1980s. Known as the “Dapper Don” for his expensive suits and cocky persona, Gotti became a larger-than-life figure who played the media like a fiddle. He earned the nickname “The Teflon Don” after beating multiple criminal cases during his rise to the top of the mafia.
Gotti’s luck eventually ran out in 1992 when he was convicted of murder and racketeering. But his outlaw celebrity status lived on. The new three-part Netflix docuseries Get Gotti re-examines Gotti’s career as it focuses on how law enforcement finally brought him down after failed attempts. Like many true crime stories today, it’s a cat-and-mouse game between criminals and cops.
Get Gotti has all the elements of a pulpy mob tale – wiretaps, turncoat informants, slick lawyers, and brutal murders, all told in a punchy, fast-paced style. With Gotti’s larger-than-life persona at the center, the series explores how his hunger for fame and brazen public profile ultimately contributed to his undoing.
In this review, we’ll take a close look at Get Gotti to see how successfully it captures the Gotti story and delivers an entertaining slice of mob history. Does it glorify Gotti too much or take a balanced view? Does it have compelling insider interviews and dramatic reenactments? Is this a definitive Gotti doc or just a superficial highlight reel? We’ll examine what the series does well versus where it falls short. If you’re intrigued by the Gotti legend, this review will help determine if Get Gotti is worth your viewing time.
Gotti’s Rise to Fame and the Docuseries Style
John Gotti ruthlessly climbed the ranks of the Gambino crime family in the 1970s and 80s through violence and intimidation. But his path to becoming “boss of all bosses” really began on December 16, 1985, when Gotti orchestrated the very public assassination of then-Gambino head Paul Castellano outside a popular New York steakhouse. Gotti gunned down the “boss” and took over the powerful mafia organization for himself.
Get Gotti captures Gotti’s brazen grab for power and his subsequent hunger for fame and media attention as he led the Gambinos. Gotti was an outsized personality who carefully cultivated his “Dapper Don” image through expensive designer suits and an impeccable hair style. He courted publicity and actively stoked his celebrity status. Tabloids and TV news obliged, turning the ruthless killer into a cultural phenomenon. Gotti came to embody the glamorized mobster lifestyle.
The docuseries style mirrors Gotti’s flashy presence. Get Gotti uses dramatic, stylized reenactments of events like the Castellano murder scene. The recreations have a cinematic, neon-lit look as we see Gotti’s thugs blast their boss away on a busy street. Integrated surveillance footage and wiretap audio bring viewers directly into Gotti’s conversations and clandestine activities. Slick editing moves the story along rapidly through interviews, archival news clips, and ubiquitous images of Gotti posing for cameras.
Nicknamed the “Teflon Don,” Gotti notoriously beat federal rap after federal rap in the late 1980s, in part by intimidating witnesses and rigging juries. But the law was gathering evidence against him too – reams of wiretaps and insider testimony. We see the FBI and other agencies hidden mics and cameras capturing Gotti’s conversations. The damning tapes expose his criminality behind the flashy public image.
Get Gotti’s style effectively merges different media forms to vividly capture both Gotti’s celebrified rise and the meticulous legal campaign to prosecute him. The visuals mirror the duplicity – Gotti’s glitzy lifestyle paraded in public versus the ugly mob violence happening in secret. The storytelling style helps explain how Gotti reached such heights and evaded justice for so long before the law finally stuck.
- Also Read: Bodies Review: A Puzzle Spanning Centuries
The Uphill Battle to Prosecute the “Teflon Don”
In the 1980s, various law enforcement agencies were all gunning to take down the powerful mob boss John Gotti and the Gambino crime family. But Gotti didn’t earn the nickname “Teflon Don” for nothing. Early efforts to prosecute him were stymied in large part because the agencies pursuing Gotti didn’t cooperate well and struggled to build solid cases.
Get Gotti details the complicated effort to prosecute Gotti led by the FBI, Department of Justice, and the Organized Crime Task Force. Their reluctance to share information and witnesses allowed Gotti to exploit seams between the organizations. With agencies territorial and determined to score the big win, Gotti benefited from their fractured approach in his first trials.
