Damian McCarthy’s Oddity, already marks the director’s follow up to his equally chilling feature debut Caveat from 2021. Like its predecessor, Oddity orbits around a grisly murder investigation that gives way to haunting supernatural revelations. At the center of it all is Carolyn Bracken, who gives a tour de force dual performance as murdered woman Dani and her twin sister Darcy, a spiritually-inclined psychic determined to uncover the truth.
We’re dropped into Oddity’s premise with minimal context. A woman named Dani is home alone in a remote Irish house undergoing renovations when she accepts a fateful knock at the door. Soon after, she’s dead – but by whose hand remains a mystery. Then the story jumps ahead a year where Dani’s husband Ted, played solidly by Gwilym Lee, is trying to move on with a new partner while Darcy remains convinced foul play is at foot. With her gift of a massive wooden mannequin in tow, Darcy inserts herself back into her sister’s abandoned home determined to stir its secrets to the surface.
What follows is a chilling game of cat and mouse as Darcy’s persistence antagonizes Ted and unnerves his girlfriend Yana, played with ice by Caroline Menton. McCarthy strings the audience along with his signature unpredictable pacing and shifting realities. Through it all, Bracken anchors the movie with a powerhouse performance that commandeers every scene. Like its predecessor, Oddity thrives on crafting an unsettling atmosphere through strong performances and keeping viewers constantly off-kilter and searching for answers within its nightmarish confines.
The Wooden Guest
The film opens with a nerve-wracking scenario. Dani finds herself alone in her rural home, in the process of renovations. When a knock sounds at the door, a distressed man stands outside. Olin Boole is missing an eye and claims to have seen an intruder enter while Dani was distracted. He insists on coming inside to protect her, though his presence is unsettling. Dani must make an impossible choice that sets dramatic events in motion.
We later learn that Dani met a gruesome fate that night, though the details remain unclear. It’s here that the stories of the film’s fascinating characters begin to fold together. Dani leaves behind her twin sister Darcy, who runs an oddities shop. She also leaves her husband Ted, a doctor who now lives in the home with his colleague Yana.
Ted strives to move on, but Darcy is not ready to accept her sister’s death at face value. A psychic gifted with perceptions beyond the senses, Darcy brings an unusual gift to the home – a towering wooden man. Her arrival plunges Yana into an uncomfortable situation, and reopens old wounds for Ted. Both dread having Darcy nearby as she pursues the truth.
The narrative skillfully skips back and forth in time. We learn just enough about that fateful night to tantalize, but key details are withheld to maintain suspense. This structure reflects Darcy’s gradual peeling back of layers in her psychic investigation. It keeps viewers as unsettled as the characters, eager to learn what really happened in the home where an unwanted guest of wood now dwells.
Illuminating Unease
There’s an aura of impending dread that hangs heavy over Oddity, and writer-director Damian McCarthy navigates it with a deft creative touch. He eschews cheap jump scares in favor of a more unsettled feeling, slowly ratcheting up the tension until your nerves are frayed.
McCarthy plays with light and shadow masterfully. He understands that what you can’t see is far scarier than anything revealed. Dark corners and stretches of black become places where your imagination runs wild. Even the score, composed by Richard G. Mitchell, seems to seep from the shadows with an eerie sense of foreboding. The ominous sound design by Aza Hand enhances every subtle creep.
Shot by Colm Hogan, Oddity also benefits tremendously from its isolated rural setting. Scenes confinement within the sprawling but empty house heighten the creeping sensations of vulnerability. Characters feel exposed in the vast unfamiliar rooms and long-empty halls, leaving audiences unsettled alongside them.
McCarthy’s directing never relents, keeping viewers constantly teetering on the edge of their seats as unease blossoms into outright disquiet. But it’s his restraint that proves most effective – less is truly more when it comes to wielding fear. Oddity gets under your skin with sparse intricacy rather than explosive thrills. In McCarthy’s capable hands, dread becomes a smoldering slow-burn that lingers long after the final frame.
Twin Tales
Carolyn Bracken gives a tour de force performance in Oddity, playing not one but two pivotal roles. Her portrayals of Dani and Darcy could not be more distinct, yet she ensures a subtle thread remains between the twin sisters. As the free-spirited Dani, Bracken radiates warmth and positivity. Then as Darcy, her energy harnesses a grittier intensity, driven to uncover the truth surrounding Dani’s death.
Bracken commands the screen with multifaceted finesse as Darcy. She’s prickly yet perceptive, tough yet vulnerable. Despite being blind, Darcy navigates her world with steadfast poise. Bracken lends her an indomitable spirit and inner fire that makes her the film’s most captivating character to follow. It’s a testament to her talent that within just under two hours, she wholly develops these two richly realized women.
Taking on the stoic role of grieving widower Ted, Gwilym Lee brings nuanced layers. On the surface Ted appears coldly detached, but Lee shrewdly hints at turmoil bubbling below. He makes Ted’s guarded nature feel both emotionally closed-off yet psychologically fraught.