Gathering convincing evidence was also extremely difficult. Wiretaps of Gotti’s home and hangouts required elaborate surveillance efforts to plant bugs. But the cryptic mafia conversations yielded little hard evidence. When informants were flipped and put on the stand, Gotti’s lawyers easily shredded their credibility. Intimidation of witnesses was rampant, leading to “convenient” memory loss when testifying against the ruthless crime boss.
For example, when a bystander came forward who Gotti had assaulted, the man comically claimed in court he suddenly couldn’t remember details of the attack. The headline “I FORGOTTI” typified the struggle to make charges stick against the menacing mafioso.
Time and again, prosecutors would labor intensely building a case, only to see it crumble in the courtroom. Gotti also had the savvy and funds to hire excellent attorneys who muddied the waters. The agencies vying to nail Gotti began to look hapless and ineffectual.
But their work trying to amass evidence against the mob boss continued in an ever more coordinated fashion. Wiretaps were run 24/7, informants were leveraged, and relentless pressure was applied to Gotti’s organization. Investigators had to get creative and opportunistic to slowly gather material that might eventually convict the man who had become something of a national folk antihero after his repeated courtroom victories.
Get Gotti captures the frustrating and painstaking efforts required just to gain an inch against Gotti. He was an expert at staying ahead of the law and winning sympathies from the public and juries. But slowly, inexorably, the attempts to prosecute Gotti built toward what investigators hoped would be the final, successful trial.
Gotti’s Courtroom Drama and Celebrity Rise
In the late 1980s, John Gotti beat the rap three times in high-profile federal prosecutions. Get Gotti takes us behind the scenes of these trials showing how Gotti outmaneuvered the justice system and grew his fame.
Gotti’s first acquittal came in the prosecution of an assault against a refrigerator repairman, Romual Piecyk. Gotti had attacked the man in a traffic altercation. With eyewitnesses and a victim ready to testify, a conviction seemed straightforward. But in court, Piecyk claimed to have mysteriously forgotten details of the assault against him, leading to Gotti walking free. The absurd testimony led to the famous newspaper headline “I Forgotti.”
Gotti had intimidated Piecyk into botching his account, undermining the prosecution’s case. The brazen courtroom victory only enhanced Gotti’s reputation and air of invincibility. He gained notoriety for his ability to “beat the system.”
Next, federal prosecutors levied an array of charges against Gotti including murder, illegal gambling, racketeering and more. At trial, the prosecution relied on recorded conversations and informants testifying against Gotti. But Gotti’s attorney, Bruce Cutler, was able to undermine the credibility of every witness. With the prosecution’s case built on shaky witness testimony, Gotti again won an acquittal, further emboldening his criminal empire.
Cutler also successfully argued that Gotti was being selectively prosecuted by law enforcement with an axe to grind. This resonated with everyday people who saw Gotti as flashy but relatable. His legal victories over the government only amplified his folk hero celebrity status.
The third trial involved charges Gotti ordered an assault against a carpenters’ union official John O’Connor. Again Cutler was able to sow reasonable doubt by questioning the reliability of witnesses. Gotti walked, cementing his reputation as “The Teflon Don” in the media.
But behind the scenes, investigators were gathering reams of evidence from wiretaps, informants and surveillance. They recorded Gotti implicating himself directly in crimes and planning hits. The loose-lipped mob boss didn’t realize the extent to which authorities could hear his conversations.
Prosecutors also finally had Gotti’s right-hand man Sammy “The Bull” Gravano agree to testify. With irrefutable tapes and an unimpeachable insider witness, the state had the tools needed to finally convict Gotti after his long run of courtroom victories. The fourth trial for the Teflon Don would prove very different from the first three.
The Teflon Finally Wears Off
After years of frustration, law enforcement finally compiled the evidence needed to convict John Gotti in his fourth federal trial in 1992. Critical to their success was extensive wiretap evidence that caught Gotti implicating himself on tape, and the cooperation of Gotti’s trusted lieutenant Sammy “The Bull” Gravano.
Investigators had long suspected Gotti’s tendency to brag about his criminal exploits if you got him comfortable and conversing freely. So the FBI and other agencies bugged the Bergin Hunt and Fish Club frequented by Gotti and his crew. They also set up video surveillance across the street. Finally, the patient monitoring paid off, capturing Gotti directly discussing past murders, ongoing schemes, and more.
Gone was Gotti’s ability to hide behind vague language and coded conversations. He openly talked business, names, crimes – firm evidence that would be hard for even the savvy Bruce Cutler to refute. The prosecution finally had Gotti definitively implicating himself in a litany of offenses.
And they finally had someone beyond lower-level turncoats to testify against the intimidating boss – his right-hand man Gravano. Facing his own legal liability, Gravano made the deal to tell all on the witness stand. As Gotti’s trusted insider, his testimony carried immense weight – difficult for the defense to undermine.
Armed with Gravano’s insider accounts and Gotti’s own words caught on tape, prosecutors had assembled an ironclad case. During the trial, the jury heard Gotti directly ordering murders, assault, bribery, gambling operations, and other mob crimes. The vulgar, expletive-laced tapes stood in stark contrast to Gotti’s polished “Dapper Don” image.
On April 2, 1992 after only 14 hours of deliberation, the jury convicted Gotti on all 13 counts including racketeering, murder, and conspiracy charges. The Teflon Don was finally heading to jail after his years outmaneuvering prosecutors. Without rigged juries and intimidated witnesses, Gotti was unable to escape justice this time.
The fourth trial conviction brought down the curtain on Gotti’s reign as head of the Gambino family. Law enforcement officials had finally penetrated the legal shield of America’s most infamous mobster through meticulous evidence gathering and convincing testimony. The legal saga showed that while Gotti was slick, he was not invincible when faced with determined prosecution.
Wrapping Up the Gotti Story
The new Netflix docuseries Get Gotti delivers a sensational retelling of John Gotti’s rise and fall as head of the Gambino crime family. While not a perfect production, it succeeds in vividly capturing key aspects of Gotti’s infamous career for those unfamiliar with the historic case.
Centering on how investigators finally brought Gotti to justice after years of courtroom victories, the series provides insider views of both Gotti’s organization and law enforcement’s efforts. The storytelling style effectively merges reenactments, surveillance footage, and interviews to detail Gotti’s brazen public persona and clandestine criminality.
Get Gotti is at its best humanizing the long, frustrating road to prosecution faced by officials determined to end Gotti’s Teflon-like ability to avoid convictions. It illuminates the meticulous work required to assemble a bulletproof case against a celebrity gangster expert at rigging the system. The series also excels at exposing Gotti’s hubris in secretly implicating himself extensively on wiretaps, leading to damning evidence once decrypted.
While not definitive, Get Gotti succeeds as a reasonably compelling overview of this notorious mobster. For those unfamiliar with Gotti’s legacy, it provides intriguing insight into both the inner workings of organized crime and the legal war needed to prosecute a glorified crime boss. The docuseries is a worthwhile watch for true crime fans fascinated by the Gotti legend.
While falling short of definitive, Get Gotti succeeds as a slick and reasonably captivating overview of John Gotti's rise and fall. The docuseries excels most in chronicling law enforcement's dogged pursuit of the celebrity mobster, though Gotti himself remains a superficial figure. For newcomers to the saga, Get Gotti entertains while exposing both the inner workings of organized crime and the murky quest for justice against a glorified gangster. It doesn't fully pierce the Gotti legend, but provides enough intriguing history and dramatic flair to warrant a watch for true crime devotees.
- Fast-paced and slick editing keeps the storyline moving
- Archival footage and surveillance tapes effectively integrated
- Reenactments provide dramatic visualization of events
- Insider interviews offer fascinating firsthand accounts
- Chronicling of prosecution efforts is compelling and detailed
- Exposes Gotti's hubris and criminality behind public image
- Entertaining for those unfamiliar with Gotti's story
- Gotti himself remains a superficial, one-dimensional figure
- At times sensationalizes and glamorizes Gotti and mob lifestyle
- No definitive critical portrait of Gotti emerges
- Interviews with law enforcement more insightful than mobsters
- Could have delved deeper into contextual themes
- Production quality inconsistent between episodes
- Never fully pierces the larger-than-life Gotti legend