Tadhg Murphy also affects an unsettling presence as suspect Olin Boole. Even in limited screen time, Murphy’s uncanny intensity lingers long after as the possible dark hand behind it all. Supporting cast including Steve Wall further bolster the unsettled atmosphere.
Together this standout ensemble ensures Oddity remains an ever-unraveling psychological mystery. Under McCarthy’s guidance, they immerse us in the film’s chilling folds with nuanced skill, keeping viewers constantly on edge.
The Strange Power of the Wooden Man
At the center of Oddity lies an unsettling figure unlike any other – a towering wooden man brought into the home by blind psychic Darcy. With its elongated limbs and forever open-mouthed scream, it’s a discomforting sight. Yet beyond its grotesque appearance, the man carries deeper significance.
We learn it once belonged to Darcy and Dani’s mother, a supposed witch who crafted the man herself. Plugged with keepsakes in its head holes, it represents the holding of secrets and unseen forces. From the moment Yana prods her hand inside its jaws, a chill hangs in the air. Is this object just a prop, or something more?
As the night wears on, the man takes on a life of its own. When alone, Yana feels it shift and turn to watch her, its empty eyes following wherever she goes. By the time Ted returns, it looms ominously at the dining table in a position it wasn’t left. Darcy remains coy on its powers but seems to draw from it, initiating a séance that unleashes unearthly mayhem.
Through suspenseful scenes and subtle shifts, the wooden man metamorphoses from art to antagonist, blurring the lines between reality and the realm beyond. By the climax, its presence has come to signify all glimpsed in the shadows of the house – a conduit for the vengeful spirit pursuing truths left buried with Dani.
More than a mere prop, the enigmatic man exists as a symbol of Oddity’s deepest mysteries. In its grotesque body holds the film’s chilling atmosphere and supernatural forces challenging our perception of reality.
The Wicked Gift
Darcy arrives unexpectedly at Ted’s house bearing an ominous wooden mannequin from her mother’s collection of oddities. Ted has little patience for Darcy’s spiritualist views, which conflict with his scientific outlook as a doctor. He soon departs for work, leaving Yana alone with Darcy.
Alone together, tensions rise between the women. Yana grows increasingly uneasy as strange noises fill the empty home. Her curiosity gets the better of her when investigating the large wooden figure packed away in the trunk. What begins as a taunt turns terrifying as its hidden contents are revealed.
Later, Darcy confronts Ted with new revelations that cast doubt on his account of the events. She insists the man responsible for Dani’s death is not all he seems. Their heated exchange brings lingering questions to the surface.
Just when it seems the truth will remain buried, the film surprises with a shocking final scene. In a chilling finale, the story comes full circle as a new perpetrator is exposed. McCarthy delights with this twist, tying together loose ends in classic horror style while blending slasher, supernatural and psychological thriller genres. Overall, Oddity draws power from the path less travelled, upending expectations at every turn for an ending that is as unforgettable as it is unanticipated.
The Wooden Man Cometh
Damian McCarthy takes his audience on a disturbing ride with Oddity. At its heart is a large wooden mannequin gifted by Darcy – an object shrouded in mystery that seems to hold psychic significance. As the tensions rise in the remote house and Yana engages with this eerie figure alone, it’s as if the mannequin slowly comes to life.
McCarthy works his magic by withholding important plot details and manipulating timelines. This keeps viewers tightly wound throughout, always leaning forward to soak up new clues. Though some twists are foreseeable, it’s a twisty tour worth taking for McCarthy’s unsettling atmosphere and tight performances. Special props to Carolyn Bracken for seamlessly slipping between the kind Dani and fiercer Darcy with flair.
By film’s end, the true fate of Dani is revealed and her spirit finds justice. Yet that wooden man still looms large in memory, as does McCarthy’s visionary style. He proves again to be a director unafraid to take horror to creepy places in fresh yet enjoyable ways.
For fans of the strange and supernatural, Oddity is worth your time to experience its unrelenting strangeness. Just keep the lights on after – you never know when that wooden man may come knocking!
The Review
Oddity
Damian McCarthy delivers another layered, unnerving puzzle box of a film with Oddity. Despite some predictable beats, McCarthy sustains a palpable sense of dread throughout with his exceptional use of atmosphere and unsettling wooden centerpiece. Carolyn Bracken anchors the movie with a powerhouse dual performance, while the tight narrative keeps viewers on edge till the chilling conclusion. Oddity proves McCarthy continues to evolve as a filmmaker tackling horror in delightfully bizarre ways.
PROS
- Visual storytelling elevates scary moments
- Taut narrative that steadily builds terror
- Standout performances from Carolyn Bracken and cast
- Creative mix of horror genres employed effectively
- Lengthy payoff for answers to Dani's murder
CONS
- Some plot points foreseeable
- Supporting characters less developed
- Explanations of the wooden man's origins lacking
